Re: problem staining wood putty
Robert
Liz,
What was specified with the contractor regarding the banister? Is it original to the home or did he purchase one for the job? If he purchased a new one, did you specify before he started the job that the railing was going to be stained?
If he knew beforehand that you intended it to be stained, AND you have proof of that knowledge in writing (i.e. a signed contract or work order) and then purchased an inferior product and tried to fix it with filler, then you should ask him to replace the railing with a better one. If however there was no prior communication, or if it was verbal, then you most likely will have to go with one of the solutions offered above.
One possible solution other than replacing the railing entirely, if it is a straight section of railing you could have a COMPETENT woodworker wrap the railing with veneer, although the cost to do this would probably be the same if not more than just purchasing a new railing. I had an occasion where a homeowner wanted a railing made of an exotic lumber and I talked him into allowing me to use the veneer technique. It did work, but if the railing had been curved or had a decorative bead on it like some railings do the veneer never would have worked.