Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

Posts

OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#1

OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

Tom Dunlap

I have an external hard drive that crashed. The IT geek where I used to work tried to open/recover it with some software programs. Another trick is to put it in the freezer then let it warm up. The freeze thaw sometimes unsticks the mechanism. Not on mine though :(

Now I need to send in to a 'clean room' shop to have it opened.

Has anyone had to use one of these companies?

Give me some hints...what to ask...costs...this is new ground.

I have a newer, larger external HD that I'm using. My next level of backup is to go to The Cloud...another frontier that I know little about. All that I hear is about 'Carbonite' but there must be others too.

I use Mac exclusively so I'm inclined to go with iCloud.

Thanks,

Tom

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#2

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

Chuck Wintle

from what i know the 'clean room" method is expensive...sometimes running $1000 or more. I know of one instance where a person bought a functional second hand drive from ebay, the exact same model and firmware revision, and succeeded in transplanting the read/write mechanism to the point where he was able to recover all of his data.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#3

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

paul in AZ

Stick a fork in it. It's dead. A replacement external drive is dirt cheap.

I use a Mac and back up with a program called SuperDuper. That is supposed to create a fully bootable clone of your primary HD. I back up to a second internal drive and also have an external.

Having all those backups, naturally nothing has crashed (yet).

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#4

The data not the drive

Tom Dunlap

I know the drive is dead but the data is important. Family pics and other info is worth the money to attempt recovery.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#5

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

john Veerkamp

Had my HD crash a while back. My local guru was able to slave it to an operable machine and recover all of my pictures, documents and my e-mail. I did need to recreate my bookmarks and reinstall some programs. Worth a try.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#6

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

Rick Christopherson

The idea of cooling the drive is because the bearings are failing and overheating. So you don't cool it down and let it warm back up. You cool it down and run it cold as quickly as you can while trying to extract as much information as possible before the bearings heat up again.

So if you can, open the cover on the external drive to allow better cooling, take the whole computer outside or the garage, and get the data off in spurts. You don't want the drive to be super cold when you start, because that could allow condensation to build up. However, simply keeping it cool may help.

When taking your data off the drive, I recommend "moving" the data, as opposed to "copying" the data. This way, when the drive fails again, you know what was successfully transferred and what was not. When it does re-fail, let it cool down a bit and try again.

Also, go after the smallest files first. If you go after the really big files (like videos), the drive could heat up too much before even a single file is extracted.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#7

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

Jerry Nicholson

You don't have backups of everything? Why is it that people have to lose important data before they will believe that backups are necessary? I use a second drive in the computer to back up the main drive and use an external drive for periodic backups just in case the computer catches fire and ruins everything. Every six months or so, I back all my important information (especially pictures, videos, and financial information) to one of the two drives that I rotate in and out of my safety deposit box. Am I paranoid? Absolutely!!

I don't trust the so called cloud. I don't care how many times those data storage services claim that my data will be safe and secure I still refuse to believe them. Extra drives are cheap!

Jerry

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#8

More experienced now

Tom Dunlap

This external HD crashed about four years ago and I've been waiting to have the discretionary money to attempt the recovery. I'm prepared for a big bill. But, how much are family pics worth?

After the crash I started backing up more routinely. Two external HDs.

I'm suspicious of The Cloud though. It seems like I could continue using my two externals routinely and be as protected as possible.

Bottom line...I'm still trying to source info on recovering the info from my crashed HD. Any help? If crashes are so common its hard to believe that someone here hasn't had to send a HD out for recovery.

Tom

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The Cloud

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The whole purpose of the Cloud-based backup systems are so that you can easily make an off-site backup of your files. You can backup until you are blue in the face, but if you have a house fire, it's all (likely) gone.

Another option, if you can swing the technical side of it is to pair up with a good, trusted friend, and each have an extra HD online at the other's house to which you backup regularly. That way, you have a backup off-premises, and other than the data transfer via the internet, it's relatively secure as well without the concern about it being in the intercloudwebz.

Jason

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#10

Re: The Cloud

John McGaw

I consider any data insecure that isn't in a verified backup stored in at least three places with at least one of them being off-premises in a provably safe location. Personally I depend on my in-home server which redundantly backs up all content on my daily-driver every night and all of the other computers (don't even ask me how many I have running 24 X 7) once per week. I also burn things like photos onto DVD-ROM for convenient access. My offsite backups are on 1tB and 2tB drives which are cycled into and out of my bank safe deposit box. I KNOW they aren't going to burn or flood or get burglarized. I already have the box (and assume that most people do) and swapping out drives takes all of five minutes. I still don't do that as often as I'd like but the data there is a good fallback and is never more than a month old. I guess that the cloud solution might be suitable as an additional storage location but the speed of uploading data, even with a fairly good DSL line, would seem to be a problem and I certainly wouldn't trust some unknown company in an unknown location to still be in existence when I want to get my data back.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#11

I have used one

Chad P

I had a laptop hard drive go bad at work. Sent it to a local hd recovery firm in Minneapolis. It cost my company about 1200 dollars in 2006. I got all my data back on a new portable drive in about ten days.

Thanks for the reminder to back up.

Chad

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#12

Re: More experienced now

Chuck Wintle

One thing you did not mention is the brand of hard drive you have and the model number and firmware number. with this info maybe someone could offer more help?

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#13

Re: More experienced now

mark valsi

Thanks for the warning !!

I'm backing up stuff right now !!

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#14

You can try

Bill Howatt

Try giving it a sharp hit - we used to do this and it may work but our intention was to scrap the drive if it didn't; not try advanced recovery which can be very expensive. If the motor is not turning because of a non-electronic issue it may start. This would be better done with the actual drive exposed rather than the case but you do want to keep it running should it start.

I get cloud storage with via my ISP and I do keep some important files there as an off-site backup such as financial spreadsheets, previous year's income tax returns, etc. These are all encrypted by me before transferring the files to the cloud so even if the ISP's cloud security is breached it doesn't matter. Major drawback for me is that my upload speed is around 500Kbps which is too slow for lots of data.

My data is nightly copied to a second internal HD and every now and then I update a copy on one of my external USB drives. I have about 3 which I rotate through to reduce common mode failures. About twice a year I update a copy of my data on a HD (DVDs etc got too small and slow) stored at my friend's house.

Bill

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#15

Don't (just) backup

Hoa in Alameda

Harddrives are cheap. Don't just backup.

Even when you have the data backup, how long does it take you to reconstruct the original harddisk (OS, programs, settings, ....)? IME, it's 2 days to 1 week. The price of a harddisk is dirt cheap compared to 2 days - 1 week.

I have a procedure: when I buy a new computer, I buy 2 other harddisks of the same capacity as the one in the computer. If there is space in the computer, I install one of the disks inside. The other will be used as an external disk.

At the 1st of each month, I clone (I use either Acronis Disk Director or True Image) the first harddisk to the second harddisk. Each night, I run a little DOS batch file to back up the data (c:\users) from the first harddisk to the second one.

At the 15th of each month, I clone the first internal harddisk to the external harddisk. The external harddisk is stored in my office.

If the computer does not have space for another internal harddisk, it will have two external harddisks: one cloned on the 1st of the month, the other on the 15th. Nightly backup is done wirelessly to one of the desktops.

In the very worst case, I'd lose 15 days worth of data, and no time to install OS and programs.

Re: OT-Hard drive data recovery-mine crashed

#16

Re: Don't (just) backup

Gary Bindel

It is important to check your backups, also to ensure they are good.