Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

Posts

Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#1

Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

sputre

I am building a nightstand of my own design. It is fairly simple craftsman-style with 6"wide aprons joined to 1.5" square legs.

The standard leg-to-apron joint is M&T. Since the apron is 6" wide, I want to allow for seasonal movement. Therefore I have to cut tenons on the apron top and bottom, and use a pin and slot in the lower tenon to allow the joint some slide.

It seems like it would be a lot less work to use a sliding dovetail joint here instead of the dual M&T with pin, and intuitively I think the dovetail would be plenty strong for such a small table with wide apron. The dovetail would be pinned at the top, leaving the apron plenty of movement along its width but tightly held in the lateral direction.

In searching the web and the FWW Index, I have found no mention of using sliding dovetails to join legs to aprons. Am I missing some feature of this joint that would make it too weak or unsuitable for this?

Thanks!

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#2

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

paul in AZ

Double M&T joints for a small table like this seems like overkill to me.

One old "rule" for doubling up is if the apron width is more than 10 times the thickness. That makes it 7.5 inches for the usual 3/4" apron.

If climatic movement is a concern I'd look at making a single tenon of 2 to 3 inches, perhaps placing it a little above center.

I also like pinned M&T joints for both security and the look. A pinned M&T invariably gets favorable comments.

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#3

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

William Duffield

There must be a reason that no one uses a sliding dovetail for this application, and all the furniture that has held together for centuries uses mortise and tenon apron to leg joinery. In my experience a double tenon for a six inch wide apron is unnecessary.

A sliding dovetail is much more fragile than a M&T for this application, and the M&T is much easier to make and to fit. Tripod tables and candle stands do use sliding dovetails, but are either equipped with a metal spider when they are built, or one is added later when they fail.

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#4

besides that,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

if the apron is 6" wide, the tenon will likely be around 5" and any movement wouldn't amount to enough to worry about anyway.

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#5

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

Chris Friesen

If the width of the tenon worries you, make it narrower (3-4" perhaps) and then add a stub tenon for the rest of the width to prevent the apron from warping against the leg. Only the narrow (but longer) part would get glued.

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#6

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

Don Stephan

A sliding dovetail would require that the "slot" would extend all the way to the top of the leg. A twisting force could split the top of the leg apart. My understanding is that this is why apron to leg mortises are generally closed or haunched.

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

#7

Re: Leg-to-Apron joinery Q

Barry Irby

I agree with Chris and most of the others. OTOH I have made a number to small table and candle stands with Three legs attached to the central post with sliding dovetails. Mine were carefully fitted and thoroughly glued, but they were only about four inches wide. They seemed very strong and have not failed and do not have spiders. I still think Chris has it right. Use a three or three and a half inch wide deep tenon and the stub tenons on each side and do not glue the stubs. I believe the M& T joint gets most of its strength from its ability to resist the tenon being extracted from the mortise. The shoulders on the tenon help convert the withdrawal forces to resist the racking. The same forces might split the shoulders on the leg if you use the sliding dovetail on a slender leg.