Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Best 14" To 18" Square???

Posts

Best 14" To 18" Square???

#1

Best 14" To 18" Square???

Derek Arita

I'm looking for the most accurate 14 to 18" square I can find to do some crucial alignments. Don't say Ed Bennet at TS-Tablesaw Alignment, because I've tried contacting him with no success. Some have said he is no longer doing business, but they're only guessing. If you have a way of contacting him, please let me know.

At any rate, Ed's 14" and 18" squares claim .0001" overall accuracy and that suits me fine. Are there any other squares that are close to that?

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#2

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I have no idea what toleranceSterrett claims for their squares but I have a forged head with a12" & 18" basses and out has never left me wanting for more. I also porn several engineeres squares and I know the have the level of accuracy you are looking for.

Robin

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#3

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

Derek Arita

Robin, please tell me how I can get one.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#4

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

William Duffield

Joel Moskowitz at Tools for Working Wood carries the complete Starrett line. Alternately, you can usually find old ones that remain very accurate at most old tool sales and auctions.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#5

craigd

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square??? *LINK*

craigd

If you don't mind used, check with Walt at Brass City. I bought a Union adjustable square and a 24" Starrett rule from him for some where around $70. I like it better than my other Starrett stuff and it is as accurate as I can measure but I have to doubt it is 0.001" over the length.

For that kind of accuracy, you need a very, very good fixed square. I looked at some of my usual sources for machinists tools and machinist squares that big are a bit rare and get very expensive very fast, I did see a import 18" one for $170 but, at that [low] price, they don't list the tolerance (but I would get one, check and not worry about it). Example: Starrett has a 24" square (they jump from 12" to 24" at MSC) that is 0.0002" over 12", all for a mere $1500.

As noted in your SMC thread, you may need to re-evaluate your accuracy needs.


Brass City

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#6

JL

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

JL

Ulmia Precision Try Square - available online at Woodcraft is one alternative.

I have a precision triangle that I really like - but the sides are only 12".

Starrett combination square in 24" or 18".

Those are the less expensive alternatives.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#7

Anybody know the accuracy of drafting triangles?


Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#8

A Curiosity About Accuracy

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

First of all, I will say that having accurate measuring tools is a good thing. Especially for setting up tools. A tool off one way and another off another way can compound a problem.

I don't have "top of the line" measuring and marking tools. Mine are decent quality but hardly missle making tolerence.

My curiosity stems from my experience with working wood. For all the accuracy I could employ measuring and marking wood, wood still has a mind of it's own. Humidity, temperature and other factors make wood "inaccurate". I have cut wood to great accuracy before and days later find it is no longer accurate!

So my curiosity is....how accurate do woodworking measuring and marking equipment have to be?

T.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#9

Re: Anybody know the accuracy of drafting triangle

basil

The K&E plastic ones I have from the early 60's are spot on.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#10

Re: Anybody know the accuracy of drafting triangle

Howard Acheson

Here is some info that may be helpful.

No matter how much you spend for a device, you still don't know if it is square. I ran a large tool and die shop and we purchased a number of Brown & Sharp and Starrett devices and some of them were not "square" out of the box. We had "standards" that our quality department periodically had validated by an outside service that we then used to verify the worker's tools.

One day, one of our designers brought in two plastic drawing triangles he had purchased at a local art supply store. He had them compared to our standards and they were as accurate as the tools could measure. The triangle cost a couple of dollars each. They would certainly serve very well as the "standard" in any woodworking shop to validate and/or adjust other devices.

An excellent way to validate the accuracy of the plastic squares is to use two squares on a flat surface. Get a $10-12 plastic 30-60-90 drafting square. To prove it's exactly 90°, take two to a glass counter, put the shorter legs on the counter and face the longer legs away from each other and butt them together (like a teepee). If the legs exactly butt, you can assume you have two perfect 90° angles. Using one of the plastic squares, do the same thing using your other tools. Any that mismatch, means that the tool is not square. You can also take the plastic square with you whenever you go to purchase another tool. Keep your "standard" somewhere where it doesn't get banged up.

Finally, remember that the wood you are using will expand and contract a couple of thousands from one day to the other. Does't pay to get too uptight.

While we are at it, I also only purchase the cheapest of adjustable squares. I square them with a drafting triangle and an auger file until they are square across 10". And I own a Bridge City square that isn't that accurate. Stainless steel machinist's squares are only square until you drop them. I have had several over the years and each has found a away to drop to the floor.

The key is to NEVER use your best square on for day to day measuring. Use it only as a reference tool to verify your other day to day tools.

In a comparison test reported in Fine Woodworking Magazine a couple of years ago, the Stanley 46-123 square was awarded the best value. It's much less expensive than a Starrett and just as accurate.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#11

JL

Re: A Curiosity About Accuracy

JL

I like to set up all my tools to at least 0.02", 0.01" if I can get it and not sneeze in the middle of setting up my tools. I typically like to cut to at most within 1/32". I try not to get it so I won't see a line between two pieces of wood.

On hand tools - I try for at most between 1/32" and 1/16"

When I'm building sets for the playhouse - if I get it to within 1/4", I'm very happy - except for platforms which have to be at 1/16" or they rock too much.

For turning boxes, I typically get a "pop" fit and then sand it a little. I've never really measured the accuracy.

For turning tenons on spindles, stretchers and such - I use the micrometer and try to turn the tenons to within 1/100" of the mortise hole - I don't like packing the holes with sawdust or screening material if I don't have to - and I don't like having to jam the tenon into the hole.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#12

you can assume what you like....

Mark Hennebury

Putting two squares back to back on a flat surface to see if they touch wont prove that they are 90° only that they are complementary angles.


You could verify with three squares; use the left for the reference, check the other two on by placing on the right hand side one at a time and checking against the left.

Next remove the left hand one and put two right hand ones back to back.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#13

Yeah, but....

Barry Irby

if that horizontal surface is flat/straight And you rotate one of the traingles about that vertical line until they over laid each other precisely while still resting on that flat surface, and in fact they did overlay each other precisely, Then the only angles that would allow that to be true, would be 90 degree angles. I think. It seems to me that you then know you have that angle pegged at 90 degrees, but you don't know what the other two are.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#14

Re: A Curiosity About Accuracy

Jesse Cloud

This is a very interesting topic and I doubt that it will end with a definite answer or something close to consensus. Its kinda like arguing about religion or pizza - strong opinions from every angle.

For what its worth, here are some standards Mark Duginski proposes in his book "Mastering Woodworking Machines" from Taunton Press:

Table saw: 10 in blade should have no more than 0.012 runout at the teeth

flange and arbor less that 0.003 runout

Jointers: tables less than 0.010 out of parallel end-to-end

blades between 0.001 to 0.002 above outfeed table

Planer: run two boards thru, place them side by side, no variation greater than

0.005

Router: arbor runout less than 0.001, runout of bit one inch above collet less than

0.005

Interestingly, none of these measurements are taken with a square. Also, most of his suggestions are outcome oriented, e.g. cut a piece and flip one of the two pieces over and see if they fit....

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#15

Many ways

Mark Hennebury

I merely pointed out that the method suggested will not verify 90° and offered a simple way that would.

There are many more ways to verify i am sure.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#16

Safe assumption...

John in NM

Given the enormous odds against getting two squares that are not 90, yet just happen to be perfectly complimentary angles, I wouldn't be prepared to sweat it. If there is no gap, I would put money on their both being 90 degrees :D

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#17

Re: Safe assumption...

Mark Hennebury

Everyone is entitled to work to whatever level of accuracy is enough for them.

Verifying accuracy however is about establishing the truth.

That truth is established by understanding the principles and following correct procedures.

Plastic squares may indeed be more accurate than any woodworker ever needs, but this discussion was about high precision measuring instruments and a procedure was offered by Howard to verify the accuracy.

The fact is that procedure recommended by Howard, in this instance with two unknown squares will not verify 90° and i thought that it should be pointed out and explained why it wont.

You can check unknown squares against a reference square this way, but not two unknown squares against each other.

This is about precision and referencing, and bears little to do with practical accuracy:

Putting two squares of unknown accuracy back to back to check is, as you say pretty good odds that they are accurate and good enough for most of us.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#18

Re: A Curiosity About Accuracy

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Tom, you are correct - I am a retired Engineer, and one of my last assignments was as the Management Representative for the QS-9000 and ISO programs. A large part of that job was insuring that all our measurement standards used in our inspection processes were directly traceable to the NIST.

Many of our instruments were calibrated to +/- .0001, while others (our standards) were required to be far more accurate sometimes to +/-.00001 or less. The only reason I keep very accurate instruments is to verify the ones I use in the shop to align my tools. Granted it doesn't really matter if a board is off square by a few thousands across 6" of width, but I don't want to saw it that way. Then it becomes an error that may compound when the board moves.

It really doesn't take much longer to set up my CMS, Band & Cabinet saw, planer, Joiner and Morticer to very close tolerances than to be sloppy about it, and helps when combined with the wood movements and my lack of talent :)>. I keep a "certified" square in my tool chest that I use to verify my squares once in a while. Its not too hard to "adjust" a dropped square if it is out of square.

I have a full set of Starrett Mikes I picked up at a garage sale for little money (doesn't appear to be used) and a few Mitutoya and Starrett calipers that were discarded due to tip damage (inside measurement) as they were out by .001 - Not an issue for my use! It just makes sense to me to eliminate any "errors" I can - makes up for some of mine.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#19

Re: A Curiosity About Accuracy

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Yes....thanks. I'm certainly not against accuracy. But for all the effort I take to measure my tools for accuracy, there appears to be a host of factors that affect the wood components I make for my work. Things like:

- Runout

- Humidity/temperature

- Sanding/scraping

- Wood's own movement (or temper)

- My handling thru the machines

Those are just to name a few. Each part I make for a piece of furniture might go thru dozens of processes, each one that might contribute to the size and squareness of that piece. So that caused me to wonder how much it mattered if I used my "decent" grade measuring tools versus more expensive super accurate tools.

In the end, if a wood component ends up out of square, I have a solution...lots of glue and really strong clamps! ;-)

T.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#20

Re: A Curiosity About Accuracy

Robert Fuller

Not to beat a post to death, but when working with wood there is a limit to how accurate you need to be, and I think most of these posts go beyond that limit. If I have a run out of under .02 over a length of 4', I really am quite happy.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#21

Referencing to prevent accumulating error

Mark Hennebury

I did a lot of fairly complex joinery with machines, and so tried to establish procedures to negate accumulating errors in the many operations.

I always set up my tools and equipment as accurately as i could.

I marked reference faces and edges and organized work flow for minimal hand / body movement, quick visual reference and minimal mental distraction.

Although i did each operation as accurately as i could; when setting up the next operation I always worked with the assumption that the previous operation could have introduced errors.

I tried to understand the possible errors of each operation/ cut/machine/ stop / fence etc and how it would effect the next operation, I then set the stops for the current operation and to negate the effect of the errors that could have been introduced by the prior operation. Doing this on each step for the entire job.

By re-referencing at each step you don't accumulate errors and can get complex parts to come together with a high degree of accuracy and ease.



Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#22

Re: Obviously you are correct!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

and I try to do the same, as I believe most WW's have to when insuring decent fits - (I also have a pretty good set of heavy duty Bessy Clamps which helps "retrain" some stubborn pieces! Still for the small effort required to keep my machines accurate in order to minimize corrections later, I feel it is worth the time. Any aid I can use to make my limited skill set work is worth it to me!:<)

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#23

Hey, no fair . . .

Bob Lang

. . . showing actual work in a thread like this.

Bob Lang

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#24

Re: Third square needed.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

When I have purchased large framing squares at Borgs, I always use three (3) squares. When I have found 2 that fit as above (back to back on a level surface), then try a third square against each of the first two. If they are off and have complementary angles the third will prove it - if it fits without light (or with the same gap) with both, the issue of complementary angles is proven moot. I learned this from a retired Pattern maker over 50 year ago.

Re: Best 14" To 18" Square???

#25

Re: Hey, no fair . . .

Mark Hennebury

Hey Bob,

Point is everyone has their own idea of what they feel is necessary when it comes to accuracy; to some 1/16" is great to others 0.001" is too much.

Some say that it doesn't matter with wood, but reality is, that is just an opinion and may be fine for that person.

I did a lot of work with wood where a couple of thou was a big deal ...to me, it meant the difference between lids not fitting the way i wanted them or gaps

( strike me dead ) in joints.

So precision in woodworking depends on the type of person you are and the type of work you do, and there is room for all opinions.

I personally think that you should do woodworking as accurately as it can be done, but that's just me, Other obviously think differently: see below

My Daughter recently sent me a couple of photos of a table that her friend had made in Ottawa recently; They call it "Rustic"