Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

How to pull

Posts

How to pull

#1

How to pull

Gary Smyth

a small press on bearing? This belongs to a Makita sander. I need to replace the shaft. For that to happen the pictured bearing needs to be pulled. Makita says it is a press on and should pry loose. Once off the path is clear to drop in a shaft. Problem is I can't get purchase underneath with even my smallest gear puller and no pry baror screwdriver has fit well enough to exert leverage to lift it. Wood wedges just crumble. I'm looking for ideas or a inexpensive tool. The bearing is 1/2" x 3/16". I'm replacing the shaft so damage there will not hurt. I'd like to save the bearing.

Re: How to pull

#2

Re: How to pull

Lars Parrington

you might consider a destructive approach, since a new bearing would probably only cost $1. cutoff wheel in a angle grinder?

Re: How to pull

#3

Re: How to pull

Grant in Iowa

Gary,

I would consider taking a flat bar of steel maybe 1/4" thick and the width of the bearing or greater. Then drill a hole in the bar of sufficient size to slide over the bearing shaft. Make this hole about an inch or inch and a half from one end of the bar. Next, using a hacksaw, elongate that hole to extend to the end of the bar stock, creating a slot at one end that will slide over the bearing shaft. Then grind this end of the bar stock so it becomes a forked wedge thin enough to get beneath the bearing. To use the tool, drive it in from the side beneath the bearing. Once you do this, the bearing will have moved enough to get a standard puller beneath it. If not, you can add a wooden or metal shim behind your wedge tool and make a second pass.

I would suggest you inspect the durability of the main part before attempting this and proceed with caution so it isn't damaged.

I have attached an image of where I got the idea... a ball joint tool. Image credit www.northerntools.com

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


img

Re: How to pull

#4

Bearing separator?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you can find a small enough bearing separator, that might do the job (image below). Horrible Fright sells bearing separators, and, for a one-time use like this, that might be enough. Or you might call your local rental yard, and see if they rent them; or call any auto mechanics or machinists you know and see if you can borrow one.

I've done with two screwdrivers levering against the rest of the part, but this is high risk - easy to damage the part.


img

Re: How to pull

#5

craigd

Re: How to pull

craigd

- Pickle fork (pictured in another post)

- There are bearing pullers that will pull a bearing from the front (ie pop off the seal and puller teeth fit the bearing groove)

- Me, I'd try a brass drift and knock out the shaft, the bearing will pop off in the process. This shouldn't hurt the bearing.

Re: How to pull

#6

Might not work but.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I was reading your post. On my desk is a staple remover. I was picturing it grabbing under your bearing. And maybe with some clamping force, it might do the trick? Hey...I'm just sayin'!!

T.

Re: How to pull

#7

Solution.  Thanks all

Gary Smyth

Thanks to all. Got the bearing off the spindle. Had to do a bit of judicious grinding on the puller hooks to get it underneath, and needed four hands and a vise because nothing wanted to stay in place when pressure was applied. The shaft on the spindle has a smaller diameter than the end of the screw on the puller (and the puller didn’t have a cone end) so a cut nail placed in the spindle hole gave me enough room to allow it to do the work. Thanks again.

Re: How to pull

#8

Congratulations

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Creative understanding of how to apply force is a vital skill for a mechanic; your experience sounded a lot like some of mine over the years.

Remember, when installing the new bearing, to apply force to the inner race only. A suitable "punch" from hardwood or a socket the right diameter, on a short extension and tapped with a soft-faced hammer, are the two best approaches.

Re: How to pull

#9

Re: Congratulations

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Isn't it amazing how we guys stumble on ideas to make our repairs or to make our jigs to do the work.

Re: How to pull

#10

I read a book some years back

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

by a guy who was a graduate student in New England and was referred to a local mechanic to keep his old Saab running. In the book, he expresses amazement at some of the mechanic's clever solutions for difficult-to-find parts, treating the guy like some kind of oily DaVinci. I remember reading it and thinking, "well, yeah, that would work; what's the big deal?" I guess some people just aren't lucky in the parents they select and don't get the opportunity to learn how to do things in the physical world.

Re: How to pull

#11

craigd

Boy am I glad you didn't take my "advice"!

craigd

Didn't notice that circlip.