Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Howard in Toronto
Hi all -
I've read that using styrofoam insulation between two skins to form a torsion box is a useful alternative.
Has anyone here actually done this?
Insights? Thoughts? Opinions?
Thanks
Howard
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Howard in Toronto
Hi all -
I've read that using styrofoam insulation between two skins to form a torsion box is a useful alternative.
Has anyone here actually done this?
Insights? Thoughts? Opinions?
Thanks
Howard
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA
I have a friend that does this addition to a standard grid so that he can vacuum veneerthe surfaces without fear of collapsing the titration box.
Robin
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Barry Irby
I don't know how strong they would be in this application but you might find a piece of a SIP (structural insulated panel) and play with it. Basically two skins adhered to Styrofoam. Actually to EPS (expanded polystyrene). If you can find a local make or user, you might get some scraps cheap. They often have Oriented strand board on both sides, but might have T 1-11 plywood or even drywall.
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box *LINK*
Bruce, a MN Galoot
try this for starters:
stress skin panels
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Don Stephan
Not at all sure that all glues will adequately bond the various types of styrofoam to plywood and/or mdf.
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Dick Coers
My concern would be the height of the outside wood versus the thickness of the foam. Miss on the wood height, and you don't have a flat panel. I would also be concerned about the accuracy of the foam thickness over the entire panel. That's not precision stuff.
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
A lot depends on the design and purpose.
I made a two place airplane from fiberglass foam sandwich. There was a strong epoxy bond between the fiberglass skins and foam core which is important. It was strong but flexible, but didn't do well with point surface loads, because of the thin, flexible skin. When people questioned the sanity of building a plane from "foam" I would pull out a sample 3/8" thick fiberglass-foam-fiberglass sandwich panel, support it between two cinder blocks and stand on it without it breaking. A similarly built torsion box would not be appropriate for a bench where you might clamp or hammer on its surface.
A torsion box is like joined I-beams- strength depends on the height of the shear web (the center section. in your case the foam)- thicker is better. While there are some compression and tension stresses on the shear web, its main purpose is to keep the skins apart. Strength also depends on the ability of the skins to resist tension and compression along their surface, not perpendicular to them.
Here is picture of an 8' long by 18" wide torsion box I made for an article I wrote for American Woodworker a few years ago. It is made completely from thin hardboard and yellow glue, yet it is strong enough to support over 300 lbs. mid-span, yet deflects only 1/2" in the center.

Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Rick w
Yes, I have done this.
Several years ago, I made some panels for a traveling exhibit. They measured about 3' by 7', and had a 3/4" by 1-1/2" frame with a 1-1/2" thick styrofoam core and 1/8" luan ply outer skins. I assembled the frame, cut the styrofoam to fit, and used water-based contact cement (3M Fastbond 30) to join it all together. After the panels were assembled, I placed them in a vacuum bag, to get a firm bond and even pressure.
The panels were used in the traveling exhibit for over 10 years, and I had no problems with de-lamination.
I framed some of the panels to have an cut-out opening through them. I left the styrofoam out of the space for the opening, leaving a void inside the panel. When I opened the vacuum bag after pressing, the panel imploded in that area! I was able to use the panels anyway, but it was an unpleasant surprise.
Rick W
Re: Styrofoam Centre for Torsion Box
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
Vacuum bagging with a torsion box made with a thin cell type shear web like I show in my photo above is easy. You can't make it with foam however. A torsion box makes a nice flat table that won't collapse under pressure. All you need to do is seal the bag to the top skin and drill a small hole in the bottom skin in each cell. The hole allows atmospheric pressure to equalize so the torsion box is not crushed because pressure is applied to inside of the top skin.