Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

Posts

Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#1

JL

Strength of cherry?  Should I make pegs thicker?

JL

I typically "beef" up my turned cherry legs a bit. I was told a long time ago that I should. I'll have to admit, I've never really tested the idea one way or the other.

When I make cherry in flat work, I've never really worried about it - the legs are legs - on the order of at least 1" in the thinnest part. I have done cherry legs for sewing tables and such that have been on the order of 5/8" or so thick.

The reason why I'm asking is I'm using up a bunch of #2 common cherry. I figured I turn a few Shaker pegs to have in stock. If I were doing them in maple or white oak, the thinnest portion would be on the order of 3/8" thick for a 3 1/2" long peg. I figure all it is going to hold would be a coat.

So - the question. Should I beef them up to 1/2"? Does it even make a difference? Should I leave them at 3/8"?

TIA.

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#2

Re: Strength of cherry?  Should I make pegs thicke

John Lucas

I make all my hand mirror handles with a 3/8" tenon. I think they are pretty strong, but a really heavy coat hung up kind of manly like on the end of a 3" long spindle might be taxing it. However you do probably have a shoulder that would keep it from rocking and that will strengthen it. My suggestion would be make one and break it. See how much force it takes.

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#3

Better safe than sorry *LINK*

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

If you look at comparative strength ratings for Cherry and Oak or Maple, Cherry is considered medium strength, Soft Maple is rated strong and Oak is rated very strong. I think I would continue to beef up cherry load bearing components just to be safe.

Lee


Wood Properties

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#4

I agree

Merle

Try to break a 3/8"x3" dowel in your hands or better yet, see how much weight you can hang on one before it breaks. I can't believe that any coat would break one unless there were lead in the pockets.

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#5

JL

Tried a 10 lb sledge...

JL

Turned so that about 1" was at 3/8" thickness with a gentle taper to the 3/8". All told, about 2 1/2" was under 1/2".

I put the turned piece in a vice. A larger section was gripped by the vise. A 20 penny nail supported the thinner section so it wouldn't rotate in the vise (stuck through the holes in which you fasten the sacrificial faces). I looped a cord around the end. I bounced a 10 lb sledge up and down in the looped cord.

It did bend and flex. It did not break. The 10 lb sledge with handle probably weighs 12-13 lbs. The static load did not really bend the spindle - only a "dynamic" load.

As I'm going to have at most, 1/4" at 3/8" of thickness, I think I'll be safe with most coats.

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#6

Re: Strength of cherry?  Should I make pegs thicke

Don Stephan

I'd suggest looking at measured drawings in one of the Shaker furniture reference books, such as Kassay's. The Shakers had decades of experience and made everything to last.

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#7

Re: Strength of cherry?  Compared to what?

Howard Acheson

"Strength" is an undefined property. There are a number of types of tests used to determine "strength".

Here is a web page that contains testing results for various species and various tests.

http://workshopcompanion.com/KnowHow/Design/Nature_of_Wood/3_Wood_Strength/3_Wood_Strength.htm

Re: Strength of cherry? Should I make pegs thicker?

#8

Re: Strength of cherry?  Should I make pegs thicke

TomD

I bought my dad a lathe after he retired. He made quite few Cherry pegs, and put them up all over the place. He made them to standard Shaker dimensions, and mounted them by means of the usual tenons. None of them has shown the slightest hint of faltering. For the most part they have held stuff like coats, and garden tools. I think in many cases the original Shaker ones were also cherry. They did stuff like hang their chairs and cabinets from them. Those pieces would naturally hang out from the wall as the design does not set the object being hung back to a less levering position. Elegant proportions were of great importance to the Shakers, though they did make the pegs in a variety of sizes, so that would have some structural effect. I would not do anything to beef up cherry pegs, so long as they were conventionally dimensioned in the first place.