Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

A question for Bill Tindall

Posts

A question for Bill Tindall

#1

A question for Bill Tindall

Bill Leffingwell

Several months ago there was a post concerning food safe oils,which you shared your views on oils. other than walnut oil I have used walnut oil for 20 plus years because I bought into the myth of other oils and rancidity. I make on an average 200-225 cutting boards a year and would like to change to a locally available oil.Price is not really a concern,but the 110 mile round trip to buy WO is(I live in the boondocks).You convinced me on the rancidity issue, but I forget which oils you recommended.I like everything about walnut as a finish.What oil would would you suggest as an alternative?Thank you in advance.

Bill

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#2

an answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The only oils that will reproduce the film forming properties of walnut oil will be stinky linseed or tung. These oils have the right chemistry to easily cross link into a moderately hard film. Hence, if a moderately hard film-former is what you like about walnut you are stuck with it.

What I don't like about mineral oil is that it bleeds back out forever. The look is fine but the "wetness" is my complaint with it.

Soybean oil, as well as corn and cotton, have enough reactivity with air that they crosslink enough to not bleed out after some time. I would predict that soybean might be the better in this respect but I have not done any comparative testing. I slather on whatever is in the cupboard when the need arises.

Try soybean oil. Your requirement might be substantially different from mine. Give it a through testing before committing to change.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#3

Re: an answer

Bill Leffingwell

Thanks Bill.I will test soy bean oil,but the quick cross linking and lack of oozing is important to me as many times I market the boards within a few days of the oil application I suspect I will stick with walnut oil.

Bill

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#4

Dale Lenz

Bill L...

Dale Lenz

can't you order WO on line and have it shipped to your house? Better than driving 110 miles.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#5

Re: Bill L...

William Duffield

Mike Mahoney sells his "Utility Finish" (boiled walnut oil) in both 16 oz. and 5 gal. sizes, and ships direct.

http://www.bowlmakerinc.com/finishes.html

If you are pressed for time, you can go to your local grocery store (hopefully closer than 110 miles) and buy Loriva brand walnut oil from the salad oil section. It's pure walnut oil. Before I started using Mahoney's, that's what I used.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#6

Re: Bill L...

Don Stephan

My understanding of Mike Mahoney's Utility Oil is that pure walnut oil has been processed so that it will cure. I wouldn't expect walnut oil in a grocery store to have been similarly processed, thus I would expect it to turn rancid in time just like any other vegetable oil. I may be wrong.

Disappointed with the long curing time for Utility Oil, Ive been using a mix of equal parts boiled linseed oil, P&L 38 gloss varnish, and mineral spirits. It is fully cured in less than 48 hours and to my eye looks the same as Utility Oil.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#7

Re: Bill L...

john Veerkamp

I have used pure grocery store walnut oil. It didn't turn rancid but did take much longer to dry than Mike's heat treated oil.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#8

Re: Bill L...

Larry Barrett

I have used grocery store Walnut Oil (in the latest case identified as International Collection - pure walnut oil imported from the UK) successfully for many years as a finish on chairs. Thinned approx 50-50 with mineral spirits. Dries to the touch within a day.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#9

Re: Bill L...

William Duffield

I suspect that it's similar to the difference in drying time between raw and boiled linseed oil.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#10

Bob

A word of caution

Bob

You may want to stay away from "soybean oil" a lot of people are having severe reactions to it. My wife and her whole family are allergic to it to the point that we made an emergency room visit because she had eaten something with soybean in it. It does not happen every time but its soybean for sure.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#11

Bob

Re: Bill L...

Bob

Kind of pricy no?

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#12

Re: A word of caution

Dave Bair

Well, some other folks, my daughter for example, are deathly allergic to walnuts. I have argued for many years, on this forum and BP, that walnut oil as a finish for wood that will touch edibles should be carefully considered; at least warn prospective users that walnut oil is being used.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#13

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

Barry Irby

Look in Russ' Corner information. As I recall, he recommended Sunflower oil. Said it did not go rancid and NOBODY is allergic and it is nearly odorless.

Double check this because I am not sure.

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#14

no chemical basis for that claim

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All these oils are similar chemically, being composed of esters of glycerin and fatty acids. What differs among the various oils are the rations of these acids. What ever one will do the others will do, more or less.


Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#15

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

Bill Leffingwell

thank you all for the info.My problem has been running out of the walnut oil and then having to hunt more up in a hurry.I have been pleased with WO results so I will continue using it.I have bought it online for a number of years(best prices) and will be more diligent in ordering more before running out.

As for allergies,I mention the use of WO and hopefully the people will be aware of this if they have the allergy.

Bill

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

#16

Re: A question for Bill Tindall

TomD

If you get walnut oil from a grocery store make sure there is nothing added to it like vitamin e for anti-oxidant effect. That will stop it from drying.