Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT - reglazing an old tub

Posts

OT - reglazing an old tub

#1

OT - reglazing an old tub

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

My wife I and are looking to have an old tub re-glazed. I can't do a complete tear out/rebuild right now.

We found a guy here in the Cleveland area through some searching that is on Angie's List FWIW. I am not an Angie's List member but I found a link as well as a Plain Dealer newspaper article about the guy. Everything I've read has been positive.

I called the guy and he explained the process to me a little. Basically they put a chemical on the current tub that does whatever so that the product he sprays on sticks.

It all sounds good and at a fraction of the cost of taking out the old tub, putting in a new tub with new plumbing and so on. The other thing is we want to sell some day, not spend the rest of my life there...

So, does anybody have any experience with re-glazing a tub?

Thanks for any thoughts and comments.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#2

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

Nat Robison

I had one done about 10-12 years ago and was not terribly impressed. We ended up replacing the whole thing a few years later.

I suspect there's probably a wide range of skill and materials involved so maybe I didn't get a great job on mine.

Probably the only way to verify is if your guy has any references or can show you a chunk of reglazed tub. Perhaps the whole process has come along since my experience.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#3

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

Robert

The process described to you was basically a chemical etch to clean the existing surface followed by spraying on an enamel paint. This process while relatively cheap, is primarily a temporary measure and will not last long, as attested to by the other poster. To properly reglaze a tub will depend on its base material. If it is cast iron/porcelain, then the only CORRECT way is to spray it with a bake on porcelain enamel and bake it in an oven to fuze the materials. If it is plastic/fiberglass then an acrylic finish should be applied, but it needs to be done in a dust controlled environment (just like the finish on a boat).

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#4

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

john Veerkamp

If he is spraying on epoxy it will last much longer than enamel. And as others pointed out experience and prep are crucial to results.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#5

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

GolfSteve in Calgary

I had mine sprayed (I think it was an acrylic paint, but might be wrong). The guy spent a lot of time acid etching, sanding, and prepping the old enamel surface before spraying. (*) He spent two-thirds of a day doing my tub, meaning that for the $500 cost he could only do one tub a day. The fumes were pretty strong, but because he sealed off and ventilated the bathroom, the rest of the house was odour free.

It's been two years since the work was done and I'm still pretty happy. I was told that the finish would last about 5 years.

After about a year there was one area where water got under the paint, starting at the drain, and the film started to bubble. They came back and repaired that area.

At the end of the day, this is a just a paint job, so don't expect too much. My tub looked brand new and I had a hard time telling it was recoated and not a new tub. It was worth it for me - the old tub looked awful but the rest of the bathroom is in good shape. I didn't want to do a full bathroom renovation yet, and there is a chance I might sell the house so wanted the tub to look a lot better than it did.

My only disappointment was that they did not remove the drain assembly before spraying. I thought they would take it apart, spray, and then reassemble. Instead they sprayed around the drain and sealed over the transition with silicone. My old drain was also partially corroded away, so I'd recommend replacing that before you bring someone in to refinish the enamel.

(*) I can see how recoating a tub might be "wonderful" or "awful" depending on how good a job the contractor does.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#6

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

My experience was similar to Steve's. They tented and vented the bathroom, etched and sanded the tub, then applied one or more coats of epoxy.

The problem was the chrome finish on the brass drain flange was wearing and peeling and they epoxied right over it. The epoxy cracked there and eventually started to peel back around the drain, revealing the old pink tub surface under the new blue one. To avoid similar problems and to make more money, some of these companies will only want to recoat a tub if they also do the surrounding tile walls.

In all other respects the job was good- glossy, durable finish with non-fading color- the ABS plastic surround I added which first matched perfectly, yellowed over time; the tub epoxy did not. The 20 year guarantee was no good because the company was gone (or changed their name) in less than 5 years.

I re-did the tub myself a few years later- I just used my ROS and hand sanding to prepare the surface and blend the edges of the chipped area around the drain. This time I removed the drain assembly which broke in the process. Fortunately I was able to get under the tub from below and put in a new assembly. I purchased an epoxy tub kit for about $50(?). It was a true, two-part epoxy which brushed on easily, flowed out with no brush marks and hardened to a gloss finish. I had to be careful about runs but only had two small ones which I sanded off before the second coat. A few days later, I roughened the entire surface with 320 grit and applied a second coat.

When I was done it looked just as good as the $300 commercial job. I can't say how it has held up since we sold the house a few years later.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#7

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

John McGaw

I have not had it done but the one friend of mine who had it done (by a well-regarded firm) to a massive cast-iron tub that he didn't want to remove and replace had peeling within a year. Even when it was fresh it just didn't look 'right'. I put that down to people's long experience with porcelain. Perhaps if one was used to acrylic it would have looked more normal but with failure within a year it certainly wasn't cost effective.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#8

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

Joseph Mulherin,sr

We also had our 1952 tub resprayed with the acrylic epoxy and it does look like

brand new after 6 years. I would heartedly recommend having it done

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#9

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I have seen a number of these. At least 25. Its clear to me that you have gotten good advice above. The results vary widely. A few were excellent and "like new". Some showed ordinary wear. A fairly large percentage failed miserably. They seemed to peel off the old porcelain in sheets. I suspect they had had poor preparation. The underlying surface appears slick and shiny, not rough and etched.

There is a company locally (Bath Fitters) that makes or provides tubs that fit over your existing tub and surround. While it is significantly more expensive that resurfacing your tub it may be cheaper than tearing one out and replacing it. Might be something to check into. (I wonder how much space you lose in the tub?)

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#10

You didn't mention ...

Mike Farinella

what kind of tub you have; cast iron, stamped steel, or acrylic? Your responses here should take that into consideration. Just my $.02 worth.

Re: OT - reglazing an old tub

#11

Re: You didn't mention ...

Joseph Mulherin,sr

We have a Cast iron tub which would have been a disaster in remodeling to remove and install another.

The entire process is in the PROPER of sanding and etching of the tub in the first place....if this not done right you will have the problems mentioned above with other tubs.