Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Working with Beech?

Posts

Working with Beech?

#1

Working with Beech?

Tom

I met with an architect this past weekend to discuss his new kitchen. I have done work for him before and he really likes my work:)! So now they want to do a total kitchen remolded with custom cabinetry.

He is considering Beech. I have never worked with it before and was wondering if anyone is familar with it and could comment?

Thanks!

Re: Working with Beech?

#2

Its a bit hard to find...

John in NM

Lumber yards don't carry it often, because it is cheap and wonderfully unstable. They use it in Europe, apparently steaming helps with stability. I've found it at specialty wood stores now and then, so perhaps availability is improving. I use it for grips to match a specific surplus rifle stock - they used beech for that fairly often.

Of course, notty alder that was all the rage a few years ago also suffers from these flaws and is soft and weak to boot.

Other than that, it is decent wood. Clear, plain, and really hard. Should make ok cabinets, but its not as good a choice as a lot of more readily available domestics - for which veneer face plywood and mdf are also available.

Re: Working with Beech?

#3

Re: Working with Beech?

Dave Bair

I've seen good results on custom interior doors and work benches made of EUROPEAN Beech.

AMERICAN Beech is another matter. I've had terrible experiences with kiln-dried, 7% moisture content, select grade wood. It will warp, cup and twist and, if you try to restrain it, it'll just simply split. Some boards I glued, split and rejointed and and reglued 3 times still cupped enough to split when restrained with through-tenons.

Re: Working with Beech?

#4

Re: Working with Beech?

david weaver

Too unstable unless it's quartersawn and straight down the tree. If it's QS and doesn't follow straight down the tree, even that will warp.

Which is too bad, because when it's dead quartered, it looks fantastic.

I can get beech locally and reasonably (at least compared to what it would cost at a specialty wood retailer), but I probably wouldn't use it. To get a good large amount of QS wood that was clear and even color would be very difficult.

Re: Working with Beech?

#5

There is a reason you don't see beech furniture.

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Steamed, and hence tamed, beech is being imported from Europe. It could be a reasonable choice. It is light and plain.

Re: Working with Beech?

#6

Re: Working with Beech?

Paul Vander Woude

European Beech was commonly used in wood planes, because it is very stable. As you say, American Beech not so much. None of my usual sources sell European Beech, and I have never searched to find any online.

Re: Working with Beech?

#7

Re: There is a reason you don't see beech furnitur

2B6

I'd ask him why beech?

What beech did he see that made him want it? He might have meant birch, not beech. :\

Re: Working with Beech?

#8

beech is attractive to some

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

It is used a lot in European furniture. It is light in color, uniform. It lends a modern look to modern furniture and cabinetry, a look I describe as stark. While I have not used it the steamed European beech will likely work ok. Given that it is nearly worthless as lumber it is rarely harvested in the US, so it is unlikely you will find American beech for sale.

Re: Working with Beech?

#9

All I've seen for sale...

John in NM

Is indeed European beech. I could see an architect spec'ing it for a very Euro kind of look, but I'd hate to be the guy doing the work.

I have to wonder if steaming domestic beech would tame it as well, not that there would be a lot of point, what with all the red oak and hickory we have here.

Re: Working with Beech?

#10

Just wondering

Merle

Assuming you could find American beech, could you cut the boards into veneer and glue it to a substrate to make the cabinets?

Re: Working with Beech?

#11

Re: All I've seen for sale...

Frank House

This whole thread puzzles me.

In the UK beech furniture is commonplace, the timber is widely used by manufacturers because it is cheap, easily machined, and stable.

By stable, I understand that it's response to humidity changes is non trivial but reversible, it maintains its overall shape well over time.

I find it easy to work with hand tools, and have had no distortion problems.

I plan to build some harpsichord components (jacks, guides, etc.) and intend to follow the practise of many reputable builders and use beech for its stability and suitability for small precision parts which must interact reliably.

The jack guides in my present harpsichord are made of what looks like unsteamed beech, they are long, thin, quarter sawn strips, with repeated complex shapes cut out. If they were not very stable, the instrument would not function properly.

As has been mentioned already, it is a traditional material for wooden handplanes, and the couple of beech planes I own have proved very stable over time.

One hears varied stories about steaming. Some say the process causes the wood to become pinker, and is purely cosmetic, other that it lends stability.

In my limited experience, steamed and unsteamed beech seem pretty similar to work with hand tools, and I have not noticed any difference in stability.

Perhaps there really is a difference between European and American beech.

Frank.