How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Bart Goldberg
I just purchased a cast iron router table top, and after starting to set it up, discovered that it was badly out of flat (by about a 1/16" from front to back). The company I purchased it from is shipping me a new table, but cause the shipping is so high, they said to keep the defective table. So. I'm wondering if its worth taking to a local machine shop to have them flatten it. Any one know what a 2 ft by 3 ft slab of cast iron would cost to have flattened?
Thanks
Bart
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
John McGaw
Out of curiosity, it is "out of flat" with reference to what? Do you mean that there is a slope relative to the router mounting area or is there cupping or twisting relative to some arbitrary plane? The amount and type of machining require to correct the problem will be largely dependent upon the type of defect; if the table is a decent plane and the mounting area is not coplanar then just a bit of a touchup might do the job. A machinist acquaintance in Alaska told me that there are heat treating / annealing processes that can relax and de-stress cast iron and they are critical to obtaining stable results.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
I had a table that was out. I bought it used so there wasn't a warranty. I clamped it down to a table top with the high end loose. Then I propped a 2x4 against the ceiling and put a hydraulic jack under it. I pried the table corner down and measured it. Released the jack and measured how far it sprung back. Took me about 4 tries but I got the table flattened close enough for what I needed it for.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
You would want to have it lapped or surface ground, I checked on it once for a wing of a table saw I had gotten for $10 used. They wanted an hourly rate and said it would take 3 hours to set up and grind but would be within .0001 I think the hourly rate was $110.00
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Bart, If you really want a stable flat table, first set the bad top outside (lean it against your shop wall where the sun hits it during part of the day). Leave it there for a year or so, through winter etc.. This used to be done by all the major machine tool manufacturers. Then find a shop with a Blanchard grinder, they may charge as much as a new table will cost, but you will have one of the most stable flat tables in USA. Today, most people are short cutting the process of stabilizing the cast tables and ways, they shot peen them, do some temperature cycling and then machine them - then the parts do move some later. As an Engineer that used to build and buy automated equipment, I have seen many cast parts laying outside large machine builders, that is one of the criteria I used to choose the best builders. Once the parts have had the surfaces heated by the sun (and the dark side cool), ran through many cycles of cool rain on them in the hot summer, and had the sun heat one side in the cold spring and fall the cast really becomes stable.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
Why do you need to flatten it at all for a WW machine? It is not a "reference" surface. The only thing that matters is that the stock doesn't rock or move as it passes by the cutter and that the cutter is perpendicular to the plate if you have one or the surrounding area if you don't. Otherwise it just doesn't matter.
I just don't understand the OCD desire to have spot flat tables. Depressions just don't matter- no different than having an old open grid extension table.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
If a router table is high on an outside edge, and you are running a longer piece across the table your depth of cut will vary. When the work is supported by the "high area" the depth will be less - then as it falls off the high spot the depth of cut will increase. If the center is higher the part will "rock" as as you apply pressure at different points the depth will again vary. Maybe it doesn't matter to you but when I am cutting a bead - with a 1/16" variation in the table you could easily get 1/32 variation in depth - that would be very visible in much of my work. With my skill set, I certainly want to remove as many variations as I can. I have enough issues with my skill to not introduce preventable errors.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Dale Lenz
Agree, my router table was maybe an 1/8" high in the center. Gave me fitts for years. Finially broke down and rebuilt the thing a few months ago. Have not use it much since the rebuild, but it should make my woodworking life more enjoyable.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Chuck in mtl.
larry,
I have heard of them doing this with freshly cast engine blocks...sit outside in the hot and cold and with time the cast iron stabilizes as the internal stresses work themselves out. Lee Valley do a similar thing, they heat a batch of cast planes up to a high temperature for 24 hours and then slowly let them cool off for a week or so.
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
OP didn't say where it wasn't flat (or even how he measured it). Without knowing the specifics all of this is just conjecture . . . . it depends. For instance if one corner or one edge is low and the remainder of the top is flat, what does it matter?
Re: How much $ to flatten a cast iron router table top