I've been doing some research on jointers. There seems to be an issue as to which of the above cutterheads is preferable. Both seem to have advantages and disadvantages. I only have experience with the standard straight-knife cutterhead. The finished surface left by the standard cutterhead is very good. A cabinetmaker friend talked about a "fuzzy" surface left by a helical cutterhead. Does anyone have first hand experience with the helical cutterhead? Thanks.
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhead?
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhea
Paul Blackwell
I've had my Grizzly jointer with the helical cutterhead with carbide inserts for a little over a year now, and I'm very pleased with it. The finish is as smooth as I've ever experienced with a jointer. Little or no sanding is required. I highly recommend it.
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhead?
But I've heard that one too, not sure I believe it.
Friend of mine has a 16" PM planer that he put a Byrd head in, finish is amazing, especially in wood with interlocked grain, there's just no tear out. Save him tons of sanding time.
However, that guy is a professional. Spending another $1500 to improve that planer made a lot of sense in saved time and wages. I'd love to put those heads in my planer and jointer.... but its just not worth the cost to me. Straight knives work well enough for the light use they get in my shop, and I can save that money on lumber instead.
If you have the cash for it, they are a pleasure to use and a definite improvement.
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhead?
I just spent a couple of hours swapping out the knives in a 4" Delta jointer. I bought a Wood River Jig to help. It did make it easier, but still it was way too tedious. There has to be a better way. Sounds like the helical cutterhead is it.
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhead?
Barry I am looking also. My jointer is noisy and sometimes tears out wood. I made my own magnetic bit alignment tool so it doesn't take very long to put new blades in but they've gone up considerably in price.
My problem is justifying the price. The cutterhead costs as much as my jointer and since I am mostly a turner now the jointer is not one of my most used tools anymore. Oh well, maybe I won the lottery last night and this pesky money thing will now longer be an issue.
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhead?
Re: Jointers - Helical or Straight Knife Cutterhea
William Duffield
In addition to quieter operation and smoother surfaces, other advantages of the helical head are:
The chips are much shorter, and have much less tendency to clog your dust collection system, or to clog up the inside of your jointer after the ducts clog.
Downtime to replace knives is substantially shortened. The carbide cutters last much longer than the tool steel blades they replace. There is no alignment needed. You just loosen each head, turn it ninety degrees and retighten it in place. There is a little mark on one corner of each cutter, just in case you forget when you've rotated them four times. If you hit a nail, instead of removing three knives, installing and aligning three new knives and taking the old knives to be sharpened, you get out a torx wrench, find the chipped cutter, loosen it, turn it ninety degrees, tighten the cap screw back up, and you're ready to resume surfacing wood in less than three minutes.