Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Roofing from a sidewall

Posts

Roofing from a sidewall

#1

Roofing from a sidewall

TomD

My lower shop roof is about a 4/12 and 20 feet long, it butts up against a sidewall to the second story shop. My previous jobs have all been on roofs where the shingles were laid out from the roof middle and the excess could be cut straight at either eave. Seems as though in this situation one would lay the roof out from the sidewall, if so what is the pattern for doing so, The roof is about 17 exposures high, and I don't want to end up with a lot of small shingle segments. Obviously I will need to step flash the sidewall joint which will add to the necessity of having enough shingle segments at the joint to be able to get a smooth lay and nail - I don't see nailing a 6 inch shingle down over a piece of 6 inch flashing and getting a smooth transition.

Seems like the books I have, and searches I have made either show just the flashing details, or they show cedar shingling sidewalls. They don't show how to index asphalt shingles. Makes me think the answer is to just index off a centerline, but it would be nice to know.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#2

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

For asphalt singles I always index on one side, never the middle. I start with a full single and on the next course I start with 2/3 of a single and the next course gets the cut off 1/3 for the start. When ending I trim the next to last single on a course to avoid having a 6"single. I also run a bead of Henrys tar about an inch back from the edge under the first and last single in each course a well as under the leading edge of the entire first course.

Robin

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#3

Re: And it gets more interesting..

TomD

So I went out to see how many tabs there are on mine. None. I guess that is just a mater of looking on the company website to see how they are handled. The package has a lot of info on it, but it is mainly unreadable.

Thanks for your thoughts. I would prefer to start this job off on the left edge since that would make matters easier. Just for anyone who is wondering, I think there are several reasons for starting in the middle. One is that the shingle job is then centerred and symmetrical at the edges. Another is that one can snap the layout lines over a shorter distance, or at least register them from a central layout, which could reduce sagging. One problem with this method is that one is trimming off both edges, which is more work, more waste, and if one doesn't trim so well it is more wiggles.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#4

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I agree: work from the wall. The sidewall detail is the most likely place to have problems in future, so it's the place where you want the most control over your materials.

Speaking of which: when we did the back roof on our house, which involved step shingles in several spots, we bought them from a certain big boxy store whose signature color is orange. They're not terribly high quality (surprise!). Go to a roofing supply house.

You mention chalklines for layout. If you're hand-nailing these shingles, consider a gauging shingling hatchet if you don't already have one. We did a single layout line and gauged from that line using the shingling hatchets (even though we were nailing, mostly, with a roofing nailer), using the gauging hatchets. The courses look dead straight all the way up.

Bill, no kind of roofing expert, but I've done a few.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#5

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

Barry Irby

Tom, I am having trouble with your question. Does the end of the roof butt into the wall (where there would be a Rake?) or is it the top where there would be a ridge? If you are talking about a left or right end where you would need step flashing and the other end is a rake, there are a couple of things to consider. If you start at the side wall you want to be sure your tabs will mess nicely with the step flashing, no pieces shorter than the flashing and at the same time you want to consider the other end, the rake where you don't want any tiny slivers of a tab left either. A tab less than about two inches wide on the rake or open end will ten to dangle over the end later. Sometimes it is necessary to cheat a little to get both ends to work out right. You might have to space each shingle open about and 1/8" to "pick up" a little length or you might have to trim some of them down a bit to close the spacing.

If you are running into a wall at the top or you find the roof does not have paralleled edges top and bottom you can use your tape to cheat a bit there as well. Lets say you find out one end is 145" 'tall' (29 courses at 5" each) but the other end is 143". Rather than run 5" course all the way and have one at the top that tapers from five inches to three inches, Angle the tape on the 143" end until it reads 145" and the courses will all appear to be five inches, but in fact will taper from 5" to 4.93"=/-. You need to start this after you have set out the starter course and the first course.

Where are you and are you considering Ice and water shield?

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Read the directions...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

If you want any chance of the manufacturer honoring the warranty should problems arise, read and follow the directions. They'll have instructions for the proper offsets of the courses. This also has the benefit of helping keep nails in one shingle out from beneath the butt joints in the course above (a potential leak). Nails that do happen to fall within 3" of a butt joint in the course above should have butyl caulk smeared over the head. It doesn't matter if you have a 6" wide piece over the step flashing, provided you get the nails in the correct place (outer top corner of the step flashing, through the two shingles beneath).

Also, make sure you nail where the manufacturer recommends, typically BELOW the printed line or tar line. It doesn't seem to make sense because that puts the nail below the sealing tar, but it's not about sealing, it's about catching enough of the shingle beneath with the nail for proper holding power.

If you can't read any of the shingle packages, the instructions should be available online for your specific shingle brand and model.

Jason, no expert, but have done several roofs, and picked the brains of several pros.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#7

Re: Simple question

TomD

But maybe not the way I asked it. I really just meant if I start with a full shingle at the wall, and flash it, then what happens on the next course and so forth. I did notice that the shingles I am using don't have tabs, they are the 3D type. And the pattern is not the same shingle to shingle. So there is that to figure out. I have done a few roofs, maybe about 6 or 7, I have a few books, and I have the roof to look at... I have found that while this situation is pretty common, and while books go into detail like flashing, they don't discuss the shingle layout from sidewalls.

On Ice and water shield, I am pretty strapped at the moment, and won't be springing for that. Technically I probably need something like that due to my pitch being borderline, and if I see any indication of water damage I might have to do something about it. I probably won't even tar paper it. The roof is low enough and faces into severe weather, but it has never given any trouble, and the roofing it in horrible condition, so I am doubtful I will have much trouble when I simply cover it. I find that while all the clever techniques have their place, nothing succeeds like being lucky. Some buildings or details will give terrible trouble and others will last 300 years. When doing pro work one can't tolerate a call back. In my case I can't tolerate water pouring down on my south bend heavy 10. But I think I am in the clear.

As far as guarantees are concerned, I self-insure. This roof will cost me a few hundred, and I am not even sure if the guarantees apply to home work. They require many products to be used in concert and specifically installed.

I agree about the hatchet. I have one and find it very useful. Last roofing job, I found the price of a roofing nailer had come down so low that I could afford one for the occasional work I do. Plus I am getting a little older every new job that comes up, and probably as a result of... Plus for hacks, it is always a rush to get the roof off, fix any problems, and get it on again, all in a few hours, so this thing will save my bacon some day. Also, I was worried about how durable it would be, till I dropped it off the roof onto the concrete walk below.

I broke an ankle about 15 years ago, and I am not very steady on roofs any more. Luckily I learned rock climbing from a book starting in 1972, and I still have all the gear. I intend to be safe up there.

Thanks for all the help so far.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#8

Re: Simple question

Barry Irby

Tom, With architectural shingles the side to side spacing is not terribly critical. Since there are no tabs, the spacing at the sidewall does not matter much. Just don't set them up to have a little sliver there that is narrower than the flashing. Same thing on the outside end.

The nailing is another issue. What ever pattern you use, be sure you don't have nails within about two inches of a end joint. Also, look at the end of the shingle and notice that the part that has the "teeth" is full width with the teeth cut out and the under course is solid, but less than half the width of the shingle. The lap at the top of the teeth is only about an inch. The instructions are that you nail through both layer. Some shingles have a nailing line "printed" on them. They put a line of lighter colored granules on them where they want the nails. They want your nails to actually penetrate the line. If they are more than about a quarter inch low the heads will be exposed. If they are slightly high, the nails will miss the bottom layer and may punch through the shingle, particularly if the nails are right next to the "step". This is a terrible problem for the industry. Nobody wants the nails too low and exposed, and the pro's want to go really fast and nail well above the line. So, as well as having to space them correctly left to right, you also need to pay attention to up and down. My roofing nailer has a stop on the shoe that you can set to get the up and down part exactly right.

Most of the shingle now seem to be Metric. (There, I said it. No one in the industry will admit it, but they are 39"+ by 13"+. Suspiciously like a meter by a third of a meter. HMMM?) They call for a vertical spacing of 5 5/8". Much more tedious to set up that the old 5" spacing. The last roof I did, I used 5" anyway.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#9

Re: Simple question

Grant in Iowa

Barry is right on the money here. You are describing Architectural style shingles. I have done about 15 roofs with this type of shingle and now much prefer them over 3 tabs. I worked under a pro roofer as an assistant during busy times here in Iowa. Now is a good time to say that roofing techniques vary slightly regionally, due to prevailing weather conditions and construction techniques.

Here's how we start:

Drip edge goes on the bottom edge of the roof first. Ice barrier for the bottom course and in any valleys overlapping this drip edge. On some known problem roofs, we do ice shield over the whole thing. Tar paper above the first course of Ice barrier. Take the time to get the lines straight on your tar paper as they will serve as a "sanity check" guide as you go up the roof to keeping them straight. Drip edge goes over the tar paper on the pitched edges. Next, a starter coarse, which is a continuous roll of self adhesive material designed to protect the roof from the gaps in the following coarse. You might think you are saving a buck by omitting this material, but it is cheaper than a second course of shingles you would otherwise use.

Now, Install a full shingle in the lower left corner of the roof, its lower edge flush or slightly overhanging the starter strip. Next comes a 2/3 shingle above that, a half shingle above that, then a 1/3 shingle above that. Go back to the bottom and to the right of the first full shingle and install a full shingle to its right, then a full shingle to the right of each partial shingle listed above. Now place a full shingle above the 1/3 shingle, then another 2/3, a 1/2, and another 1/3. Doing it this way prevents excessing walking on the shingles, which is hard on them. It is also MUCH faster than running 1 course all the way across like a typewriter. We will often set up a scaffold and do the bottom 5 or so courses from the scaffold. This is easier and safer than trying to stand upside down next to the edge of the roof.

Periodically check your straightness by either sighting from and end or by comparing the top row of shingles to the tar paper lines. Any errors should be gradually worked out over several courses so as to show minimally.

As I read your question, this should answer it. Don't forget to step flash as you go if you have a vertical wall on the left. I like the Henry's bead near the right edge of each piece of flashing, though I have seen many roofs without any that worked fine. Can't hurt, that is for sure.

Run your air nailer hose up over the peak of the roof, then back to yourself so you don't have to hold the weight of the hose as you go.

To your question of the far end of the roof and how to end shingles, what we usually do is shingle to where a single piece will cover the remainder, measure the gap and cut a shingle (usually a guy designated as shingle cutter does this on the ground and "Frisbees" it up to us.), and install that shingle. If the end shingle would be less than about ten inches in length, we actually install the short piece a shingle away from the end so it won't blow off in a storm. An if it is shorter than about 6 inches, we will usually avoid using a narrow shingle by using a couple offcuts from previous courses instead of a full to make up the difference. You can usually do it in two pieces. This all disappears in the finished roof, and so long as you avoid lining up the ends of two successive courses above each other, you will be fine in terms of weather proofing. The shingle cutter is also in charge of always cutting what he needs from the shortest possible remaining piece of scrap to save materials. Done right, a roof can be completed with an arm load of small pieces remaining.

Wear sneakers on the roof to avoid damaging the shingles with hard edged boots. Easier to bend over too.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#10

Re: Simple question

Tom

Thanks. I know what you mean on spacing, particularly patching in, I have sometimes found I could barely get it done.

Re: Roofing from a sidewall

#11

Re: Simple question

Tom

Thanks Grant. I am getting too old for this. Though I have to say my mom helped me with two recent roofs when she was in her upper 70s. :)