Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Posts

Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#1

Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

David Weaver

I'm about to start building cabinets for my kitchen, and the wall cabinets will be 1/2" veneer core ply.

The cabinets that I have on the wall are also ply, they're probably 40+ years old. None of them have ever come down, despite my wife's love for very heavy dishes (fiestaware).

Strength in the new cabinets is at the top of the list. I could make them out of 3/4" ply and just screw them all over the place, but I don't want to do that. I think instead of rabbeting the backs to glue the back on, I'll recess the back in 1/2" from the back edge of the side, seat it in a dado and all of the shelves will be in a dado 1/4th of an inch into the cabinets or therabouts.

That will give me room behind the back to install a 1/2" thick hardwood cleat and have a little more meat to go through. I don't want screws and plugs on the sides.

Glue will be TB III, joints should be fairly tight?

Do I have anything to worry about? Experience in answering is appreciated, thus far I have triple overbuilt everything, but I don't want to put bulky cabinets on the wall.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#2

JL

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

JL

Mine are 3/4". IMO, if you have a 1/2" or 3/4" back (which I do) - you should have no worries about even needing a hardwood cleat.

I've got my pie plate collection (stoneware and glass), my French white Corningware and similar things up in my cabinets. I did do a dado for one of my shelves and that is glued in. The other shelves have shelf pins.

My shop cabinets are hung with French cleats (3/4") and those have similar construction.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#3

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

david weaver

I was going to dado all of the shelves and rebate the back on. I'm not worried about the strength initially, but don't know how the glue will hold up.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#4

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Dick Coers

I like to put in a hardwood cleat. I biscuit in a 3/4"x2 1/2" cleat, inside the rabbett for a 1/4" thick back. I put those in top and bottom. I screw in the back, and screw it to the cleats. Maybe overkill, but not taking any chances with all that weight.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#5

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

david weaver

Yeah, I guess I should have clarified that I don't feel the need for a cleat for strength, but instead I want the cleat because it will give me a flush fit with the wall and still allow me to dado the back in instead of rabbet.

The overall concern here was that almost 20 years ago when I worked in a cabinet factory, the backs were rabbeted in and glued with hot melt. I saw some 25 year old hot melt a couple of years ago and it still had a good grip in the cabinets we were disassembling.

I don't have as much faith in PVA glue over that period of time. If the hot melt is impacted, it gives and springs back.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#6

Kneale Brownson

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Kneale Brownson

Done properly, the glue would be stronger than the wood.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#7

JL

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

JL

Don't worry about the yellow glue (Titebond I, II, or III type) - it will last for years (as will hide glue). If a joint is properly done that is.

Upper cabinets don't see the moisture that lower cabinets see.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#8

Ellis Walentine

Overkill

Ellis Walentine

Hi David,

This probably sounds like heresy, but save yourself a ton of work with no loss of functionality (or danger of failure) by screwing the backs on to your 3/4" sides. Skip the rabbets and glue. I use a cleat under the cabinet and just screw the back into studs and screw the cabinets to each other. I just finished my own kitchen this way, and my old partner, who built the boxes for me, always does it this way. I've built several kitchens myself over the years, and specified and installed others.

Also, there's no reason not to use shelf rests and make your shelves adjustable. Four rests under a 3/4" shelf will hold as much weight as you will ever put on them.

This attitude is neither lazy nor reckless, and reflects a long-held belief of mine about architecture vs. furniture. Cabinets and other architectural woodwork are built into your house and become part of the real estate, as opposed to furniture, which is discrete and portable. I prefer to reserve the more labor-intensive and showy construction methods for furniture and keep cabinetry simple and as easy as possible, with the most attention paid to the facade, which is the part that people see, and the functionality (Blu-motion slides, quality hardware and plywood, etc.).

All this is not to say you shouldn't build these cabinets any way that makes you happy, but you don't need to go overboard on fabrication.

Ellis

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#9

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Paul Dzioba

David,

About 20 years ago I got a frantic call from my wife. The upper cabinets were beginning to separate from the wall and she had jammed a handy wood spoon between the cabinet and counter. While we were on the phone I heard a tremendous crash. I told her to stay out of the kitchen and I would leave work and come home immediately.

Oh my God, what a disaster when I got home. There was broken glass, china, and Corelle everywhere. Over the years, she kept adding more and more into these cabinets until she broke the camels back. The hot glued and stapled backs remained on the wall; everything else was torn off and fell to the floor. Miraculously, a small portion survived.

Needless to say, I don’t think you can over build your upper cabinets.

I feel like Ellis, the cabinets are part of the architecture. I didn’t build them like my period furniture with all solid wood and completely with hand tools. I used ¾ melamine faced panels throughout except for the doors and end panels. My wife liked the white and easy maintenance of the melamine. For durability the edges were faced with ¼ thick white oak to match the doors instead of cheap veneer tape. I did full overlay frame and panel doors without face frames. For sheer strength the backs were inset and the shelves and sides were attached to the backs with biscuits. Two inch coarse thread screws went between the biscuits except where they would show on the end panels. I used ¼ x 3” lag bolts with washers through the backs, two in each wall stud, one high and one low. I don’t think you can overbuild!

Paul Dzioba

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#10

Unless you have an exposed side

Dick Coers

then what do you do Ellis? Moulding to cover the plywood edge, or recess the back?

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#11

Re: Unless you have an exposed side

David Weaver

I have lots of exposed sides. Oven hood and window right in the middle of the works.

I'll inspect the joinery of the one cabinet when I take it down, they have held impressively over the years and it looks like they are probably about 35 or 40 yeras old, maybe older. They also appear to have some sort of PVA type glue, dadoes and are entirely 1/2 inch ply.

When I called a hardwood supplier yesterday and told them I wanted 12 sheets of 1/2 inch cherry ply (yeah, I know I could get by with less on the unseen sides and backs, but it'll make the process go smoother), he said "we don't sell much in 1/2". I guess most people are using a mix of 3/4th and 1/4th, depending on what the ply is for.

Most places aren't that excited to talk to you when you say you're not a business owner until you tell them you want 12 sheets of A1 ply. I may edge band the ply shelves, I may not. I know it's conventional to do it now, but my old cabinets just were run through a router or shaper and rounded over, and with finish on they don't look that bad when you open the door.

Other than the splurge on the ply, this is a budget job since it's my house and I take the same view you guys do - I can't take it with me when I leave, it's already going to be a step or two above box store budget stuff, and that's good enough.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#12

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Richard McComas

If you're dead set on half inch plywood then this won't apeal to you but I'll put it out there anyway.

I use 3/4 material for all parts in my cabinets including the back. My glue will never fail because I don't use any and my dado joints won't fail because I don't use any. I use butt joints, no glue and the appropriate fastener for the material. Confirmat screws for Melamine, assembly screws for plywood ect.

I've built a lot of cabinet this way for the past 20 years including a bunch of them for our local school district. The ones for the school district a loaded to the hilt with all kind of heavy stuff included lot of paper and books, you know heavy that stuff gets.

I cut my cabinet tops and decks the thickness of the backs (3/4") less than the cabinet sides. I screw through the back of the backs into the tops and the decks. I screw through the cabinets sides into the backs. This is all butt joint and no glue. No nailer or cleats needed.

Shelves are adjustable so no dadoes there. Never had a cabinet box fail or come off the wall. Exposed ends are covered with one of 3 things. Veneer, matching 1/4'' plywood or an applied end panel.


Applied end panels


Famous last words, never once had a failure in 20 years

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#13

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

David Weaver

Those look great. I could change my mind on the material, but I probably won't. The great look of the raised panels on the ends of the cabinets is just about enough incentive for me to add them to show faces, despite my want to have everything be a budget job.

The beveled raised panel design confirms my hope that the narrower raised panels with a bevel look a lot better than they do with a big cove.

If my wife saw that, she'd immediately ask for that color stain. I won't show it to her as we're going clear sanding sealer and clear WB lacquer.

I come from the dark side (hand tools) and like the look of the natural cherry even though most folks seem to consider it an out of date look. Maybe in another 10 years, it'll be back in.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#14

Re: If I could impose...

David Weaver

... do you have a close-up of one of the doors, whole thing? I like the proportions of the rails and stiles to the panel and would like to ...ahem....rip off your efforts for my own benefit, so to speak.

If not, do you know about what you prefer for rails and stiles? 2 1/2" or so?

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#15

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

Richard McComas

In my first post I forgot to mention that I have also use the "plant on" method for the cabinet backs Ellis mentioned in his post. Works good also.

Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#16

Re: If I could impose...

Richard McComas

David, there is nothing wrong with natural cherry.

The cabinet are not stained. They are made of Bloodwood and that the natural color.

Here a picture of a cabinet door. The stile and rails are 2 1/4 inch wide the distance between the edge of the stile or rail to the edge of the profile on the panel is 1 1/4 inch. These were made with Freeborn's standard shaper cutters.

Not the best picture.


Re: Wall Cabinets, Strength Questions

#17

Re: If I could impose...

David Weaver

wow...bloodwood, that's a fantastic idea!

Thanks for the picture, they look great. I'll work up my line...

..."can't get that color unless we spring for bloodwood".

"cherry" where I grew up was a term people used for dark reddish brown stain. When I show people a lacquered cherry piece, they always say "that's not cherry, cherry is dark brown".