Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Pastry Station Finish

Posts

Pastry Station Finish

#1

Pastry Station Finish

Yonak

My wife wants me to make a pastry station, i.e., a wooden board with foldable sides to contain the flour some. My original intention was to leave the wood raw, but a friend said I should have some finish on it, even if just oil. I had thought it wouldn't matter if flour got embedded in the wood, but then I realized there may be raw egg and other organics.

Then I considered covering it with vinyl that could be wiped clean or a removable canvas cover that could be put in the washing machine, or maybe making the base out of Formica. I'm now not keen on any of those ideas and am leaning toward oil.

Suggestions / ideas / thoughts requested.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#2

I would leave it raw...

John in NM

Scraping off any residue when finished and letting it dry fully between uses should be fine. If you are very concerned about the egg or butter, you can wipe it down with some bleach and water after each use.

Alternatively, I would perhaps oil it with a drying oil or use varnish of some kind. Lots of people fret about food safe finishes, but the thing to remember is that dry finishes are inert anyway, so I don't worry about it. Using a non-drying oil wouldn't really help you anyhow, just make a mess with the flour. With a couple coats of oil you could then wash it a bit more aggressively if desired.

I like the canvas cover idea too, if you could get it sorted out. With the sides that seems a bit complicated though.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#3

Re: Pastry Station Finish

Chip Burwell

What about a marble or granite slab? Easy to clean, durable, and looks nice. Depending on the size you need, you might be able to pick up a left over piece from a granite fabricator for next to nothing.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#4

Re: Pastry Station Finish

John Veerkamp

Traditional bread bowls were not finished. The oils in bread making eventually soak into the wood and create the patina seen on old bowls. If you want to hasten the oil sealing I'd use Mahoney's Utility Finish. It is a heat treated pure walnut oil. It dries into the wood, is inert when dry and totally food safe. There is no allergy issue! It dries in about 24 hours depending on temp and humidity. A couple of coats will be sufficient.

Studies show that wooden utensils harbor less bacteria than even plastic items.

I would not use bleach since it can lighten the wood and will leave some odor that can be picked up in your food. To clean the board/trough after use scrape it with a pastry scraper and wash with mild dish soap if necessary. Don't soak the soak the bowl.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#5

JL

Re: Pastry Station Finish

JL

It would depend on what wood you were using.

When I do pastry boards and rolling pins I typically sand them to 220 grit, raise the grain with water, sand again, raise the grain with water and then do a final sanding to p280 or p320 grit and then I rub it down with some shavings or sawdust.

I then oil with mineral oil.

If you use a close grain wood, you shouldn't have any problems. I don't usually use raw egg (except in cookies), but I do use a lot of butter and shortening - especially in my pie crusts. I've never had problems with stuff sticking to the wood. I usually use cherry or maple.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#6

Re: Pastry Station Finish

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

as we speak I am making rolls laden with eggs and butter which will be worked on my maple counter top that for 20+ years has been given a dash of what ever cooking oil is handy when it looks dry. It gets scraped and/or wiped occasionally to clean it.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#7

Mineral Oil

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

You want to use mineral oil as it won't go rancid over time. Vegetable based oils all eventually go rancid and can impart a foul taste to food. I think most nut oils have the same problem.

Lee

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#8

Folding sides

Yonak

John, regarding the sides, my thought was to use piano hinges and cover them with strips of vinyl that can be wiped off. If I chose a canvas cover, which seems unlikely, as I can't get my head around egg, milk and oil on canvas (unless, of course, I intend to sell it to MOMA), I could hinge from the underside and have the sides fold underneath when stored.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#9

Re: Pastry Station Finish

Yonak

JL, I intend to make it out of maple plywood with maple edging that will extend below the bottom surface on three sides so it will hook on the edges of the peninsula counter top. This means I will have to make it 38" wide, which should be a sufficiently wide working surface.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#10

JL

Careful.

JL

I'm always sort of leery about plywood. Sometimes when they cut the veneer, the surface isn't really that smooth. You have all these little checks.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#11

data to support the statement?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"Vegetable based oils all eventually go rancid and can impart a foul taste to food." This claim gets repeated every time this discussion comes up. Do you have any data to support it?

Were it true, and I have 40+ years of experience that says it isn't a relevant issue, how would one keep the oils from the stuff one works on these wood surfaces from sticking to the wood surface and causing this supposed problem? I have one cutting board that we use for butchering that I made in 1966. It is oily from sheep, deer and beef fat as well as vegie oil added when it looks like it needs some. Indeed it has a faint odor of "oil and fat". The thought that this amount of oxidized oil will transfer to something cut on this board and affect the taste is unimaginable, and not supported by experience. We have had a wood section of counter top in every house we have ever lived in. They get used, last night for example, to work a dough rich in butter. Without a doubt some butter remains on this surface along with the remains of the olive oil from working a pizza crust last week and what ever else it has ever seen in the past 20 years.

Further driving a stake on this hypothesis, the desirable flavors in bread resulting from fermentation (rising) are some of the same chemicals that result from oxidizing fats and oils. (ditto cheese). The few molecules of oxidized fat from my wood work surface that get transferred to the rolls I made last night will be but an insignificant fraction of what was made during fermentation(rising).

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#12

not a good idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Today's maple veneer is but a few thousandths of an inch thick after sanding. I doubt it will hold up. And, because of the way it is manufactured it is more porous (which can be mitigated by loading it up with oil).

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#13

Re: not a good idea

Yonak

Thanks for the advice. I've got plenty of hard maple. I'll use it instead.

It's beginning to look like it'll take a crane to put this thing in place. Maybe I'll make it a permanent fixture.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#14

Re: Folding sides

William Duffield

When rolling out pie crusts, we use a Norpro pastry frame and rolling pin sock, so the dough doesn't stick to the pin or the work surface. The frame is canvas, with a wire and wood frame. It works immeasurably better than any other surface I've ever used, including maple, Formica, marble or nylon. We keep them in the refrigerator, and they go in the washing machine. My mother-in-law was a home economics teacher, and she always used a pastry frame too.

I think it is easier to clean flour and dough off the floor than out of hinges, especially piano hinges, and anyway you're going to get flour on the floor when you clean the hinges.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#15

make your own veneer plywood

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

You could slice some 1/16"(approx) maple and glue it to each side of a good grade of 3/4" birch plywood.

Re: Pastry Station Finish

#16

Re: Pastry Station Finish

brad p bransky

Leave it bare wood and clean it with a pastry scraper and sponge it. Go to any bakery and ask them what they use or a finish and they'll tell you bare wood.

If you want sides to contain the flour, make them with dowels which settle into holes on the sides of the board so they can be removed for cleaning and storage.

Happy baking!

Brad