Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

Posts

Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#1

JL

Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

JL

I've made some Shaker peg racks for a church. Material costs are negligible - I made the pegs out of scrap cherry that I had laying around (destined for the burn pile) - and the cherry was free (except for transport costs). The birch base for the racks (about 6.5 board ft.) cost me about $1/board ft. So all in all, I've maybe $10-15 in materials and about 7 hours in labor.

I've been told by the Senior Warden and the priest to definitely charge for it. What's reasonable? I was thinking about $100.

Three racks - 2 at 54" x 4" with nine pegs each, 1 at 42" x 3.5" with 7 pegs.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#2

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

john Veerkamp

You're pricing your labor at about $12 per hour. Not much for your talent and skills. However if you want to donate some to the church, what you are proposing seems reasonable. I would be sure that the church understands that your normal recompense would be higher. Don't want to open the window to being taken advantage of in the future.

My opinion.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#3

Not greedy.

Gary Smyth

Charge your normal rate. Identify all expenses including time, the materials used, and any dedicated transport costs. If they are responsible people and you are comfortable with them, refund any portion of your fee you wish as a donation. Request and keep a letter from them acknowledging the donation. Use the donation amount on 2013 taxes.

As I view it.

Future fee structure is established. They get the service(s) you provided. You get the benefit of doing good and providing them a donation. You also reward yourself next year.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#4

Re: Not Wise

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If the tax man audits, especially since it's not "your" church, the donation will be disallowed (as an end-run around the artist donations rules) you you could get penalized and the pastor could be asked some uncomfortable questions.

Be the nice guy and either give them the stuff for the cost of materials or charge a price 20% under similar at IKEA.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#5

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

Mark Nowicki

Charge your normal rate.

Mark

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#6

Good to know

paul in AZ

I have been tempted to charge for something and give the money back for what seemed a 'cleaner' tax deduction -pure dollars and not article valuation. Never did it though. Now I'll put that thought to rest. Thanks.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#7

I must disagree

Gary Smyth

I don't want to get into a contest here but I disagree. The Internal Revenue Code provides taxpayers with a charitable contribution deduction for all donations of art work that have an ascertainable value. To qualify, you must donate the art to a qualified organization. Donations to most non-profit organizations that promote religious, educational, literary, scientific, charitable or humanitarian causes will qualify you for the deduction. Though subject to possible other limitations, the deductible amount of your donation is equal to its fair market value on the date you contribute it. If the value of your artwork is $5,000 or less, it is permissible for you to conduct your own valuation for purposes of calculating the deduction. In assessing the value, you must consider the condition of the piece and the price you can reasonably obtain in the open market. If you fail to conduct due diligence or intentionally inflate the value by 150 percent or more, the IRS may impose penalties only on the excessive amount. For artwork that is worth more than $5,000, the IRS requires you to obtain a qualified appraisal. By the way, a call to the IRS help line will provide you mental comfort. 1-800-829-1040 (for individuals)

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#8

All True, Gary, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It doesn't work for the artist.

The producing artist has, for nearly40 years, been prohibited from donating their own work and then taking a tax deduction for more than the actual cost of the materials. Time was, artists could get a nice tax deduction for work donated to charities, like fund-raising auctions, and then take a deduction for the stated value. The deduction was seriously abused by artists so special rules were formulated to prevent what amounted to tax fraud. Part of the problem was that the IRS was getting into disputes over how and who was to determine the value of a particular piece, and so they solved the problem by disallowing the whole thing.

Having the charity purchase the item at fair value from the artist and having him donate the money amounts to the same thing. But even that doesn't help because a charitable deduction is not a tax credit, so the artist must report the income. The amount he would save on his taxes with the deduction will still be less than he will pay in income tax on the net profit (price less the cost of materials).

The paradox, however, is that a collector can purchase the very same piece from the artist, donate it to the charity, and get a tax break for a) what she paid or b) the fair appraised value of the artwork.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#9

Cost of materials . . .

steve mackay

If they ASKED me to make them I'd charge cost of materials only. With that the word will spread who did it. I'd place my bets of the "back end" of the deal figuring I was going to get more work out of it from "citizens". I always think a good deed pays off down the road. But I'm kinda stupid that way.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Cost of materials . . .

Dale Lenz

Built two large signs for the town I lived in at the time. Each sign weigh in about 1000#. The grant to the city paid for the materials. I put in weeks of work, thinking I'd get some work from this afterwards, not a drop! Your milage may vary.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#11

Dale Lenz

Agree...

Dale Lenz

Your time cannot be used in tax breaks, at least not in this case. If you paid your shop helper to build the item I believe you could claim a tax donation. I always figured it had to do with; Money had to be exchanged so the IRS will get their share somewhere along the way. Anyway, only the materials you purchased and might could claim some overhead cost(?).

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#12

Bob

Been down this road

Bob

All true, You can only deduct for "Cost Of Goods".

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#13

True . . .

steve mackay

But so far so good.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#14

Was Asked

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

to do a fund-raising piece for a large national faith-based charity. The piece was a portrait head, about 4" tall, of Supreme Court Justice Charles Evan Hughes. It was to be done in bronze in a limited and signed/numbered edition of 150, each mounted on a 3x3x6 block of black marble with the donor's name etm. inscribed. The pieces were to be used as thank you's for donations to the charity of $100,000 or more.

I did the first piece after spending many hours researching old photos and paintings of the subject, and worked with the foundry, the marble guy, and a trophy engraving firm to give the charity a very nice cost basis of about $200.00 for each piece without counting my time which I figured to be 4 hours for each piece. I then discounted my own time (thinking it would be excellent advertising) and quoted them $320 for each piece, $48,000 for the whole job that was to raise $15,000,000.

They loved the piece, commenting I had produced a remarkable likeness. A week later I was called back after approval by their Board. I walked in thinking "So the discounted time worked, and all I need is the agreement and the materials deposit and we're a go."

"Silly Rabbit."

Turned out that their approved idea was for me, the starving artist with a family and only $10k in the bank, to be the first contributor by donating the entire deal, including the $30,000 cost of materials!

I really should have known better as I had had a similar experience with another smaller group. Somehow I thought "bigger is better."

Lesson learned: If you discount your own worth, you'll be viewed as having that much less value.

This was confirmed when I actually got a call from a person who had seen the Hughes piece and inquired about my doing a full size portrait. When I quoted the price they were more than a little surprised and got a bit huffy in light of what they said they expected based on my prior charity proposal.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#15

The Piece

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey


Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#16

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

TomD

There is no right in the ether answer to this. The question is what are they asking you to do in asking for a bill, and what are you thinking when cutting them a deal, though they are not your church.

Some people want a bill so that they can finally find someone who can do the work they need at a fair price, and they can keep going back to them. They may not want to get more work, if they feel you are being put out. Or maybe they have no idea what real work costs, and will go crazy if you ask for a real amount.

In your case, why would you cut a church a deal that is not your church or otherwise connected? I guess it would be all easier if we knew how Jesus used to bill churches in his neighbourhood.

I tend to either do stuff for free, or charge real prices. Neither gets me much work, I am not that great at costing jobs for what the market expects. I do find that free stuff tends not to be valued by the people who get it. We live in a very commercial world, where free verges on pathetic.

If you do select the option of charging only for materials, it might be an idea to actually cost those at a fairly hard line. Who cares if it came out of a woodpile, that is your side of the deal, their side is comparable real world suppliers of short orders of wood. It is bad enough that people burn down forests to make more room for burger cows, without giving people the idea that wood is a free. It might be a better world if the next time someone clears a lot for houses, as happened here recently, they didn't chip all the mature maples, and apple trees.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#17

Public agencies

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Keep in mind that many public agencies have procurement rules requiring them to put big jobs out to bid and have an open decision-making process that leans toward the lowest competent bidder. "Well, he did us a favor with those signs" may not fit anywhere in that process.

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#18

Dale Lenz

Re: Public agencies

Dale Lenz

With all due respect, Bill. I built those signs back in 1991....I've gone on to greener pastures. No hard feelings.....The ol' saying: Build it and they will come.....did not work for me, :).

Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#19

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Pricing work for a church (not mine)?

#20

Thanks, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

what it was was the hi-speed lane to broke!

I had turned my back on a nice tenured teaching job. My family backed me. But I learned that there was a rather nasty side to the whole art-as-business thing, and I just wasn't prepared to (or have my family) weather such storms for my art.

Sound a bit bitter? Actually not, as I learned very practical lessons that have stood the test of 30 years practicing law. I still carry my art with me, I've just found different ways to express it.