Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

Posts

OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#1

OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

Barry Irby

Local news just ran a story about waste at city hall. They leave the lights on all the time. Building looks like a bad Christmas Tree even on Sunday when no body is there. Turns out the building was built with a flexible floor pan that allows walls to be easily moved around and as a result, there are very few light switches. The claim was that the electric bill is about a million bucks a year.

Its a dim recollection, but I took a course on this stuff in college, back when you had to outrun dinosaurs to get to class. As I recall, the argument was that fluorescent lights suffer from being turned on and off and it basically cuts bulb life in half. So, if you turn them off 12 hours a day, they last about as many days as if they were left on all the time. That means you still have to replace the bulbs just as often and you do not double their apparent life. If you factor in the cost of the switches it might save enough to run the lights a long time. Another consideration was something called power factor. In buildings with three phase power you can run the lights, using them to absorb or adjust the current between the phases, (or some such mumbo jumbo) effectively running them for free. We were told that the reason they put light switches into commercial buildings was the public would not believe it actually was more effective to just let them run.

(I suspect they are on a campaign to install switches and turn out the lights and will find they have spent a fortune and save very little. It might also be the problem that the building basically has a glass exterior which means we can see them wasting light, but the heat bill might be the real problem.)

So whats the real truth here? Anybody know or know where to get a real answer?

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#2

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

Jason Waters

Barry,

I can't tell you a real answer, but food for thought:

My office has 6 30W T-8 bulbs. So that's 180W. I work 8 hours with a 1 hour lunch, so let's say the light is on 9 hours a day. That's 1620W in a day. Now most people work about 50 weeks a year (2 weeks vacation) times 5 days a week is 250 days. subtract about 10 holidays and 5 sick days, so let's say 235 days. So 1620Wx235 is 380,700Wh or 380.7 kWh. Let's say the electric cost is $0.095 per kWh (commercial rate). These are all representative for me.

So that's 380.7x0.095=$36.17

If I left the lights on all the time, it would be (8760 hours in a year)

180Wx8760hx1kWh/1000Whx0.095=$149.80

That's a difference of $113.63. Based on experience the bulbs last at least 3 years (or about 6345 hours being turned on and off), let's see if we can figure the difference over 6 years, assuming that it does cut life in 1/2:

Lights out (at night):

$108.51 Electricity

$120.00 Bulbs (assume $10 each, replace twice in 6 years)

$100 Labor to change ($50 each time)

That's $328.51 for 6 years or $54.75 per year

Lights on all the time

$449.40

$60.00 Bulbs (assume $10 each, one set)

$50 Labor to change ($50 after 6 years)

That's $559.40 for 6 years or $93.23 per year

Ok, so I know the bulb cost and labor to repalce is probably high, but I used the same number for both. If you look at the numbers, it's clear to see the electric cost is the driving component. Redo it for your 12 hour on and off scenario and post it for fun? Or better yet, keep solving to find the break even point.

Multiple my office by however many offices you think there are on a floor, adjust for the electric rate in your area (usually commercial is cheaper but not always), etc.

I'm not an EE, but I can't imagine balancing a load with lights. Unless it was a 24/7 factory. Most motors are 3 phase in commercial, eliminating the balance issue mostly anyway.

So I think it pays to turn the lights off.

Jason

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#3

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

Jason Waters

P.S.,

you will find there will still probably be lights on in the building. Usually a few here and there are hardwired as a safety mechanism. But it's probably 5-10 percent.

So you can't just multiply throughout for every fixture

Jason

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#5

JL

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

JL

Three phase balancing is important. If you don't balance the load between the phases, you have problems. The power is not "free" though - you are still consuming current.

We've got three phase power in the playhouse (and at the church). Last year when we had the electrical reworked at the playhouse it was important to balance the load. If you have too much current consumed on any one leg of the three phase, it creates an imbalance. This leads to power fluctuations and other not good things. For theatrical lighting, it can really mess up your expensive bulbs and lights. The church was a similar case when it was upgraded to three phase. The electricians had to balance the load.

As far as the bulb issue - I can't really say. All I know is I turn my CFL lights off and on on a regular basis. I've some bulbs that have lasted for a couple years and they are still going. Some have lasted not quite as long.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#6

Mythbusters research

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

One one show they mythbusted the idea that turning lights off shortened the life.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#7

Thanks, everybody....

Barry Irby

I read one of the articles and scanned the other. This is much more complicated that I thought and it would seem at first glance.

I wonder how LED's will affect these calculations?

As an aside, I bought about a hundred CFL bulbs for about $20 when they were on special at Lowe's. I remodeled a house for my son and we got to the fixtures for the front door. They had dusk to dawn sensors on them and specifically said not to use CFL's. I ignored the instructions and used what I had, thinking I would find some incandescent bulbs the next time I went to the store. I figured they would be OK for a few days. NOT they were both dead the next morning. Something about the circuit causes them to flicker and they cycle themselves to death in short order. Not a big loss and lesson learned. Since then, I wire the dusk to dawn sensor out of the circuit, converting it to a regular old dumb light.

The city hall in Richmond is a huge building, maybe ten stories tall. I am guessing they will spend a fortune installing switches in the building and then no body will bother to sue them. In any event I am betting it will take years to recover the cost of the switches.

As an aside, the building has something of a checkered past. When it was built they specified thin marble for the exterior to save money over thicker material. A few years later it was noticed that the panels were bowing and failing. After much hand ringing and gnashing of teeth they decided to completely re-do the exterior. They removed the entire exterior and replaced it. I can not remember what the exterior looked like before, but I swear they recessed the new glass panels back several feet into the building, appearing to sacrifice a lot of floor space. As I recall, it used to be largely marble on the exterior with windows, now its mostly glass with some marble.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#8

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

Jason Waters

JL,

You are correct about balancing. I did not mean to imply that 3 phase balancing was not important. I meant to say that I would not think an EE would use a set of lights to balance the other loads, but rather try to distribute the balancing in a different manner. That might mean balancing 1/3 of the lights on each phase, particularly those meant to be on at the same time.

Again, I'm not an EE, so I will leave balancing the electical phase load to them.

Anyway, it saves money to turn off the lights, not to mention pollution from the generating plant.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#9

About that Marble.....

Barry Irby

When they took the marble off the city hall there was a lot of interest in it. People wanted it for flooring, furniture, shower stalls, whatever. The city council was so fearful somebody would buy it and then sue them for some sort of slip and fall accident or whatever, they had the contractor break it into small pieces, not really suitable for anything. Probably would have been better to crush it into chips. Seemed like a waste.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#10

Sadly

John in NM

That sort of wasteful caution is very common in our increasingly litigious society.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#11

CFL's in automatic fixtures

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Many of the day/night or motion sensor type fixtures and some of the older timer switches used the lamp as part of their circuit path. On the CFLs with electronic ballast and LEDs that means that the current from the sensor wasn't enough to allow the lamp to fire and light up, but it was enough that the electronics heated up and burned out. The newer sensors controls have three wires so they have their own neutral connection so they don't use the connected device as part of the circuit for the sensor itself.

Lee

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#12

Lights as heat source

Pat Evans

Some buildings are designed to take into account heat from light fixtures as a heat source. Many commercial buildings are designed for the lights to stay on for heat since building cleaning takes place at night anyway.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#13

Re: Lights as heat source

Barry Irby

They put LED lights into the stoplights in New York City (I think). They were expensive but were supposed to last a very long time and not require changing for many years. They also thought they would save money on electricity. Turns out the LEDs put out so little heat the stop lights got covered with ice and snow. (The older incandescent bulbs melted it off) They had to go back and install heaters in all the lights. Let's hope they can turn them off in the summer.

Re: OT Anybody a real lighting cost Expert?

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Yep.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Lafayette went gangbusters several years ago changing out stoplights with LED models, only to discover the same problem you described with ice and snow building up on them rendering them invisible to drivers. I think the solution was to install heaters. I must say though, as someone who has always had marginal vision (even with correction, still not 20/20 after surgery), the LED stoplights are visible at a much greater distance, same with the LED light bars that cops cars now use.

Jason