Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Start over now, or hope for saving?

Posts

Start over now, or hope for saving?

#1

Start over now, or hope for saving?

Brint in Richmond, VA

I've glued up several panels before, but still consider myself a novice. This time I glued up four pieces of beech into a 3/4"-thick, 13"x21" panel for a side-table tabletop for my daughter. The next day it was cupped almost 5/64" in the middle. There's a possibility I might cut it down 12" wide, in which case I could try running it through my planer, but that might just make it too thin. I have more beech, and it's not that big a deal, so I'm prepared to start over unless someone can tell me an easy way to save it - ??


Thanks in advance -

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#2

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

Barry Irby

Welcome to the world of beech. Tends to warp, badly. If the panel is wide enough you could rip it into about four pieces, flip every other one over and re-glue it. Then it would form a serpentine curve rather than a single one. Not sure it would help much or enough.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#3

So, Do you think your joinery was off

Keith Newton

Or do you think the wood changed? If your shop is heated, and the concave side might have gotten better warm air circulating over it through the night, the wood may have contracted on that side. Before you do something drastic, I would just flip it over, and leave the convex side up for the night, and maybe it will be straight by morning.

Also, that is not a lot of cup to hold down, if you are fastening it to a frame underneath. Bending across the grain like this is the weakest property of all wood. You may be able to push it down flat, with about 10 lbs on each side, which is nothing for screws to hold. But just remember, that when screwing down solid wood to another cross-grain member, that you must provide room for it to move through seasonal changes.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#4

1 vote for redo

Dick Coers

But you should identify what went wrong first. Was it like that out of the clamps? What kind of clamps? Did you alternate clamps on either side of the panel? How long has the wood been in the shop? Panels will warp if flat stacked on a bench, and one side sees shop air and the other is tight to the bench. The humidity changes, and the side that is open to the air, changes. I always keep glue-ups open to the air on all sides while I work them.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#5

Bob

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

Bob

By looking at the end grain that should not have happened. Try misting it on the cup side and clamp it to the bench with cauls under it so its flat letting air circulate below then let it dry out and see if it returns to flat when un-clamped.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#6

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

hennebury

Flip it over and leave it for a day or so, it will straighten out, its just dried out more on the top.

When it straightens, sticker it for a while.Your shop is drier than the wood and the wood will need to reach equilibrium with the shop.

Best to sticker all the time until you put the table together, that way you keep the air flow all around the wood and keep the moisture balanced.

Mark


img

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#7

So that's what I've been doing wrong

Henry Higginbotham

I've never bothered to tie all those strings to everything like that. Looks impressive, though. :D

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#8

Sorry the photo was posted in error. 


img

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#9

Not a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Do as Mark recommends above but if it does not become completely straight don't worry about it. This top is going to be installed on some sort of frame. You can pull it flat against this frame. All that is important in the end is that what ever shape it becomes that you can pull it flat where ever it goes.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#10

Let me re-state a rule.....

Howard Acheson

..... when making up panels. NEVER set your just glued up panel down directly on another panel or flat surface. Doing this prevents air from getting equally to both surfaces. This means that the panel will develop uneven moisture on the two surfaces which is the cause of the warping. ALWAYS sticker the newly glued up panel with at least 3/4" stickers. Generally weighting or clamping is not necessary.

Leaning your panels can also be problematic particularly if you lean them against an outside concrete uninsulated wall. That too will cause uneven moisture content and lead to warping.

The good news is that almost always a panel warped like this can be rehabilitated by now stickering. But, in this case, apply some weight on the top being sure to not cut off air circulation except where the stickers are located.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#11

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

Dave Bair

I feel your pain. I made a threesome of Craftsman style bookcases of american beech.

Initially, the sides were glued into over-sized panels, allowed to rest for a week and then re-ripped along the worst of the cupping, re-jointed and re-glued. Some of them cupped badly again and were redone. One had to be done a third time. Eventually, I quit because the losses due to kerf and jointer operations reduced the panels to near finished size. This wood had, and maintains a 7% moisture content.

Since I used wedged-through tenons, I thought I could pull everything flat. I pulled it flat all right, but over night the sides began to split. It's still splitting more a month later. I'm not sure these cases will ever see the inside of my home unless I can do a good job of stabilizing and filling the splits.

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#12

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

Brint in Richmond, VA

Thanks to everyone -- as most of you noticed, yes, I had left the glued-up panel sitting flat on my benchtop, under a ceiling-mounted space heater. Duh. It's a no-brainer once someone points it out to you, but as a novice, it had never occurred to me. I actually got impatient and ripped it in half before waiting for any replies, thinking I could re-joint the edges and glue it back up. Then I read the first few responses and flipped the pieces over on the benchtop. It's getting better. :\

The beech was originally 8/4 and had air-dried outside for about 4 years, then had been in my shop for a couple weeks, but I glued it up right after re-sawing and ripping it, instead of waiting for it to acclimate (the hazards of a hobbyist - always rushing to do stuff when I get a little bit of free time). So the resulting pattern is continuous in the middle, with bookmatched sides. Is there a name for this arrangement (besides random hobbyist)?


Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

#13

Re: Start over now, or hope for saving?

TomD

For a woodworker, this is pretty much the only use for a lawn. You just toss the board, cup down, on the lawn for 30 minutes.