I need to modify my fireplace mantle by adding a new, wider top. What type of paint should I use for it? I have painted several things over the years and have had the problem of things sticking to the paint, even months later. What do you suggest?
...is the industry term. Typically, what you want to use is a true acrylic enamel, not just any "latex" off the shelf of the borg. Enamels will tend to cost quite a bit more than standard "wall and trim" paint.
Another option would be to topcoat the paint with a clear acrylic topcoat (waterborne poly). Floor poly is much more durable and scuff resistant, making the likelihood of future repairs (harder to do with a clear coat) less.
If its painted as mine was, just semi-gloss or gloss would be fine. The reason being you can clean it with soap and water. Just don't use the cheap stuff.