Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

HVLP Spraying Results

Posts

HVLP Spraying Results

#1

John Pierce

HVLP Spraying Results

John Pierce

This is my attempt to show what the spray finish looked like after the third spraying cycle. I am trying to understand if my sprayer was maladjusted, the 10% of dissolution of the Polyurethane was improper or their were other problems.

On some other panels that I was the spraying at the same time, when I sprayed slower in an area I had Poly runs.

Any advice or observations you can provide would be greatly appreciated.

( I don't have a website, so I guess you have nothing to look at! )

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#2

Information, Please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi John,

First, if you go through registering for the forum, you'll be able to post photos which makes thing way easier.

Now to the questions:

I take it your term "dissolution" implies thinning the product. Yes?

You don't state what kind of poly (Oil or Waterborne) you're using and what you've thinned/dissoled it with; very important information.

What kind of HVLP are you using? . . Turbine or conversion gun with a compressor?

If working with a compressor, what are your setting a) at the regulator and b) at the gun?

What are you spraying? Flat-work or contoured/rounded forms and horizontal or vertical?

How have you preped the surface? Can make a big difference.

Take a few minutes, register using the menu above, and then post the additional information.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#3

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

1. WC provides instructions for posting pictures. Even I can do it.

2. Until you mastered spraying on some test surface it was bold to try the project.

3. HVLP is more picky about getting things right to get proper atomization, which is why I don't recommend these sprayers. If you were spraying droplets instead of a mist, atomization was the problem. No idea if this was your problem. If so, thin to the amount I recommended. It works at least for a conventional gun. Under thinning results in failure. Over thinning just makes getting runs easier.

4. Or, you may be moving the gun to fast-grainy texture_ or too slow-runs. You should be laying down a wet film , as seen in good lighting, like water spread on clean glass.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#4

hate to say I told you so......

Dick Coers

but spraying poly is not easy. But, it's easier than us trying to trouble shoot your problems with basically no information. Pictures will be a necessity.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#5

John Pierce

Re: Information, Please

John Pierce

I was on WoodCentral several years ago and thought I remembered that you could post a picture. I just signed-in and still cannot see how to link a .jpg that I have on my computer.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#7

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

RobCarr

Why don't you try spraying lacquer? I'm not exactly sure what a HVLP sprayer is, but the gun I use has to be at least 35 years old and while I've spray finish my whole life I don't feel like an expert, but I always get good results with lacquer, it dries fast a couple of coats with a light steel wool between them and you're done.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#8

John Pierce

Re: look at the FAQ's in the bar above

John Pierce

Dick, I am missing something basic. In the FAQ section is says:

(Click the little blue button next to the "Upload embedded file" box to see the permitted file types and the size limits for each.) Place your cursor in the message text box where you want the image to appear in your post, then click the "Browse" button next to the "Upload embedded image" box and browse to the image or file on your computer and click Open. In a few moments, a line of code will appear in the message text, surrounded by [uplimg][/uplimg] tags.

There is no little blue button on a reply page or an "upload embedded image" box on my reply page. Is that only on a post a message page?

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#9

John Pierce

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

John Pierce

Well one thing I have learned. I went to the manufactures web site and looked up the Polyurethane I was using and they only suggest application by brush. No viscosity for spray. I am still trying to post the photos, but after reading the FAQ on photos, I am still at a loss since the screens for posting and reply do not offer me the links to photo inclusion.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#10

photo inclusion made easy

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

1. Become officially registered for WoodCentral. When you open a post you get a box labeled "choose file" and a bunch of strange symbols in gray boxes if you have registered.

2. Size your picture file to less than 100K.

3. Begin a post.

4. Click on the gray box that says "choose file"

5. Click on the picture file and wait till some strange symbols appear in the text of your post.

5. go to preview and be amazed that a picture appears.

6.hit post at bottom of screen

for example, the picture is one a many things I have varnished (in this case not urethane varnish but it, alkyd varnish and oil paint all spray the same when thinned as I recommended) I have no problem spraying sufficiently thinned varnish, paint or shellac (shellac is by far the most picky as it has no viscosity and runs easily)


Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#11

John Pierce

Re: photo inclusion made easy

John Pierce

How do I register? Haven't located the link for registration. I have a profile.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#12

John Pierce

Re: photo inclusion made easy

John Pierce

Under my profile, there is a box for files on my computer. Should I set up a WoodCentral folder on my computer and keep all the photos I may want to list in that folder. Then list that folder location on the "My Profile" section?

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#13

John Pierce

Re: photo inclusion made easy

John Pierce

I finally figured out how to get the photos on my page here. I mentioned that I discovered that the Polyurethane I was using has no recommendations for spray painting only brush applications. So the comments that spraying with poly is very trickey. Here are a flash picture and a reflection picture of the panel.

Flash Photo


Reflection Photo


John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#14

spraying poly is easy, when thinned correctly

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

It looks to me like it is not flowing out (leveling) and/or it was not atomized to begin with. Thin as I recommended and try again.

BTW, it doesn't flow out very well when brushed either unless it is thinned 25-35%. Again, it is formulated to meet an EPA requirement, not to apply easily. Add the proper VOC's and all is well.

Now, you can believe that it is hard to spray or can't be sprayed. In this case use something else. My results (and thinning employed) differ, at least when using conventional spray gun.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#15

John Pierce

Re: spraying poly is easy, when thinned correctly

John Pierce

Bill, I thinned it 5% to 10% by volume, but there must have been a problem with atomization. I had tried spraying with water first to get the gun set right. I used the small adapter head tip, 0.9mm.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#16

Needle/Tip is Too Small

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Oil-based poly is not water-thin by any means. Go to a 1.2m needle set, thin the poly 15% in a small batch with naptha, and set your HVLP gun to 25-30 PSI. Use as wide a fan as you can, back off on your material knob to give the a better chance to atomize the material, keep your gun no more than 8" from the surface being coated, and double hit at 90° to the first pass direction.

I hope you're using a conversion gun with an air compressor. Air turbine outfit heat the air stream and will play hell with solvent finishes, including oil-based poly.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#17

Thinning- why are you stuck at 10%?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Why are you stuck at 10%, a piddly amount? One thins till it spray right. In my first response to you I suggested 1 :3 solvent to varnish, a suggestion you have avoided trying. If that don't spray add more solvent. I have had thick paint that I thinned 1:1. I thin poly 1:3 for brushing, often 1:2 for a first coat. To avoid a thick build when spraying urethane varnish I thin urethane 1:2. After grinding a finish flat I often spray 1:1 dilution to avoid a thick build of the finish.

BTW, for those that don't like the "thick plastic look" of urethane varnish, thin it! Thinning not only enables these thick varnishes to flow out better, release bubbles better but you can thumb you nose at EPA that mandated that these finishes be made too thick to perform ideally.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#18

John Pierce

Re: Thinning- why are you stuck at 10%?

John Pierce

Sorry I left the impression I was avoiding your suggestion. I was following the thinning suggestion of another woodworker. I can easily see the advantages of using a lower ratio (more thinning). I certainly will try that. Although I am not getting the results I would like, I will keep trying to get things right. The piece your included in your previous posting looked excellent.

When spraying on cardboard, what I first see is simply the effect of the cardboard being whetted, and not much else unless I over spray it and it begins to run. Should I be evaluating the spray pattern and any other factors in this test spraying? You can probably tell that spraying is brand new to me.

Also there are spots on the panel that are not taking paint. The only thing about those spots, that I remember after the final preparation sanding with #220 grit, was that they were dark spots in the cherry almost like what a knot hole might have looked like. You can see one in the upper left corner of the Reflection Photo I included in a previous post of mine.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#19

Re: Thinning- why are you stuck at 10%?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Not meaning to be a smart ass but following the instructions of someone that has no trouble spraying urethane varnish might be the better choice. In spite of your avoidance of my advice I will offer more.......

The first coat of varnish, or any finish, will absorb more or less depending on the grain orientation. Don't worry about this fact. It matters not what he first coat looks like. Its job is to seal and stiffen grain fibers so they can be sanded smooth. If I want a thin build of finish I may thin the first coat 50/50. Spray. Let dry. Sand with something in the range of 320 to 400 grit stearated paper (white stuff). Then spray a second coat diluted less. Let dry, sand , add a top coat. Or, depending, I may dilute the first coat less, sand, and just do one more coat. Depending on how much you dilute and how many coats you spray, will depend on how thick the coatings build. You can get a thick protective coating with a "plastic look" or a thin close- to- the- wood coating that may look better but offer less protection.

An alternative to urethane varnish for protection is conversion varnish. It is easier to spray but not as easy as lacquer. I usually thin the first coat of conversion varnish.

You seem reluctant to experiment. If you are ever going to be a successful sprayer you must experiment for no one is going to write enough to tell you all you need to learn..

PS if the card board looks uniform wet that is what you are looking for. You are looking to get a uniform coating, not necessarily a thick one. Spraying is not difficult to learn. I gave my daughter a 15 min lesson and she now sprays stuff I make for her. Actually I taught her on paint that is easier to see the result.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#20

Re:Agree with Bill 100%

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

However I normally thin (I use Minwax oil based Polyurethane) roughly 50%. (I fill the gun about 3/8 full with Poly then add thinner to about 3/4 full). I have a conventional Binks Spray gun - can't remember the tip size.

I found I can get excellent results with Zero runs or voids by thinning the way I do and spraying multiple coats. I normally only wait long enough until the surface is not "tacky". Yeah I know it is not cross-linked/cured but it works well for me.

If I want a Gloss surface I continue to add coats until it is done. When I desire a "Satin" finish, I coat until I achieve a good gloss coverage then finish the surface (after a couple days or more to achieve full cure) using 4-0 steel wool and wax for lubricant. (I have used several different waxes and really can't tell much difference) Then I buff the surface.

I have done this on vertical and horz. surfaces as well as round legs etc. Never have a problem. I also spray Lacquer pretty thin (about 1 to 1), and have sprayed a lot of 1/2 to 1 lb cuts of shellac. I do have a cheap "conversion" gun from HF. About the only time I use it is when I have to spray inside a "box" or inside deep shelves, just cause it doesn't "bounce back" and coat me with more material than the item I am finishing!

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#21

John Pierce

Re: spraying poly is easy, when thinned correctly

John Pierce

I have been asked what HVLP sprayer I am using. I purchased it from Rockler.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#22

HVLP

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

OK, John,

The Rockler "kit" is a turbine-driven unit. These kinds of HVLP sprayers were designed for waterborne finishes and can present problems with applying material that uses solvents and diluents, like lacquer, shellac, and oil based varnish and poly. The reason is that the air supply from the turbine is drawn through the motor, like a vacuum cleaner, so the air is warmed up. This plays havoc with the solvents because it will tend to make them flash off between the spray tip and the surface you wish to coat. When this happens, those solvents that help the oils and resins level out and fuse are reduced and you get the "orange peel" shown in your photo.

With your kit came a small plastic funnel-shaped cup with a handle which you should use to gauge how much to thin your finishing product. You should have gotten an owner's manual with will explain how. The cup is essentially a timer in that properly thinned product will drain from the cup in a set number of seconds. The manual will tell you which drain time is proper for the size tip you are using.

Since you are using a turbine gun, you should thin with a diluent that has a slower evaporation rate like mineral spirits (rather than naptha) so it will be more tolerant of the warmer air your unit uses. If you were spraying solvent lacquer or shellac, you would need to use a "retarder" to prevent the solvents from flashing off too quickly.

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#23

John Pierce

Re: HVLP

John Pierce

The Orange Peel effect explains a comment made by a person who purchased a Rockler system. I have been unable to find a viscosity rating by any paint manufacturer. The only viscosity times are those stated by the manual and purchasers of the Rockler system.

Looking at water based paints, I found a Polyurethane and a Polycrylic. Both have rather short drying times.

John

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

#24

Bob

Re: HVLP Spraying Results

Bob

I did some spray finishing a few years back but now only do hand finishing, maybe its an illusion but the hand finish seems to just look better to me.