Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Festool Guide Variance...

Posts

Festool Guide Variance...

#1

Festool Guide Variance...

Derek Arita

So, I bought a 32" guide rail to connect with another guide rail, in order to be able to make cuts on longer stock, without having to pull out the big guide rail. Problem is, the guides on the new guide rail are not quite the same width as the older guide rail. My saw slide perfectly over the old guide rail, but as soon as hits the new one, it stops! If I adjust to the new GR, then the saw is sloppy on the old GR.

I called Festool for some tech help and the guy said I should just adjust to the new one. He said there won't be enough slop in the old one to make a difference in cut quality. Just wondering if anyone else has encountered this?

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#2

Re: Festool Guide Variance... *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

I haven't encountered a significant variance from rail-to-rail, but if you are having a noticeable variation in the movement from one rail to another, it is possibly a sign that you have your guide rail gibs adjusted too tight. This can lead to premature wear of the gibs.

Here is a Festool authorized/owned video I made for them that shows both of these topics (and more). It will show you how to set the gibs (or whatever I am calling them these days), and also how to connect 2 rails.

I used to know how to embed a video, but now I can't remember. I'll give this a try. (That finally worked. I was trying to use the old BB code, but it is just the standard Youtube html code after all.)




http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Xjd2AGr1pw

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#3

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

Derek Arita

Thanks for the link. I adjust the gibs exactly the way the video shows I should. Problem is, when I adjust to the old guide, the saw is very tight and won't slide in the new guide.

If the recommended adjustment is no play, but slides easily, why did the Festool tech tell me to adjust the gibs to the larger rail, even though it's sloppy in the smaller? Wouldn't doing that create a sloppy cut? The tech said no, but Festool instructions say that the opposite.

Can you switch between guide rails, with the same gib adjustment and still have no play, but easy sliding?

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#4

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

Rick Christopherson

The rails are extruded aluminum, so they will have some variation. After all, that is the purpose of having the adjustment cams in the first place. The dies used to make the extrusions do wear, so they have a limit on how many rails can be extruded before they have to be replaced.

If one rail came from the beginning of a production run, and one rail came from the end of a production run, they will have the maximum allowable tolerance between them.

If you have a caliper, measure the difference in width of the 2 rail ribs. I don't know what the tolerance should be, but they will probably be pretty close. If your gibs are set fairly snug, even a couple thousandths of an inch will be noticeable in resistance, but won't be noticeable in cut quality. That is probably the stance the technician was explaining. If the difference is more significant, then contact Festool and see if one of the two rails should be replaced.

Also, when joining rails, instead of using the straightedge on the front of the rail (like I show), try using it right on the rib that the saw guides on.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#5

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

Derek Arita

Just measured the difference and it comes out to .006"...which doesn't sound like much, but it sure makes a difference in the feel of the adjustment. When I adjust to the new guide, the saw feels sloppy in the old guide. I measured my other two old guide rails and they are within .002", which is fine. Wonder what Festool's tolerance is for the Guide Rails?

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#6

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

Derek Arita

Sorry...what I meant was that all of the old guide rails are within .002" of one another. The new one is out by .006".

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#7

Very interesting

Merle

I think this is the first time I have heard a complaint about Festools other than their exorbitant prices.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#8

Time to ask Festool

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For the prices they charge, you would think they'd be willing to make it right somehow.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#9

First thing to try...

John in NM

Set it up as the tech told you, loose on the older rail, just right on the new one, and try a few test cuts. I'm willing to bet that a few thousandths won't make any visible difference in the cuts.

For what its worth, I have heard of this problem putting two rails together that way. Never had two rails to try it with myself though, so its just hearsay :D

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#10

Re: First thing to try...

Derek Arita

If I lose the older rail, then that defeats the purpose of the second guide rail. The idea is to get a good fit from one to the other.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#11

Loose, as in sloppy...

John in NM

Set the saw to fit well on the new rail, then lock the rails together and try some test cuts. Mark where the rail join was on each and which rail was on which end. Cut two, then flip one over so the cut is a mirror image of the other - put them right up together as if you were gluing a table top and you should be able to determine how big a gap is caused by the sloppy fit on the older rail.

If the feel of the saw on the looser fit rail is just too annoying, the only practical solution is to use their long rail instead.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#12

Re: Time to ask Festool

Dave Bair

I agree, the buyer should be satisfied.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#13

The only hitch is...

John in NM

They're German :D

If you'd known my grandfather, no more would need be said :D :D :D

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#14

But they're also in business

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In Derek's case, I think I'd march up the line, asking for supervisors until I got someone who'd listen. It just seems wrong, given their prices and their strong promotion of the idea that you don't need any of those tablesaw contraptions if you'll just buy their guide rails, that they would not have a resolution for what has to be a common issue.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#15

We don't know if this

Merle

is a common issue or not. However, there is a Festool user group where Derek could ask about others' experiences and see how others have resolved it if it is common. I have never looked at the site so I don't know if it is active or not. I agree that for the price of the tools, they should provide better customer service. FWIW

http://festoolownersgroup.com/index.php

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#16

Cultural perceptions vary...

John in NM

Our notions of customer service are not necessarily universal, but I'm certainly willing to hope they will do the right thing and keep the customer happy.

I would still like to know if there are any measurable flaws in the cut resulting from following the tech support suggestion. Seems to me we may be discussing how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. I mean really, an angular shift in the saw caused by, say 0.002" slop in the rail, I bet its too small to even measure.

Now if the "feel" of an expensive tool is more important than its function, then that is another story. I can't offer any opinions there, function is what I'm looking for in tools.

Re: Festool Guide Variance...

#17

Re: But they're also in business

Rick Christopherson

Bill, the variance between his old rails and new rail is only 0.006". That is just barely over the thickness of a single piece of paper (@ 0.004"). That's a good tolerance for a machined surface--it's an exceptional tolerance for an extruded surface. There is no real problem here.

Those are slick, plastic adjustment cams. If he is getting noticeable binding at only a 0.006" difference, it means he is over-tightening his cams on the smaller rails, and he will prematurely wear his saw out, regardless whether he uses the new rail or the old ones.

I adjusted a saw/rail with a sheet of paper in the middle, and then removed the paper. There was no noticeable excessive slop in the rail.