I usually just wait until I get a warm day (in the 50s or so) and finish in my basement. However our oldest cat is complaining that it triggers his arthritis and that it gets the house too cold. It's no problem finishing with oil, I can keep the temperature up in the basement. It is a problem finishing with anything that has volatiles - as I do have to vent the basement (and suck out the warm air from upstairs).
I tried heating the garage - but after the last power bill - I'm not sure that's the best idea either - though it did work reasonably well.
My shop is attached to the house and shares the house heating cooling system, son any finish that off gasses can't be done in the shop in the winter. I do have an unheated garage that is not attached to the house. I usually take my finished projects out there even in the summer to keep fumes out of the house. In the winter I use Deft Clear Wood Finish. It is lacquer based and doesn't care what the temperature is. It will cure even in sub freezing temperatures, it just takes longer. I can coat one horizontal surface and let it stand over night. I get a nice leveling of the finish, no runs and no dust. I can rotate the part and finish the next surface the next day. Once all surfaces have the required number of coats, I leave the project in the garage for about a week to fully cure.
I wrote to Deft years ago and they said using it in cold temps is okay and confirmed that it will just take longer to dry.
Go back in time when houses were finished with oil based paint and varnish. People survived (accepted)having the finish applied to walls, floors and moldings and life went on. It is only recently that people objected to a sniff of the solvent fumes for a few hours of their lives. There is a large load of volatiles in the water based products (coalescing aid) which get ignored because their odor threshold is lower.
I worry about flammability, never odor.
If I am spraying something I spray outside and then move inside to cure and harden. Works even below freezing. A bathroom is a handy place for cure. With the heat vent full open I can get it warmer than the most of the house. The smell is better than what results from its other uses.
When I had a van I found it great for curing finish on a sunny, cold winter day. The greenhouse effect of the windows made it toasty warm and its ample size enabled most things I finished to fit inside.
Humidity is an important variable. High humidity retards the oxidation catalysts ability to perform the cure. It is common to be damp when it is cool, an important factor in cure rate. That and every chemical step in the curing process is markedly sensitive to temperature. A good rule of thumb is a doubling of rate for every 10 C temperature rise. Then there is diffusion of the solvents out of the curing film. Again extremely temperature sensitive.
Waterlox is loaded with curing catalyst. Other vanishes may take days to cure in cool temperature.
Not that I understand much of this stuff, but could it be that this a case of absolute humidity vs relative humidity? And the absolute humidity of the air is what is affecting the polymerization process?
VOCs are not something to take lightly. If you can smell an oil-based finish, you're breathing in VOCs, which all have some level of neurotoxicity.
If I used only oil-based finishes in a closed-up house all day, I'd have more of a buzz than if I chug 3 beers in quick succession. Only I'd also feel nauseous. No thanks.
I say do what you can to control the temperature and humidity of the finishing area, as in, get it relatively close to the same parameters as where the piece will spend most of its time. The bonus is that there are also fewer concerns about wood movement due to the wide temperature and humidity differences.
>>>> Other vanishes may take days to cure in cool temperature.
Bill, I would have thought so too but a small test I did last winter supported the conclusions in the article. The temperature in my garage was about 45 degrees during the day and lowered to 30-35 degrees at night. I was brushing Waterlox on a refinishing job and it was ready for sanding with 36-48 hours.
I got to thinking about other finishes. I had a recently opened can of oil based P&L 38 non-poly varnish and a can of Minwax Poly varnish that was opened about six months previously. Both finishes would normally be ready for sanding within 6 to 8 hours in 65 degree plus temperatures. I applied a coat of each to separated sections of a sanded birch board. I set up a fan to keep the air moving over them. The next morning (about 12-14 hours later) both were almost tack free. After 30 - 36 hours both produced fine sanding dust when sanded with 320 paper.
Since that time I have finished a few more times in colder temperatures and while the cure time is longer by maybe 50%, the finishes cured normally. If the option is not to finish at all, I will take the longer cure time every time. Since the publication of the article, I know of a number of finisher who have had good results.
You might want to try your own test and let me know the results.
Option A: Send the cat to the neighbors for a few days while you finish.
Option B: Warm the basememt and use water based finishes.
Option C: What are you using to vent your basement that cools down the whole house? My 11 x 26' basement shop has a 6" squirrell fan that is ceiling mounted and discharges to the outside. It runs all the time I am in the shop. Keeps the room slightly negative pressure so I can sand or varnish, and not have any ill effects of those processes reach the upstairs. It is not enough to vent effects of spraying, but works well. Have applied a quart of oil based varnish at a time on large projects, only to have a hint of smell upstairs. Turn off the fan for an hour, and the whole house will stink up.
Some many years back, I was painting an apartment when we lived in the Midwest. This is back when oil paint was still the recommended paint for bathrooms. I spent an hour or so in the small bathroom painting, and didn't notice the fumes much until I passed out.
You're describing a regime, Bill, that seems to avoid the ventilation problems by applying the finish outside*, then moving the work inside, to a room you can isolate and ventilate. This would be an improvement over what I did to myself back then, but I'm with Jason: the VOC content of finishes and its health impact is not a trivial issue.
*I'm picturing applying most any finish outside in January throughout much of the upper Midwest, with normal seasonal temperatures being less than 20 degrees on good days.
How do you cope with the approx. 30% solvent (VOC has a legal definition having to do with Smog) coalescing solvent in latex paint and all other water based finishes? Probably , like most, ignore it because it doesn't have as high an odor threshold as mineral spirits. Many would have not a second thought about latex painting a room and staying in the house.
I am not advocating 8 hr shifts of solvent based finishing in the basement. However, a 30 min session of varnishing a foot stool and leaving it to smell up the basement for a couple of days I see as no practical problem. I also acknowledge that it seems to be a problem for some, if not most, only because mineral spirits have a lower odor threshold, and maybe a more objectionable smell, than 2,2,4-trimethyl-1,3-pentanediol isobutyrate (common coalescing solvent).
The baloney about oxygen deprivation was my quibble. I don't deny finish will eventually cure, the rate being highly dependent on temperature, humidity, formulation and maybe other stuff.
I had a friend who built a house. The carpet guys were installing carpet in the basement and applied some sort of spray-on adhesive that was pretty nasty stuff. It was so nasty, in fact, that when the furnace came on, the basement caught fire and burned the thing to the ground.
...but the petroleum-based solvents will give me a buzz, plus the nausea. I've never had that problem with waterborne finishes. I can smell fresh latex paint for weeks after application, but it doesn't bother me in any way I can tell, and all the twitching and tics are usually gone by the time I go back to work on Mondays (KIDDING!)
I suspect that the coalescing solvents have molecules that are too large and complex to be quickly absorbed into the body through the lungs before they are exhaled, unlike the simpler and probably smaller hydrocarbon chains in oil paints and finishes.
Just to make sure there is no confusion, EPA considers 2,2,4-trimethyl-1,3-pentanediol isobutyrate to be a non-VOC, nonhazardous (except in California where it is considered LVP-VOC-exempt). Thus, its popularity as the world's most popular latex coalescing agent.
I just completed finishing several shelves. I have an attached and insulated, but unheated garage. I have a kerosene heater that can warm things up into the 60s. I bring the pieces in the house to warm up. Then, back into the warmed shop, turn off the heater and spray away. I use water based finishes and I've had good luck so far.