Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

buying new forestner bits

Posts

buying new forestner bits

#1

buying new forestner bits

John Lucas

I purchase one of the really cheap taiwanese sets about 15 years ago. It's been OK. I'm sure the holes aren't as clean as the better ones and they sometimes burn wood. Here's my dilema. These are really getting work even after I've sharpened them a few times. I need a new set. Do I just buy another cheap set that should cut better than my worn ones, or is there a better option.

I've looked at the good bits and they are just out of my league. My insurance company has raised all my rates (you know we saw this coming) and that's left me a little on the broke side so I need to find a less expensive set. I would like to find a better quality than the bottom of the line but don't really know how you tell. I assume price is one way to tell at least from bottom of the line to top of the one but when you in the middle somewhere it's tough to figure out.

Is there a good brand. I purchased a single Freud bit one time and it definitly cut better. It wasn't as expensive as the top of the line. Anyone know how the Lee Valley bits work?

Re: buying new forestner bits

#2

Re: buying new forestner bits

Bill Howatt

I have a cheap set and some selected sizes of HSS LV bits. The LV bits are definitely better but I can't really say that I use them a lot but they do get used.

An obvious difference between my cheapies and the LV is that the larger LV sizes have hex shanks so they don't slip in the chuck.

Maybe just buying one and evaluate it would be an option? Or maybe there are just a few sizes you use a lot and they may(?) be cheaper individually than buying a set since you already have a set to go to if you really need an odd size once in a while.

Of course, there is always the LV guarantee if you don't like it.

Bill

Re: buying new forestner bits

#3

Re: buying new forestner bits

Tony-Memphis

I have been very pleased with the Lee Valley bits. I have used them on lots of projects including flat and spindle turnings. I work with maple, cherry, mahogany, and walnut typically. I have used them on a few imports I can't spell like makore and goncalo alves. No problems so far. I'd like to get some of the Colt bits, but they are pretty pricey.

Tony

Re: buying new forestner bits

#4

Re: buying new forestner bits

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have a set of woodcraft forstner bits. They work well, but then I do not put them through a professional working pace.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#5

same here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a cheap set and selected quality bits for the sizes more used.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#6

Re: buying new forestner bits

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

If you use a Colt maxi-cut bit in a hard wood like maple you will never wanna go back to the trash bits that we all think are OK because they are cheap. Your time is the most valuable tool in your shop (studio, excuse me). Just got my $37 1 1/2 " in the mail this morning. We are replacing ours as quickly as money allows.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#7

I've had a variety over the years...

John in NM

My current favorites are FAMAG German bits from Traditional Woodworker. I had one of their Chinese cheap bits too, and it doesn't cut straight on really deep holes. No clue why not, cutting face not perpendicular to the shaft perhaps. The quality ones cut straight though. Bear in mind though, I only notice on 3" deep or so holes.

I also have a few Freud bits, I like them a lot too. Also Fisch are quite good IMHO. I have a new Woodcraft generic bit, not as clean a hole but I don't drill deep holes with that size so I don't know how straight they cut.

I keep the very good ones for the challenging applications, like those really deep clean holes, then often use the cheaper ones for every day use.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#8

forstner bit sets

Merle

Rather than buying a set of anything, you will be better off buying better quality bits in the sizes you need. Invariably sets have sizes that you will never use. I bought a set of router bits once and have never used 3 of the 7 bits yet. FWIW

Re: buying new forestner bits

#9

Re: buying new forestner bits

John Lucas

Thanks for all the input so far. the reason I am looking for a set is I pretty much use all sizes and sets are less expensive than individual. A cheap set would get me buy but I'm at the age where I would like to step everything up a notch as far as my woodworking.

I'm thinking that a mid prices set might be the best option.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#10

Re: buying new forestner bits

John McGaw

I started with a fairly complete Asian set of dubious quality way back in the day. Rather than replace all of them I kept an eye on which ones were dulling and burning and replaced just those with high-quality Freud Forstner bits one or two at a time. Once most of them had been replaced over the years I bit the bullet and replaced the remainders. After that I bought special ones, metric or large diameter or extra-long for example, on an as-needed basis. No doubt the cost was no less doing it this way (probably a bit higher in fact) but it spread the pain out over a number of years. I did the same thing with router bits, starting with a truly crappy set maybe 20 years ago and replacing them piecemeal and adding new ones as needed until I finally trashed the last of the originals during a recent cleanup.

Re: buying new forestner bits

#11

What Bill Turpin said!!!!

Terry Quiram

I bought a couple of Colt bits and was so impressed I went back and bought a set. These bits are great.