Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

Posts

Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

#1

Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

Barry

i am in the process of building a Shaker Bench or Footstool. The plans were in an article by Christian Becksvoort in Fine Woodworking, #231. I thought it would be a neat small project. Everything is straight forward except for chopping the through mortises in the top of the bench. I selected #1 White Pine as did the author. I am no stranger to handcut dovetails or handcut mortises. I expected the White Pine to be very easy to work, but that is not the case. Instead, I have found it to be an extremely difficult wood to work with. It is soft, and tends to tear out when I try to pare down the sides of the mortises. I have sharpened and re-sharpened my chisels, to no avail. I would appreciate any suggestions.

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

#2

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

AlanWS

Paring pine endgrain is a very stringent test of sharpness -- considerably more so than paring hardwood. You could try using a more acute sharpening angle, and taking a smaller bite in each cut. The other thing to keep in mind is that soft pine will also compress more easily, so the fit does not need to be quite as precise as with harder wood.

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

#3

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've never been successful at chopping pine end grain, for the reasons that Alan states. Paring, when the chisel is sharp enough to split frog hair, yes; but it collapses under any heavier treatment.

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

#4

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

Jim B

I built that stool last week out of pine...can't get white pine up here in the NW...not sure what variety of pine it was. I didn't really have any problem "chopping" the mortises but I use an angle of ~18 degrees...something I learned from Rob Cosman...works well for pine but not on a hardwood. Fun project...challenging if you are doing it all by hand...

JimB

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

#5

Re: Shaker Bench from Fine Woodworking

Steve Kirincich

I have recently built the small bench and would suggest rough chopping the mortises from both directions. I think that if your final chisel work is done with a paring chisel you should be fine, but planing or sanding the top after assembly would be prudent.

Steve