Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

Posts

Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#1

Alan Young

Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

Alan Young

I'm building a large (48" x94" when finished) top or a kitchen Island.


The island is in a kitchen (SE Michigan) with windows on the North Wall


I think I'd like to use Waterlox for the finish but am not certain if this needs a Marine Finish product or the non-marine finish. It seems then there is a product labeled Sealer/Finish and a Product labeled "Finish". Are these different products? Is the difference just the sheen ie Satin or Gloss?

Finally do I need this same product to finish the underside?

Thanks for the assistance,

-Alan

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#2

Re: Waterloox finish for Walnut Top

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That will look lovely on your walnut top however I know from personal experience that it will not last. It is too soft a finish for a working top like a kitchen island. I did my daughter's Island in waterlox [Sealer followed by gloss] rubbed out to a great soft sheen and it looked great for a week until somebody made the mistake of putting a hot pot on it. Took all of 3 seconds to melt a ring into the finish. We wound up refinishing the top with General Enduro Clear Poly with added cross-linker.

Yes, I would put at least 2 coats of sealer on the underside to even out moisture uptake, especially for a cabinet top where there will be less free air flow.

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#3

Re: Waterloox finish for Walnut Top

Bob Entwisle in NJ

I've gotten good responses to Waterlox related questions from

Kellie Hawkins Schaffner (4th Generation)

Vice President | Waterlox Coatings Corporation

(khawkins@waterlox.com)

You might want to email your questions to her.

I think you'd be ok with original sealer/finish for a dry (no sink) Island, but I've no direct experience in that type of application.

Hopefully others will chime in with more knowledgeable advice.

(and of course try it out on scrap before you commit:))

Bob in NJ

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

Ellis Walentine

I have maple countertops and a mahogany island top in my kitchen. I made the island top about 20 years ago and finished it at the time with Waterlox "Transparent", which has undergone several reformulations to make it more VOC compliant. The current product is called Sealer and Finish. It is a gloss product that comes in a yellow and red can nowadays and costs about ten times what I used to pay for Transparent.

If I'm not mistaken -- which I occasionally am these days -- they put up the same product with the label "Marine Finish" to get around the early VOC nomenclature, when marine finishes were exempt from the regulations. I don't even know what they make nowadays, so I can't help with that, but the regular Sealer & Finish is what most people refer to as "Waterlox" and it is fine for most woodworking projects. I don't recommend it for work surfaces unless you want a worn sort of look. Waterlox is a relatively soft finish and doesn't stand up well to abrasion, although it is otherwise quite serviceable for this sort of use, as it is impervious to moisture and most other assaults.

In contrast, I finished my countertops with four coats of polyurethane, and they're holding up very nicely fifteen months later. Of course, I use cutting boards and trivets and such to keep them from getting damaged, but the urethane is the way to go. As I recall, I just used some kind of Minwax spar urethane (I suspect that's an oxymoron) from the borg, but I'm sure there are better and harder ones out there, such as the cross-linked brand Mark mentioned.

So, I'd say consider the customer. If they want a nice pristine countertop that will retain its original sheen for a longer time, go with polyurethane. For a workmanlike finish that will be a little funkier but not have the somewhat plastic feel of urethane, go for Waterlox or some other similar varnish like General's Seal-A-Cel, which is what my pal David Marks uses a lot.

One other tidbit: Waterlox is a wiping varnish, which just means it is a dilute varnish, so you're paying for a lot of thinner for the sake of being able to apply thin, wiped coats. This is a major factor for a lot of folks, myself included, who don't have a spray room or who don't have a dust-free atmosphere for thicker coats of varnish to dry dust-free. For a situation where you want to get a nice build, I would brush it on. Otherwise, wiping only lays down a very thin film, and you throw the rest away with the rag. Build several coats, level the last one and then wipe on a thin finish coat for a nice smooth finish.

Anyhow, this is my take on Waterlox and working surfaces. YMMV

Ellis

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#5

Alan Young

OK-A Few More questions....

Alan Young

Thanks guys for the Waterlox primer. I was/am? leaning towards this finish because I used it on a smaller Walnut Island top for these same clients 4 or five years ago. This was in a different house:


They liked the finish and wanted the same for this new house they are building. I will present the poly options to them in light of the "softer" finish of the Waterlox.

I am still a little confused by some of what I have read. Perhaps the Marketing folks at Waterlox are very crafty? This is from their webpage:

Waterlox permeates wood surfaces and actually becomes part of the wood itself to resist moisture, dirt, household chemicals, alcoholic beverages, heat and cold and to provide an unprecedented finish.

Questions:

1.

Mark-Did the Waterlox need longer to cure to keep the hot pot from leaving a ring? I used the Enduro Clear Poly on a Table last year- I am sure it is a great hard durable finish but the look was awful, and I won't put that on something this massive. If the Waterlox won't work I will at least look for something with a warmer natural look.

2.

If Waterlox is soft why does it seem to be such a popular choice for floor finishes?

3.

Ellis you say:

For a workmanlike finish that will be a little funkier but not have the somewhat plastic feel of urethane, go for Waterlox or some other similar varnish like General's Seal-A-Cel

I like that word "workmanlike" but it seems to contradict the "soft finish" characteristic both you and Mark use to describe Waterlox. So can I see workmanlike as say an "honest" or "natural" finish as opposed to the plastic look and feel of a urethane-especially waterborne?

Finally

4.

If after all is considered and the clients still prefer the Waterlox, Can I seal the bottom side with a less expensive product?

Thanks for fleshing this out.

-Alan

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#6

Re: OK-A Few More questions....

John in NM

The different Waterlox products are quite different from one another. I prefer the sealer/finish because it is amazingly easy to apply. I've used the marine finish once, and it was much thicker and more like poly.

I don't think I would expect any poly or oil finish to stand up well under assault from hot pans... its not like it's stone after all - most stone will take it, unless someone has poured plastic on it too. Marble might be the one exception to that.

I would probably coat the underside with something cheaper, like poly or Watco. The moisture transmissivities are likely to be a bit different, but not enough to matter.

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#7

Re: OK-A Few More questions....

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The "lox" was cured for several months. While I had no way of measuring the film thickness, I'll guess it was fully cured before I delivered it. It was a lovely finish but scratched easily and, of course, was never meant to be able to stand up to a hot skillet. I rather doubt the Enduro would have escaped unharmed either.

That said, consider these:

This is a detail of Memsahib's Nokashima-style walnut slab coffee table.

The finish is off-the-gun Enduro [3 coats with added cross-linker] over an application of Waterlox Sealer and a tie coat of Ultra-pale dewaxed shellac.

Next is a slab corner table that makes the set.

Finish is Enduro over shellac but without the oil.

While the client has been protective [toucha my table, I breaka you face ;) ] they have both held up quite well to drips, spills, and abrasions for several years.

[ps - the tables have too :D]

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#8

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Floor finishes can be a different store. I know a old-time floor man who would only use McKlosky's Gym-Seal (for basketball court), a tung oil finish, because it was a softer finish that would dent but not scratch and chip when stuff was moved around on it.

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#9

Re: Waterloox finish for Walnut Top

Howard Acheson

Waterlox Sealer/Finish will work just fine for your top as long as the surface is not used for choppng and cutting or other aggressive food preparation. Waterlox actually stands up to heat to about 140-160 degrees but the trick is that you must allow the finish to fully cure. This takes 4 - 8 weeks for oil based finishes. Once the finish has fully cured, it will stand up to heat as well as other oil based finishes. Waterlox is also a very rugged finish due to its phenolic based resin. It was initially developed for use on gym floors and still is today. It is a harder finish than any of today's urethane varnishes.

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#10

PPS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Couple coats of shellac will seal the underside nicely. Ain't going to get much cheaper than that. ;)

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#11

Alan Young

Re: OK-A Few More questions....

Alan Young

Mark-Those pieces are a delight-And I see you "undercoated" them first with 1.Waterlox and Shellac and 2 Shellac. Had I done that to the Table I refereed to in my original post I may have had a better impression of the Enduro. I used the enduro as the only finish and just found it dull and lifeless-This is the table-Hickory with three sprayed coats of Enduro Waterborne Poly


Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#12

Waterbornes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

are great finishes, but the "self-sealing" description is bs. They raise the grain and look muddy. The dewaxed shellac allows the grain to "speak" and I wouldn't do without it. Caution here: Use only freshly mixed shellac. Once it begins to esterize [sp] after 6 weeks or so, you run the increasing risk of cold checking under the top-coat. In any event, keep the shellac application thin (just enough to pop and seal the grain) and then build with the waterborne for clarity and depth.

Re: Waterlox finish for Walnut Top

#13

Re: Your Table

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

With all that natural color in the Hickory grain, I've no doubt that a touch of oil and a tie of shellac would have made a world of difference. I liked it the first time you posted it; still do.

Remember too, that a great option with both shellac and good waterbornes like General and Target is that you can tint them with alcohol dyes like Jeff Jewitt's TransTint. I actually prefer tinting with dye to using the other grades of shellac because I can make very subtle pushes toward red for warmth or blue to cool or even tone down too much grain contrast by going to a brown tint without having to deal with yellow.