Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

Posts

OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#1

OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

David Hay Denver

I'm just about ready to seal my new shop floor, but I'm driving myself crazy trying to figure out what to apply. I'm looking for something easy to apply and relatively inexpensive. Epoxy is not in the cards right now.

So far, I've looked at H&C Concrete Sealer (Sherwin Williams), Seal-Krete, and Thompsons WaterSeal. Are any of these head and shoulders above the other? Any other products to consider?

Also, do I need to etch the concrete before applying anything? Water soaks in (that is, it doesn't bead up on the surface). Does that mean it's porous enough to seal as-is? I don't really like the idea of messing with harsh acids (e.g. hydrochloric acid). If I must etch, can I just mix in some citric acid powder into water and use that?

Thanks for any and all advice!

David

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#2

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

RobCarr

I've used Thompsons WaterSeal, no etching required. Use a roller and it takes less than 30 minutes to do a 20'x25' space.

Be careful, though... after sealing the floor when it gets wet it is rather slippery, if you're wearing smooth sole shoes... learned that the hard way! :)

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#3

JL

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

JL

Yes, you need to etch - even if only slightly. A dilute solution of hydrochloric acid is recommended - so use that.

Would citric acid etch concrete? Somewhat. Any acid (citric, acetic, hydrochloric) is going to react with the calcium salts in the cement. The stronger acids such as hydrochloric are going to react more readily and completely than the weaker organic acids. You want to paint in a "reasonable time frame" - so you don't want to wait for the reaction to take place. You also want the reaction products to be easily soluble - so you can rinse them off easily before painting.

Muriatic acid (hydrochloric) is also less expensive. At 1 pint per gallon to etch the floor - it may take you a couple of quarts to do the floor.

Yes - hydrochloric acid is nastier than citric. It is also faster, more thorough and better for the job. That's why they've used it for many years.

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#4

I know nothing.....

basil

I know nothing about this product....I just got this in an email a few minutes ago....I don't recommend it....and I have no knowledge of the company or their product but I did find this video both interesting and somewhat relaxing....wonder if it would shed the IRS like it does liquids?

http://www.youtube.com/embed/IPM8OR6W6WE?feature

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#5

Thompsons

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I would shy away from Thompsons WaterSeal for use in a wood shop as it is heavy on silicone which will mess with wood finishes down the road.

m

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#6

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

Paul Blackwell

I built a new house, and partitioned off part of the basement for my shop. I sealed my floor with Sherwin-Williams sealer about 14 months ago with no etching, just vacuumed it good and it looks good so far. It cleans up easily now, and is not slippery. Very easy to apply-I bought a roller which is about 20" wide to speed up the job.

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#7

Sealing Concrete

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

When we paved our driveway with concrete, the concrete contractor supplied a sealant for the concrete. It had to be applied a day after the concrete was poured. It was applied with a pump up type sprayer.

Why not ask the local concrete supplier or your contractor what they recommend after all they have far more experience with concrete than any of us do.

Lee

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#8

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

Dick Coers

They used some sort of water based sealer here at work to seal the concrete floor. It looked about like water based polyurethane, and is wearing well, but doesn't play well with water. When we bring in a wet vehicle, you watch the water wick into cracks and expansion joints, and it actually gets under the sealer. It doesn't lift the sealer off, but looks horrible for a couple days. Despite the smell, I would use a solvent based if you can get it. Call the contractor that poured the floor so you can get a professional sealer that the big box store doesn't carry.

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#9

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

JMOHNIKE

From the end of Nov last yr, and late Jan, this yr I could not do much in my shop due to a hernia, so my time was spent cleaning my shop. I cleaned, dusted etc. and the last thing, which was not on the origina list, was the floor. I moved things around and mopped (the 2nd time in 30+ yrs.) and it looked pretty good, with the exception of various paint spots, glue etc. I decided (stillhad time on my hands) to put something on the floor, I found a product by Zep called the wet look. I put 2 coats on with a sponge mop and it made a big difference in the floor, spills of paint, stain and glue all wipe up easly, and the sawdust is easy to blow out (no dust collection system) and it is easy to maintain.

I mop and apply a coat the first friday of the month, takes about 20 min. Cheap, effective and does the job for me. I later found out it is the same product that is used the custodian at our local post office. The only difference is that they buff the final coat. Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#10

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

David Hay Denver

Thanks for the reference to Zep products. It looks like the z-tread floor sealer might be what I'm looking for. The big box stores carry Zep floor sealer, though I'm not sure if it's the same stuff as here:

http://www.zepequipment.com.s54339.gridserver.com/pdf/onesheets/R040.pdf

Thanks!

David

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

#11

Re: OT: Sealing Concrete Floor

Tony - Memphis

That's what I did to my shop floor. I was going to leave it bare, but someone suggested that sealing it would help a lot. That was in '98. It has held up wel and it makes it easier to clean up messes. Sort of made it look a little better too. As stated, it was easy to apply.

Tony