I have a nice box top I made from some book matched Cocobolo. I put on two coats of Danish Oil, then waited a couple days and the sprayed it with Poly.
Scrape it as much as you can. use lacquer thinner, take the rest of the poly off, let dry and resand/buff to very high grit, like 600G. Just use oil to bring out the color. Dab the cloth to oil, then apply, buff with dry cloth.
First, Cocobolo is a tropical wood that contains lots of oil. The natural oils prevent an oil based finish from drying properly. You can wipe the item down with acetone or lacquer thinner just before applying the finish. Best, however, is to apply a coat of dewaxed shellac before applying your oil based top coat.
Second, as suggested, use a chemical stripper containing methylene chloride to remove the existing finish. It will do the most complete and fastest job of removal.