Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Torsion box sandwich panels?

Posts

Torsion box sandwich panels?

#1

Torsion box sandwich panels?

Josh

I am looking to build a moveable kitchen island with a heavy-duty, high quality countertop that will be used for cutting and food prep. I have been researching torsion boxes a lot because of their high strength-to-weight ratio. Since I never built one before, the first prototype was a complete disaster. I searched for torsion box manufacturers on Google and found a company called Singcore, which manufactured lightweight "honeycomb" panels (which means torsion box panels judging by the drawings on their website http://www.singcore.com). Does anyone think this would be a good alternative to use as a countertop? I am thinking about a panel that is about 4 inches thick.

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

Clint Searl

Sounds inappropriate to me. Why not just butcher block?

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#3

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that sounds pretty thick. Take a look at this:

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#4

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

Dick Coers

A torsion box usually has thin skins too. If you are going to use solid stock for the skin, wood expansion is going to be a problem with inner laminations.

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#5

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

Don Stephan

Is there something you'll be doing that would require a top 4" thick? Or is the moveable island design requiring a torsion box? The box would give you thickness and stiffness but not a surface suitable for cutting/chopping. Can you give some more info?

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#7

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

TomD

The key to making these things in the real world is epoxy With epoxy the parts only need to touch they don't need to be perfect. Probably the best core for something like what you are planing would be balsa core, but you can use any light wood cut into pieces so that the wood runs vertical in the core. This stuff is rock solid, and there aren't any gaps.

Craft paper cores are also really good, but they run more to the light end of the spectrum and less to the solid, but if that is what you want they should be good.

The marks kind of approach is way too complicated, and does not yield a particularly good structure, for one thing it isn't end grain orientation of the wood grain.

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#8

Ellis Walentine

Some considerations

Ellis Walentine

If the 4" thickness is important for the aesthetic you want to create, and cutting and food prep are the intended uses, I would advise against torsion box construction, for a couple reasons. The main reason is, as someone mentioned, torsion boxes are constructed with skins of man-made materials, such as plywood or MDF, neither of which would be acceptable for countertop use. One possible exception that I would have to think about before suggesting it seriously would be to make the torsion box with Corian or some other solid-surface material for the outside surfaces.; but, you seem to prefer wood, so this is probably a moot point.)

I'm with Clint on this: use solid butcher block. If it really needs to be 4" thick, you'd have to glue it up yourself, because nobody sells butcher blocks that thick. It would be a very heavy countertop, but, depending on the size of your island, weight shouldn't be a huge factor. Even very heavy cabinets can roll around quite easily on quality casters. Alternatively you could use regular 1 1/2" thick butcher block and mount it on a 2 1/2"-high skirt, set in slightly from the edge of the block in anticipation of shrinkage. Not a perfect solution, but way easier.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#9

Kitchen Island

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As mentioned, torsion box ain't great in this application. Good for doors and shelves, not work tables.

Here's one I made for my daughter.

Top is 3'x5'x1-1/2" maple I glued up with cherry accents.

The island is counter-top height and seats two plus has open storage.



She originally wanted a drying oil finish so we used Waterlox. Looked/felt great but that got wasted by the first hot pot someone put down on the top. Resanded and now "finished" with a mineral oil/wax renewable application that is perfect for a working surface.

After it was finished she "wondered" if I could make it moveable. I supplied her with ball casters that work reasonably well, but she decided against them because while chopping etc. the whole thing wanted to move. If you go with casters, make sure they're the heavy and double locking type or you'll wind up with a jiggly table.

Re: Torsion box sandwich panels?

#10

Re: Some considerations

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

As others have said in this post and I said in my American Woodworker torsion box assembly table article, the main reason to use a torsion box for a bench top, table top, or countertop, is so you end up with a LIGHTWEIGHT, relatively strong, structure with a flat surface that will stay flat. The only advantage to be gained over a top made from properly dried (butcher block) lumber of the same thickness, is weight- not much of a consideration for a fixed counter top where the surface must be hard and durable.

The engineering principles are the same as an I-beam. An I-BEAM is NEARLY AS STRONG as a solid beam of the same dimensions, but it is MUCH, MUCH lighter because material has been removed from either side of the web (the center section).

If you have other requirements that still make a torsion box desirable for your application, don't waste time building it like David Marks- by laboriously cutting, fitting, and piecing individual web pieces. Use a dado blade and make a simple indexing jig (wood fence and guide peg which looks like a basic fixed box joint jig) to cut halved joints in full length web pieces which are quick and easy to assemble: