I need a glue that will release after I cut around the inlay with a scalpel. After the inlay piece is cut around, I need to excavate the wood under the inlay to set it into the door/panel. What are your suggestions?
I'd put two small pieces of blue painters tape opposite each other in 3 and 9 o'clock positions then trace the profile with a mechanical pencil. Then place two more pieces of tape in the 6 and 12 positions. Then remove the 3 and 9 pieces and finish tracing the profile. Now cut the profile leaving the line.
You might want to practice this on scrap first to get used to the intricacies of the profile.
I spent an afternoon with a lady who does high end musical instrument inlays. She uses a small drop of CA glue. Of course she's inlaying Ivory and pearl which is probably tougher. She just goes under the piece with a long thin exacto blade to pop it off the wood. She uses a needle sharp pointed tool to scribe the lines around it. then she rubs chalk into the lines to make them easy to see.
Big pieces of pearl aren't all that tough, though small blobs are like gravel. I would use hide glue since there are six ways to sunday to release, it. Use the least glue you can.
one drop of CA glue in 2 or 3 locations about 1/4" in then use a razor blade to release it after your done scribing the outline then as suggested scrape some contrasting chalk on it and wipe it off, it will fill in the scribe lines and make it easier to see and work. don't forget to route on a piece of scrap to get the depth right (leaving the inlay proud of the field). Nice Marquetry piece. Do not use spray adhesive or double sided tape unless its veneer tape, carpet tape is to thick.
tape in the red container. Not available everywhere. Found in office supply, college bookstores, and art stores. 3M calls it low tack but it has always stayed for me when holding down a pattern or sanding identical wood pieces -- if pressed down -- and it rolls up with no residue when it comes up. Test on a couple of pieces to see if it works in your application.