We all know it, because we are builders. This is what we need to keep in mind when we approach teaching. It's called the Ikea effect. I will admit I've bought a bunch of this junk especially when my son moved out and was needing furniture we didn't have. I know it's not going to last very long but it was inexpensive and since he put it together he now has just a little bit of the "build it" factor that got me started in woodworking 35 or so years ago.
There is so much wrong with this, I hardly know where to start. Don't really have time to dive into the source article now either.
As far as I can tell, the sociologist who wrote the study and named the "Ikea effect" appears to believe that the motivation for creativity are feelings of incompetence. That fella needs to get out in the world a bit more often
We have so little manual skills, that people are amazed at the simplest of crafts. As for Ikea, take their ideas and execute them yourself properly. Jerry
This really isn't a new concept. IIRC when cake mixes first came out they didn't sell well because all the ingredients were included except water. Once the mix required the "baker" to add an egg and the water, they sold much better. More recently, we attempt to get people to "buy in" to a project by getting them involved in the decision making process. Of course, we all know that the decision has already been made, but we somehow feel better about it if we have an opportunity to "get our oar in the water". lol
Think Memsahib would have a different view. She is actively involved in the core decision-making on all the stuff she "orders." To get My Preferences included, I've learned to be persuasive during the design phase and then have interim consultations at points along the way that she can charge her mind without too much grief.
Of course, there have been some real mistakes, but then I get to say, "Hey, that's what you ordered."
As received it, leaning against the wall under the canoe. It's a kit for a wine cabinet for our son and DIL. Unfortunately, no instructions were included.
The laddder is what you use to throw yourself from when, after getting the last coat of finish on the project, they call and tell you they found the perfect piece and brought it home from IKEA!
We looked at Ikea when we were planning our kitchen remodel (although we ultimately took another, and much more expensive, path). One thing that struck me is that they do use solid wood in many (by no means all) of their pieces where already-assembled pieces would be made from termite barf. For those pieces, even if you weren't a shop person, Ick-ee-ah would have the advantage and be worth the few minutes of assembly.
I don't doubt the outcomes of the research, and we can be hopeful that a few minutes with an Allen wrench assembling a table might just be a gateway drug for enough people that another generation of shop folks will be born (although from what I've seen on the forums, there are many parents doing their part by encouraging their sons and daughters to get into the shop). But purchase of that particular product line may have more than just this emotional dynamic behind it.
I heard this article on NPR while I drove to work. Very interesting.
Another example of the IE is how proud some car owners are of the vehicles that they've basically maintained, not even customized, when it comes to selling the vehicle.
I can understand the IE...I've felt it a few times
I would say the biggest problem is the result of, at a guess, a very limited scope of participants in their studies. I seriously doubt that they had any experienced "hands on" type people at all. I have seen the pet project effect firsthand, but in my limited experience you see it most often with people who's work is more intellectual and less practical. When you get two mechanics discussing how to approach a task I don't think it happens as often.
Of course, throwing a few experienced builders in the mix would likely make the results so variable that the researcher could not come to a concrete conclusion. Such is the nature of a lot of these fields like sociology - it is very difficult to construct objective experiments because everything involved is so subjective - even the nature of the data itself.
He has succeeded however, in re-enforcing my preconceptions about the field of sociology
"The very essence of this research—what made it compelling—was that it was limited to those who had no such experience at 'making' "
Perhaps the problem is in how the NPR piece presented this research. The implication was that the conclusions formed based on study of a limited and specific group were broadly applicable to a wider group. This is typically done in order to reduce complexity that can confuse the research. There is little point to studying how those with little experience building things react to doing so if it is not to learn something about humans in general - including those who do habitually make things. But in my view, limiting their participant group skewed their conclusions.
The implication I got is that building is driven by narcissism - and I find that to be very far from the truth. Looking for the flaws that might lead the researchers to such a conclusion, I find that a huge one is in their selection of participants.
I actually do not agree that one should only judge the research based on primary articles. When it is put out into the broader public domain by secondary articles such as the NPR piece, it should be judged there as well. It is the researcher's responsibility to ensure that the secondary author has an accurate understanding and can communicate the essence of the research to a casual audience. If we are not to judge the research by its secondary distillation, there is no point to articles like the NPR piece.
However, I do admit to a bit of a prejudice regarding the soft sciences. As difficult as it is to be objective in hard sciences, I can't imagine it's possible when trying to come to predictable conclusions based on intangible data like how someone "feels" about a thing they assembled.
Come to think of it, one might even argue that scientific research and the publication of erudite articles is similarly driven by narcissism, and be just as far from the truth.
Re: Seems like the discussion went off on a tangen
Jesper, Denmark
As I read it, John's original point was that one feels better about something one has had some involvement in building, and that this little involvement can lead to more and better involvements in woodworking.
Didn't we all start with something simple, which led to more and (mostly) better things?
I think it was the particleboard stuff from Wal-Mart, Office Depot, Target, etc. that inspired me to build stuff, and even the stuff from big name furniture makers I was not pleased with. It broke and fell apart, and I decided I could do better.
I'd much rather have something from Ikea (and we do in the kids rooms) which is better built that old "kits" from the above (probably "Sauder", "Bush", etc.). The little end table shown for $7.99 is a piece of junk, unless you use it. I would have loved to have access to Ikea for my first apartment for items like this. I feel that Ikea offers a price much closer to the value of these inexpensive items than what was previously available.
That being said, I am picky about what I buy from Ikea, and do deviate from their instructions on occasion. My kids desks are from Ikea frankly because I didn't have time to build what I wanted. However, my son helped me put it together and he learned about mouting drawer slides, etc.
What I like about doing it myself, is that I can build it my way to fit where I want it. And strong enough to store bars of gold for when I hit the Lotto
I'd always prefer to build it myself completely given the time and money. But even I am constained by those items a lot right now in my life.
I do believe people take more pride and particularly take better care of something they built themselves. Because they know it actually took work to build.
In my opinion, good social sciences research can yield useful information, but its limitations must be understood. Because the subject matter - people - contains so many variables, I suspect comprehensive, sweeping conclusions are likely to be very hard. Imagine running the same study in two cultures: one in which the physical making of things is seen as extremely low in social status, and another in which someone who makes things is held up as an example of what to strive for. That variable alone would likely lead to opposing outcomes.
Nevertheless, well-defined research can be useful. I've been following some of (the popular summaries of) the literature analyzing the success of various early education programs, parenting programs, and so on; and the good studies following up on those programs have been vital in suggesting where we should put the effort.
John, you said, "It is the researcher's responsibility to ensure that the secondary author has an accurate understanding and can communicate the essence of the research to a casual audience." As someone whose job included occasional interviews with reporters, I can tell you that the interview subject never has any such control. Ya do yer best, and ya takes your chances; but after ten minutes of dripping sweat, thinking through the nuance of every word I said and trying to get confirmation that the reporter understood, I'd see one of my statements taken out of context and skewed by the reporter to mean exactly what I didn't say.
From what I understand, the same issue occurs in the hard sciences. Many experiments are answering very narrow questions - necessary ones to answer, but not questions the answer to which will shake the foundations of the discipline. The reporting will then blow them up into something they're not.
About 80% of the visitors we get at the radio telescope think that we are looking for aliens, thanks to movies like Contact....
They seem vaguely disappointed (or confused) when I explain that our equipment would not detect a modulated signal if we were looking right at it - or rather it would detect the carrier wave but not the modulation. Just plain old physics and chemistry is what we're up to, no alien hunting, and for better or worse, no Jodie Foster.