Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT-- Repiping My House

Posts

OT-- Repiping My House

#1

OT-- Repiping My House

bud

My house is over 40 years old and here in central florida that's past the time copper pipe starts to get pin holes.

My choices are either CPVC or PEX for the pipe and I'm undecided which is better, if one is. I'd like to do it myself to save the money but it would take me probably 2 years to do it - in stages of course. A plumber would take two days but charge about $2000 more then I would spend. One plumber I contacted uses CPVC and another uses PEX.

Anybody have experience using either of these pipes or doing a repipe?

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#2

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

Nat Robison

My neighbor, a plumber, helped me finish my basement which included a bathroom. He plumbed a shower, toilet, and sink in probably 45 minutes so it seemed like PEX was a big time-saver. Didn't need to be too fussy on holes through the studs and such since the PEX has some give to it. It seems like all the tools/fittings necessary for working with PEX are sold just about everywhere now.

Granted, my experience was not with re-piping a house which would add some time but so far, I have no issues with PEX.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#3

Alan Young

I'm not a Plumber and don't play one on TV but *LINK*

Alan Young

My SIL and I re plumbed my entire house last March over the course of one weekend. The rest of the remodel job took quite a bit longer. But with proper planning and an investment in the PEX crimper.(I got one crimper with 1/2,3/4 and 1" inserts) we made quick work of a job. I did hire out one section to Roto Rooter plmbers- The drain from 2nd floor to first floor- But having seen what he did I am more confident in doing the same thing if needed in the future....You can make things go even quicker if you use the Shark Bite (Home Depot brand) components that don't need the crimper-they are more expensive than the corresponding PEX components that need the rings and crimper-No regrets though for having purchased the crimper at $100.00 -Overall the parts/materials cost me under $600. Our labor was not a factor as SIL worked for beer!

-Alan


Bathroom Re-plumb and remodel

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#4

I've used both...

John in NM

CPVC is just like using PVC except its a little more freeze resistant, and smaller in OD than PVC. Cut, deburr, and glue, not much to it.

Pex is quick, due to continuous runs, and it's nice and cheap. I like it a lot. Only caution is to not expect it to be all that flexible, because it isn't. It will bend nicely in large radii, but don't plan on having to bend it much, that will slow you way down fighting with the stuff.

Also I over sized a bit - 1/2" and 3/4" just like regular pipe. The trend with Pex seems to be smaller is better, and I live in a low pressure area. If your water pressure is good - like 50 psi or so - then you probably don't have to worry about it. Come to think of it, a friend with a pressure pump and a professional Pex job still has crummy flow. Could be all those low flow fixtures though.

I used a crimping setup I got at HD that is just the heavy jaws with no handle - you use vise grips for the crimping power. Works well for the price $20 as I recall. Don't think I'd do a whole house with it though :D

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#5

Re: I've used both...

John McGaw

I like PEX and that is basically all my tame plumber will use nowadays. Before you get started you should check out the availability of fittings since there are a couple of different styles and the tools for one don't necessarily work with the other. My guy uses the style which is expanded from the inside and which uses a plastic (nylon?) ring around the outside; it is very fast to use. The other style uses a crimp-on metal band. The price difference between the two can be substantial.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#6

Re: I've used both...

R Payne

I believe CPVC is more heat resistant. I think PVC went away because code changed to not allow its use on the hot water side but CPVC is ok for hot water.

CPVC has a longer track record than PEX. The forerunner of PEX didn't last very long. Copper has a longer track record than either. The failure mode and longevity of copper is well known. It's also known for CPVC but not yet for PEX.

ron

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#7

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

Barry Irby

I have used both personally and as a Home Inspector I see a lot of each. PEX has an excellent reputation and is easy to install. You need a crimping tool and a pair of snips to cut the pipe. The crimping tool I used was about a $100 and was for the type that crimped the exterior rings of any of about four sizes. the tool worked well, but I thought the fittings were more expensive than they should have been. One handy thing is you can buy it color coded. Red for hot and blue for cold. (In case you have trouble with the "hot on the left cold on the right thing.") I did two houses with PEX and have had no problem with either.

The old Fuddy Duddy in me makes me a little skeptical of PEX. Intellectually I know its not the same thing, but it looks too much like the polybutylene or Quest pipe that was such a disaster.

I have also done a lot of CPVC. PVC is only suitable for cold water, but CPVC is suitable for both hot and cold. A pair of snippers is about all you need. If you use the Yellow glue you do not need to use the primer. Cut the pipe with what looks like pruning shears and glue the pipe and fitting and wait for the glue to set. (I'd have to read the label, but I think its about thirty minutes. I usually wait longer.) You need to be slightly more careful drilling the holes for it than for PEX, but its more forgiving than copper. Considering the cost of the fittings, I think CPVC is cheaper than PEX over all. I have completely replumbed two houses and repaired three with CPVC and had no trouble with any of them.

The Shark Bite (Home Depot) or Gator Bite (Lowe's) fittings are very expensive but very useful, especially for transitioning from one type of pipe to another. I also like the new braided supply lines for toilets and sinks.

I actually like copper best of all, but on several of the houses I have bought recently (At foreclosure) have had the copper robbed out of them. So I put back CPVC because it seems pointless to put the copper back for them to steal again. I can solder/sweat joints as well as most plumbers but it is nice to use either of the plastic pipes and not have the fire risk.

Locally copper lasts about 50 to 60 years on municipal water and only 15 on well water. One nice thing about the plastic pipe is it does not impart a taste to the water.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#8

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

Scott Greaves

Hi Bud!

I really like PEX! I have plumbed four places with it. I use the Wirsbo PEX and use the connections where you expand the tubing using a special tool, insert the brass fitting, and the tubing shrinks back onto the fitting making a secure joint. The fittings are a little pricey, but you need fewer of them because there is only one at each end of the run. The special tool is expensive, but many of the suppliers will rent them. I bought the tool and it has been worthwhile.

When replumbing it seems to take longer to cut the old plumbing out than it does to put the PEX back in. Also, each fitting you put in a run reduces water pressure a small amount. The copper and cpvc do use more fittings, so if water pressure is a concern, PEX has a slight edge. PEX has been around for quite a while, longer in Europe than in North America, and has been dependable in the long run.

Obviously, I am a fan of PEX. But it is worth a serious look. Good luck on your plumbing project!

Scott.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#9

Both heat and freeze...

John in NM

Our local code requires CPVC for hot, regular PVC can be used for cold water if it is not in a habitable structure - that is because of the way it breaks when it freezes, at least that's what the inspector told me. I've had minor freezes with both CPVC and Pex, both have come through fine.

I've always heard that they've been using Pex in Europe since the 1980's, so it seems to have a decent record. I remember that other stuff that failed, Polybutylene. Never had a house with it though. I remember being told it was more the connectors than the pipe that failed. Either way, ya get lots of water damage.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#10

Shark Bite.

basil

Thief was going to steal the plumbing from under a very low house I own. He broke/bent the plumbing and the water was still on and running when water flowed out the vents. Thankfully all I needed to make the repairs was a tubing cutter and "Shark Bites".

Shark Bites are the greatest invention since......well, at that moment....anything.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#11

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

JMOHNIKE

Check with your insurance carrier first. Some companies do not like either one of them (I am an Insurance by day and woodworker by night). There are some companies that will insure only houses plumbed in copper or surcharge a house that has been plumbed in galvanized or pvc/cpvc. I had an insured that replumbed his farm house in plex, less than a month he had a claim, the rats/mice thought it was some kind of candy, and the damage was not covered under the warranty. The insurance company paid that claim, and then issued an endorsement excludeing any further damages due to plumbing.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#12

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

Jerry Roberts

I cant remember exactly what was used in my house a couple yrs ago. Pex I think. Just a couple things. Seems that just abt everyone in my neighborhood has had problems with copper pipe pinholes. Most have been repiped. I was not satisified when I had mine done . NOw when one takes a shower and someone else turnes on the hot or cold elsewhere you either sre scalded or you freeze. Didnt do that before. I helped a frioend redo his house. Just him and me several yrs ago. He used a manifold out near where the supply came in and ran an individual pipe for each faucet. Much more pipe in the attic but he was much more satisified than I was. If I had thought abt that for mine thats exactly what I wld have done. Good luck.

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

#13

Re: OT-- Repiping My House

Brian from Monument

Recently my plumbing developed a leak.

It was at one of the corner junctions.

The junction is made of copper and joins two pieces of what looks like some variant of pvc.

So I am about to replumb the basement of my house with COPPER.

My house was built in 1994. I have seen a steady increase of a greenish buildup near the copper joints on nearly all the junctions in the basement.

Looks like most of the junctions leak.

This is where the green (copper oxide) comes from.

I hope to install cutoff valves to limit damage upstairs.

Two 2nd floor bathrooms, first floor kitchen and first floor powder room.