Re: Thinning- why are you stuck at 10%?
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Not meaning to be a smart ass but following the instructions of someone that has no trouble spraying urethane varnish might be the better choice. In spite of your avoidance of my advice I will offer more.......
The first coat of varnish, or any finish, will absorb more or less depending on the grain orientation. Don't worry about this fact. It matters not what he first coat looks like. Its job is to seal and stiffen grain fibers so they can be sanded smooth. If I want a thin build of finish I may thin the first coat 50/50. Spray. Let dry. Sand with something in the range of 320 to 400 grit stearated paper (white stuff). Then spray a second coat diluted less. Let dry, sand , add a top coat. Or, depending, I may dilute the first coat less, sand, and just do one more coat. Depending on how much you dilute and how many coats you spray, will depend on how thick the coatings build. You can get a thick protective coating with a "plastic look" or a thin close- to- the- wood coating that may look better but offer less protection.
An alternative to urethane varnish for protection is conversion varnish. It is easier to spray but not as easy as lacquer. I usually thin the first coat of conversion varnish.
You seem reluctant to experiment. If you are ever going to be a successful sprayer you must experiment for no one is going to write enough to tell you all you need to learn..
PS if the card board looks uniform wet that is what you are looking for. You are looking to get a uniform coating, not necessarily a thick one. Spraying is not difficult to learn. I gave my daughter a 15 min lesson and she now sprays stuff I make for her. Actually I taught her on paint that is easier to see the result.