Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Shellac Question

Posts

Shellac Question

#1

Shellac Question

Jerry Nicholson

I have had limited luck with shellac in the past but I decided to try it again. The first coat went on OK over walnut stained with Watco Dark Walnut. However, the second coat, applied after sanding the first coat smooth with 600 grit paper, looked strange and dried with bumps and lumps. I would call it reticulated. I have scraped some of it off and it scrapes readily. The first coat seemed dry and sanded easily. Did I not wait long enough between coats or do I just not know enough about using shellac? I am aware that the alcohol in the second coat will at least partially dissolve the first coat. I used fresh denatured alcohol to dissolve the shellac flakes. I prepared a 1 1/2 pound cut, unless I made a big fat mistake.

The Watco dried for two days and none of the stain is coming up when I scrape the shellac.

Jerry

Re: Shellac Question

#2

Re: Shellac Question

Howard Acheson

I would bet that the Watco ws not fully dried/cured. Watco is primarily mineral spirits and linseed oil with a small amount of resin (varnish). The resin quickly dries and give the appearance of being fully dry. But it's not. When you sanded the Watco, you removed some or all of the partially dried resin exposing the remaining resin to the alcohol in the shellac. The alcohol is a more aggressive solvent than the mineral spirits in the Watco so it partially dissolved some of your Watco finish.

I would let it dry for 5-7 days then sand it smooth with 400 paper. Once it's fully dry, re-coat.

Re: Shellac Question

#3

Re: Shellac Question

Jerry Nicholson

I will continue to scrape off the shellac and wait a week or so before I try again. I am using shellac on the inside of a couple of keepsake boxes I am building so there won't be any smell from the finish.

Jerry

Re: Shellac Question

#4

Re: Shellac Question

joseph mulherin,sr

Howard, would this also be true for the chairs I am building? And the blotching came thru a hell of a lot too.

I am thinking I should use Charles Neil's Blotch Control, then shellac, let dry for a week, then apply the color stain and let dry for another week.

Re: Shellac Question

#5

Re: Shellac Question

don stephan

Joseph:

You'll likely have to experiment to get the results you seek. A wash coat of shellac is often used for blotch control, so if you use two approaches you might not get much color.

Re: Shellac Question

#6

Flock

Jerry Nicholson

Maybe I will just buy a flocking kit and flock the whole inside of the boxes. That would bypass the stain and shellac problem. I think the last time I tried to use shellac I used stripper to take it all off and went back to my old stand by, wiping varnish.

I really don't like finishing!

Jerry

Re: Shellac Question

#7

Re: Shellac Question

Todd Nebel

I agree with Howard, Watco needs to dry 5-7 days before applying shellac. I stopped using Watco and use a dye and boiled linseed oil instead.

Re: Shellac Question

#8

The first rule of using shellac.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....and any other finish. Don't do chemistry experiments on the product. Do them on test pieces. Nearly every finishing question that comes along has the same theme. Something untried was applied to the project with an unanticipated result to be rescued. Finishing products are chemicals, and in this case largely unknown chemicals. Mixing won't lead to explosions but unexpected results are still likely. Mixing top coats is especially risky, as was demonstrated.

We rarely know what is in a finish so it is impossible to predict a result when they are used or worse mixed. Hence, experimenting on a test piece is always prudent.

In the case of shellac we do know what is in it and used alone it is predictable, most of the time. But even here lurk surprises, like the first time I applied it using a disposable foam brush. The brush dissolved, leaving gray particles stuck in the finish. (White home-made foam brushes do fine)

There are aspects of this problem that remain unclear. For example, if the goal was to have a pleasant odor inside the object why was Watco used before the shellac? On the outside, what was the objective of using Watco? If the goal was to stain, then something designed to stain and be over coated would be a more logical choice for coloring.

Finishing should be the most enjoyable part of a project. It is here that the finished result is revealed and the project becomes "finished" and ready for use. Perhaps the assumption is made that because finishing is "simply" moving stuff from can to wood that it should be easy. No practice or experience needed. Perhaps this approach leads to a disappointing result. The solution to this problem is to use a different stuff next time that is "Easy to Apply" or so it says on the can.

A more successful approach to finishing is to approach it like cutting dovetails. Presume it will require practice. Learn to use the proposed product and become satisfied with the result before applying it to furniture.

That said, I shellac the insides of stuff I build. It makes drawers slide nicely. Smells good. Seals. Buy Zinsser premixand it is a cheap finish. Use "garnet" if you want some color. I apply with a synthetic bristle brush or there is a disposable brush from Woodworkers Supply that works for shellac.

Re: Shellac Question

#9

Re: Shellac Question

del schisler

i would use charles neil blotch control and not use shellac after , that is what the blotch control is for to keep the blotching on the wood when staining , i guess if you are filling grain ? i don't know about that, i use blocth control all the time and never any shellac, so maybe some one will chime in my 2 cents

Re: Shellac Question

#10

Re: Shellac Question

joseph mulherin,sr

Thank you, Del, I shall order a bottle of the blotch control to use on my next two chairs.

Re: Shellac Question

#11

Re: The first rule of using shellac.....

Jerry Nicholson

I like the appearance of Watco Black Walnut on walnut. I have been using it for years, normally with finish coats of Minwax wiping varnish, and have never had any kind of problem. The only reason for the shellac on the inside of the boxes was to avoid any lingering varnish odor. I had considered forgoing the Watco on the inside of the boxes and using a few coats of water based poly. Now, of course, that is what I wish I had done.

Jerry

Re: Shellac Question

#12

Re: The first rule of using shellac.....

Jerry Roberts

Bill, I too use Zinsser shellac but I find the finish too shiney to suit me. Do you know if Zinsser comes in anything except gloss and is shellac supposed to be glossey? All I have found here is just the one kind. Thanks.

Re: Shellac Question

#13

Shellac Flat *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

clic link and scroll to the bottom of the page for the product you ask about.


Homestead Shellac

Re: Shellac Question

#14

shiny shellac

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

4/0 wool renders it less shiny, or at least that is the solution I use when needed.