Strength of wood.
Dale Lenz
From the recent tornado in Moore, OK. Gotta be a shard from a telephone phone, pretty amazing to me! Makes me think twice about above ground "safe room".
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Strength of wood.
Dale Lenz
From the recent tornado in Moore, OK. Gotta be a shard from a telephone phone, pretty amazing to me! Makes me think twice about above ground "safe room".
UFFDA!!
Re: Strength of wood.
Dick Coers
I was surprised on many trees had the bark stripped off. Saw one tree on tv that had no bark anywhere, even on the branches that held on.
Re: Strength of wood.
Keith Newton
Dale, that is intriguing, but I'm always a bit suspicious of these things. I wish I could see the close end of that wood, to see if it was mushroomed in a way that one would expect if it came in from the other side. I can't imagine that that sharp end did the penetrating without getting a mushroom cap.
Yet, even if the large unseen end to the left was the way it came through, I would have expected the concrete to have blown out on the side toward us with somewhat of a Hertzian cone, instead of the tight fitting edges, and those two loose pieces on top, which should be almost to Kansas by now. Well, at least I would have expected them to have been picked up along with everything else in that 200 mph wind.
I just think there is something else missing from the photo that we may never know. Like,,,,,,, There are lots of metal fittings bolted onto wooden utility poles, which could have made the initial impact, and blown through. The front part of a long wooden projectile gets slowed, and the shaft explodes in the middle, from the inertial of the following end, then the front parts get taken away, leaving the fairly sharp end that we can see.
I am only speculating of course, maybe physics changes at those speeds, but I doubt it. We just hear all these phenomenal things like pine needles buried half their length in an Oak tree for example. Well, I have done some cleaning up after a few tornadoes, and the trees that don't get torn out of the Earth, get bent and twisted, that what remains upright, is full of fractures which would open under extreme rotational forces. It is not hart to imagine how any air-born needles or leaves for that mater, would get stuck in the closing crevasses when it regained its memory shape.
Thanks for sharing the photo. I may be all wrong in making any assumptions, with nothing more to go on than that pic, but I find it fun to try to figure these things out. Maybe someone else can come up with a better explanation, and I would love to hear them. That is just my 2¢.
Re: Strength of wood.
Keith Newton
Dick, It is Springtime, the easies time to remove the bark, so that doesn't surprise me, as much as the fact that any portion of them remains standing.
Did you notice some of the cars, like one pair in front of a brick wall at the Hospital, which had been so pummeled by flying debris? Those kind of high speed impact, plus the pulling force of the high wind foiling around the tree, would have been pulling it off.
Trees are just amazing. If the ground had been already wet and soft, they would have likely blown over due to the soil failing, but those shags which remain standing obviously had a solid grip on terra firma.
Re: Strength of wood.
GolfSteve in Calgary
Hi Dale. I've previously seen that photo years ago, so it is not from the recent tornado. I don't know the original source.
Re: Strength of wood.
Dale Lenz
Kinda like a certain book on the coffee table, makes for good conversation. Opps,
blush.
I never under estimate the power of wood and trees, 
Re: Strength of wood.
Howard Acheson
Never under estimate the creative PhotoShop person either.
Also.....
Howard Acheson
....looks like a container ship in the background and there seems to be a channel in the background too.
Re: Strength of wood.
Don in Central Illinois
At the Illinois state museum I saw a wheat straw blown through a piece of wood. Something about the incredible air pressure surrounding the straw, or in this case, the pole, that it becomes incredibly dense and able to penetrate normally denser objects.
Re: Also.....
Barry Irby
They don't have container ships in downtown Oklahoma? Who knew?
About thirty years ago lightning hit a tree adjacent to my friends deck. (I know this was a tornado and lightning is not the same thing, but its still and enormous force.) It was a poplar tree about 12" in diameter and about two feet form the deck. The force of the lightning blew the shaft of the tree to smithereens. The tree was still standing, but the bark was mostly gone and the wood was turned into toothpick sized pulp/splinters. dozens of little hair like pieces, some as big as tooth picks were blasted into the railing of the deck which was made of dry hard treated wood. You could not pull them out. Even if you were very careful, either with your fingers or pliers, they just broke off. And they were wet and very soft. It would have been a very painful experience to have been hit with them, if the lightning did not kill you.
That picture does not look right to me. Its seems the top of the concrete would have been ejected upward at the very least. Other than the cracks, it looks undisturbed.