Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Spraying with Lacquer

Posts

Spraying with Lacquer

#1

Spraying with Lacquer

Joseph Prendergast

Was perusing your article on 11. Lacquer, did not read the whole thing, but noted your comments on water base lacquer. Although water base lacquer doesn't have the characteristics of of nitrocellulose lacquer, nor behaves the same relative to climate conditions, it has come a long way to matching the qualities of nitro. lac......it no longer looks like a plastic finish on a piece of wood. If you look at some of the better water base lacquers, the are more than adequate for most any wood project in todays world, and except for antique restoration, are almost indistinguishable. Have used both products for too many years and will not go back to nitro lac. except for small projects, pieces that need rubbing out, antiques and or musical instruments to name a few. If you come into my shop, you will never go back to nitro lac. IMHO. Joseph ......ps. most people would never be able to tell the difference. I know, your a pro but most aren't.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#2

Whose Article . . . 11?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

While I agree with your comments in general, I'll point out 2 things. 1. I've rubbed out waterborne lacquer (Target) with high success. 2. Waterbornes, for all their advantages, do not have the repair-ability held by solvent finishes, lacquer and shellac. I've spoken to several "refinishing" experts and, aside from trying to "spot on" finish to fill and attempting to level and rub out (iffy at best) they've been mostly without suggestions. I actually tried that with a deep scratch/dent in cherry and had to refinish the entire top because of the witness line.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#3

Re: Whose Article . . . 11?

Joseph Prendergast

Not familiar with the Target brand, have been using Enduro, now from General Finishes, for man years. I agree you are not going to repair a water lacquer finish without doing the whole thing over, unless someone here can tell me how, and I am the King of Cheaters. I also rub out water base finishes but mostly try to leave them alone. I will say the big difference is how your shop smells, and feels......Healthy!!!!!

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#4

Yo!  Hermano!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Enduro Clear Poly, with and without the cross-linker, has been my goto finish for years, and, since it levels so well, I leave it "off-the-gun" on everything now.

Jeff Weiss and Target (right here in New Jersey) were one of the first to develop 100% burn-in waterborne lacquers. Did, however, run into a problem with cold checking on my shellac sealer/tie coats with the old PSL formulation; it was not pretty. I hear the new Emtec line is an improvement. I should call him and ask about follow-on repairs.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#5

Emtec and shellac

Merle

Mark, my understanding is that the Emtec products are fine with freshly prepared shellac. However, it/they do not play well with Zinsser Bullseye Shellac and cause crazing if applied in moderate/heavy coats. I have read that if the Emtec products are applied in thin (1-2 mil) coats, one MIGHT be okay, but I would avoid the combination if at all possible. FWIW

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#6

Shortly After SealCoat Came Out

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

a number of waterborne finish mfgrs were reported to be getting complaints about the SealCoat and stored shellac cold-checking under the waterborne topcoats. In talking with Jeff Weiss at Target he was recommending that any tie-coat or tinting/sealing using dewaxed shellac should be with product that was no more than 3 months old as the esterification of the shellac would become significant after that time and that was what they felt was causing the problem.

Bulls Eye, being not dewaxed, was never recommended to undercoat water based product because of the adhesion issues.

I had to change my routine as I was working with cherry at the time and was using dewaxed dark garnet to blend the different tones that cherry can exhibit. Since I now had to keep the shellac as thin as possible, I had to move to inclusion of TransTints in the shellac to get the color blending I wanted. I also got in the habit of mixing only about what I needed for the piece(s) ready for finishing so I knew my mix was as fresh as possible.

Had to refinish a cold-checked cherry Lady Morris Chair which was not a whole lot of fun to do.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#7

Why water based lacquer?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

You seem to imply a health risk improvement. I would argue that that is not highest on the list reasons to consider a water based lacquer, or even a significant factor.

There are three risks from spraying lacquer, or any other finish- fire, effects of solvent, effects of film former aerosol entering lungs to stay there forever.

I would think that the most compelling reason to spray a water based finish would be flammability, yet many seem to be gravitating to these finishes for some perceived fear of the health effects of the solvents used in solvent based systems. At the levels that these solvents are a health risk for long term exposure there will be a significant risk of flammability.

News flash- water based systems require organic solvents to coalesce the latex particles. In the case of Target they are using glycol ethers. They have the "advantage" of not smelling like mineral spirits, acetone or toluene. Does this make exposure to them for the small amount of spraying most of us do significantly safer? Doubtful. Additionally, for the paranoid, one could worry about the volatile acrylic and isocyanate monomers invariably present in these formulations. They have interesting MSDS sheets.

The significant health risk is from the nonvolatile stuff present in any finish that is sprayed. Any precautions to eliminate this risk are going to make the solvent health risks insignificant, but not he flammability risk of solvent based finishes.

Bottom line- Worry about blowing up if using a solvent based finish. Worry about avoiding breathing the aerosol from any sprayed finish.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#8

Re: Why

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

First, breathing vapor is not an issue unless the user is duh! enough not to be wearing a proper mask.

Second, waterbornes are easier to handle, store, and clean up, especially if you don't care to have to store quantities of solvents. The tail solvents you mention are minimal, but work better than retarders to get the film to flow and level, and the fresh film is much less sensitive to changing environmental conditions at the time of application.

Third, if you have a modicum of concern about reducing VOC in the air and water, waterbornes help. Argue that "the little bit I use makes no difference" and then multiply that by several million users to see the fallacy. Each of us can take just a little responsibility and make just a little difference.

Fourth, good waterbornes outperform solvent lacquer in situations such as kitchen cabinetry and table tops subject to water and food acid spills.

Fifth, good waterbornes build faster with higher solids content that solvent lacquer to get the piece to an acceptable finish in less time.

Sixth, in my experience, waterbornes work much better in HLVP rigs as the combination of less pressure and heavier liquid seriously reduces overspray and wasted product.

Lastly, having worked both, I prefer the optical depth and clarity of cured waterbornes to that of solvent lacquer. While I can easily dye-tint waterborne product, I most often look for as little color change as I can get. I know, however, that there are some solvent lacquers that will do as well in the water-white criteria.

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#9

Mark, thanks

Merle

for clarifying that for me. This getting old is wrecking my memory. :(

Re: Spraying with Lacquer

#10

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

My clear preference for waterborne finishes is not to take away from the superior ease in repairability of solvent lacquer and solvent shellac. Having had to refinish a cold-checked piece top-coated with waterborne lacquer, I can attest from personal experience that it ain't no fun where a solvent lacquer or shellac finish would have been a breeze by comparison.