Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Plumbing Question

Posts

Plumbing Question

#1

Plumbing Question

Ken Krawford

We're remodeling our master bath and I'm making new cabinets. Presently the water supply comes in through the bottom of the cabinet. I'm going to move the sink about 18" and wondered about relocating the supply lines so that they entered the cabinet through the back instead of the bottom. No only would this make cabinet installation easier but would free up a bit of space on the bottom of the base unit.

Is there any reason to NOT do this?

Thanks.

Re: Plumbing Question

#2

Re: Plumbing Question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

It may be a little difficult to do if the cabinet is located against an outside wall, due to the sill plate etc. Other than that the only reason not to run it inside the wall is that if it is on an outside wall, the possibility of freezing the lines is increased.

Re: Plumbing Question

#3

Re: Plumbing Question

John McGaw

If it was an outside wall and in a cold climate there would be a good reason not to do it. Which way does the drain line run? If through the floor, would you be relocating that too Sometimes added fittings and angles in drain lines can cause clog problems down the line.

Re: Plumbing Question

#4

Re: Plumbing Question

Nat Robison

I have a bathroom where the lines come from the wall.....I guess the original plumber could have put them up through the floor but didn't. Maybe it was a pedestal sink originally. I guess as long as they're not in an outside wall, I don't see a problem. I don't know what the building code says about it, if anything.

Re: Plumbing Question

#5

Re: Plumbing Question

Ken Krawford

I knew there was something I meant to mention in my original post - this is an interior wall. I also have easy access to all the plumbing from my unfinished basement.

Thanks for the replies.

Re: Plumbing Question

#6

Re: Plumbing Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In these parts it is always done through the cabinet back.

Re: Plumbing Question

#7

Re: Plumbing Question

Joseph Mulherin,sr

Ken, I am a retired Pipefitter/plumber of 35yrs experience....It would be OK to redirect the plumbing drains and water as asked about. Here is what I would do: open the wall where the cabinet ie to be installed; drill down from above thru the plate with oversize holes to allow for sound and vibration arresters to be used....you can buy them at suppliers; stay away from studs in drilling to allow room for any fittings to fit proper arrangements for install the piping as needed, used metal protection plates on studs to protect from screws and nails upon installation of drywall' then install new drywall and finish and paint; Install you cabinet and enjoy.

Use long turn elbow or 45s below the floor to allow better water flow without any future clogging and install a cleanout above in cabinet below drain.

Re: Plumbing Question

#8

Re: Plumbing Question

Jason Waters

Joe,

Very good writeup, but I'm not following "install a cleanout above in cabinet below drain. "

We always installed the cleanout above where the trap entered the wall. But usually only put cleanouts in slab houses for sinks. (and the pipe in the wall was 3" down to the drain, for easy snaking under the slab later).

Other notes

We also always tapped the hot and cold from a tee, and left a short piece of pipe capped going up in the wall to reduce "hammer" in the pipes (acted as an air chamber).

Try and look at a house being built and you'll see.

Jason

Re: Plumbing Question

#9

Re: Plumbing Question

Joseph Mulherin,sr

Yes, Jason, you are correct in some areas, but in my experience we only installed them below the trap. If it ws above the trap tee then IMHO it would be too hard to get into with a snake since it would be at about 22" from the floor and probably too close to the sink bottom. When a sink filled up and would not drain I have always loosen thr trap and let the water out into a bucket and then remove the trap so I could better get into the cleanout opening.

Re: Plumbing Question

#10

Re: Plumbing Question

Joseph Mulherin,sr

The air chamber you mention using only the pipe about 12-15" above the fixture opening is fine for awhile, but the air will be absorbed into the water and then you have to drain down the system and let air once again enter the chambers before refilling the piping system. There are rubber and spring water chambers which get over these problems, but they can be expensive.

Re: Plumbing Question

#11

Re: Plumbing Question

Jason Waters

I agree with your logic as well, I guess it depends on the situation. For a kitchen sink, there usually is enough room above to snake, but the bathroom can be a challenge. You can snake thru the male adapter for the trap if you have to, but it's a lot smaller.

The main thing is to install a cleanout while you are at it. I imagine most people don't unless required by code in order to cut costs. penny-wise, pound-foolish in my opinion....

Good that we have these discussions.

Re: Plumbing Question

#12

Re: Plumbing Question

Jason Waters

I know that happens with the pipe and good point, but it can still help. Those sealed air chambers have come down a good bit, though I think they are about $10-15 each. I actually had to add a screw on one near my washing machine.

Again, something to considered while all that is open.

Re: Plumbing Question

#13

Re: Plumbing Question

Joseph Mulherin,sr

Yes, Jason, with my 35yrs in the Trades I have installed many of both types.