Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

Posts

OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#1

OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

California's energy code requires, in new construction and remodels, either high-efficacy lights or dimmer switches*. The high-efficacy versions of the light fixtures we're looking at in the current remodel are twice the price of the low-efficacy versions (for one fixture, this wouldn't be bad, but we're putting in five). This makes dimmer switches more attractive. Since incandescent light bulbs are moving in the direction of halogen, not a terribly efficient light, my plan is to buy the low-efficacy fixtures, which take incandescents or CFLs, and put CFLs in them.

This then requires a dimmer switch rated for fluorescent lights; we'll be putting in two three-way switches, one at each door into the room.

OK, that's the setup, here's the question: looking at the installation guide for the Leviton switch, it appears that these dimmer switches do not require a neutral, just the usual hot legs (incoming and outgoing) and, of course, the equipment ground.

Is that right?

*My son and I shake our heads over this. Maybe modern dimmer switches save electricity, and we just don't know; certainly the older ones just reduced output voltage without really reducing net energy use.

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#2

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

Bill Howatt

Dimmer switches do not require a neutral, they just go between the supply and the load like a regular switch. You can consider them referenced to the neutral through the lamp.

Dimmer switches do save power because they block current for part of the cycle. They are not like rheostats (big variable resistors) which dissipate a fair amount of energy themselves.

Bill

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#3

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

Jay Lombardo

Be aware that the "dimmable" CFL's really do a poor job of dimming. It's more like high and low and low is still pretty bright. LED's on the other hand dim perfectly, just like incandescent. But unfortunately they still cost and arm and a leg and there is no way to recapture the added expense with energy savings or longevity of the bulb YET. Electrician for 44 years and CFL technology is the worst crap to be marketed to the public so far. Yes you save some energy but the drawbacks outweigh the savings to me. They don't work with electronic timers, they take too long to "warm up", they don't last as long as the claims, they don't dim well at all, don't work in the cold, and you still have to deal with the mercury. They have a few practical applications but for the most part I'd wait for the prices to come down on LED technology, and they will.

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#4

Neutral in switch boxes

Henry Higginbotham

There was at least a proposal to amend the NEC to require a neutral in switch boxes (2011?). I don't have the latest book, so I don't know if it made the final cut. Might be worth looking into.

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#5

Thanks, all

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'll confirm that neutral question when the inspector comes around for the rough inspection. What I didn't want was to find out after the sheetrock was up and painted that I needed one.

Re: OT - fluorescent dimmer switches

#7

I'm with you...

John in NM

I detest CFL's.... got to turn them on and go do something else for a couple minutes while they warm up. Incandescent just works so much better, and all the bulbs in the country on all the time still would use only a fraction of the power that all those A/C units use.

We seem to still be able to buy regular bulbs and T12 bulbs down here, though you have to watch carefully that you aren't getting a big bulb with a little CFL inside it. I'd thought all the +40W stuff was CFL or halogen now.