Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT: Smoke detector alarms

Posts

OT: Smoke detector alarms

#1

OT: Smoke detector alarms

Merle

We built a new house 5 years ago and I am certain the contractor installed the cheapest smoke alarms that he was able to find in the bargain basement of the discontinued, odd lots, no-name, off shore junk store. Since very shortly after we moved in, various ones have beeped for no reason sporadically. We told him about it and he had someone look at them, but nothing really changed. They receive power from the house and have battery back up power. I believe they also communicate with each other so that if there ever were a fire in one part of the house, they would all beep.

I have replaced batteries and vacuumed them out and still various ones will infrequently beep for no reason. I would like to replace them with a reputable brand. Can anybody tell me which is the best manufacturer/model for my situation? I am okay with basic electrical connections. Are there any special tools, features, tricks, etc, to wiring interconnected smoke alarms? Any other options, suggestions or guidance?

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#2

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

Barry Irby

I don't have any learned information as to which brand is best, but recently installed some made by Kidde and they are doing fine.

I Also checked with some of my Home Inspector buds and they recommend the Photo-electric version and not the Ionization type. The Ionization type detect the fumes or products of combustion. The problem is that most residential fires are the smoldering type and by the time they set off the ionization type you have been dead for a while. The photo electric type "see's" the smoke particles and go off much earlier.

As to the wiring, its simple and has been interchangeable on all the ones I have worked on. Basically Black wire provides power, white wire is the neutral, and the red wire interconnects them so that they all go off if any of them go off. You may find small plugs already wired and they may be interchangeable.

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#3

Thanks, Barry 


Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#4

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

Bill Howatt

I have a unit that incorporates both types of detection. While the odds may favor one type, there are no guarantees it will be the best type if you have a fire.

Bill

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#5

Ours did that too...

John in NM

Don't you just love technology :D

The beeping I could live with, but then they also started going off at 3 am for no reason at all. Odd thing was though they were interconnected alarms, the spurious alarms happened independently - apparently that model went to market with absolutely no testing at all.... I think they were Kidde too.

We've not yet replaced them, I wish they still made the ones we had when I was a kid, just took a 9v battery and worked reliably whenever mom burned a pizza :D

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#6

Re: Ours did that too...

Barry Irby

The ones I bought were powered buy a Lithium Ion battery that was sealed and not removable or replaceable. Did not have 120 volt power. When they die you replace them, but have an expected life of ten years. You put a little disc on the wall or ceiling and twisted the detector into place and the act of installing it turned it on. Seemed pretty slick.

I was somewhat over whelmed by the technology. They had many combinations. Photo electric and CO, Co and raw gas, plug in units, hard wire and battery backup. On and on. I tried to find ones that were photo electric, battery powered, and wirelessly interconnected. They had the ones that met all that except they were the ionization type. So I went with photo electric throughout and the one for the kitchen also picks up CO. The one at the top of the steps has LED lights to show the way out.

I did an inspection for a couple from India. I asked them if they understood the smoke detectors and the husband said, "Oh Yes!, Indian cooking always sets off the smoke detector."

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#7

I like the sound of that battery...

John in NM

Seems to me some of the problem with these that I have lies in their complexity. A unit with a long life battery that is basically disposable makes more sense than line power and alkaline backup. If I remember correctly, the ionization units have a limited life in any case.

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#8

Re: I like the sound of that battery...

Bill Howatt

I think the 10 year replacement recommendation is based on keeping within the low failure rate period and is not ionization or photoelectric dependent. It is not related to the decay half-life (432 years) of americium-241 contained in the ionization units.

Some jurisdictions in Canada require that new construction be wired with 120V powered alarms and this may certainly be the case elsewhere. This is because of the number of alarm failures due to battery removal.

Bill

Re: OT: Smoke detector alarms

#9

Re: I like the sound of that battery...

John in NM

I had understood the change in sensitivity to be related to surface oxidation, not radioactive decay. It may well have been a bunch of hogwash, I never checked up on it.

Yes, that is why they now have line power units with battery back ups. If I remember correctly they are required in new construction by the IRC, same down here as in Canada - but I may not be remembering correctly, always a risk :D

Kind of funny that the system intended to fix the problem of people removing weak batteries and not replacing them actually works less well than what it's trying to fix.