Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

repairing bench dog holes

Posts

repairing bench dog holes

#1

repairing bench dog holes

John Lucas

I built my workbench from an Oak solid core door that I got free years ago. It's been a great work bench. I used the round bench dogs and a couple of the round hold fast clamps. A few of the holes have gotten elongated from using the hold fasts in them for all these years so I need to come up with a fix. Any good suggestions. They are 3/4" holes

I'm a woodturner so my first thought was to simply drill some 2" or so holes about half way through and then maybe 1 1/2 the rest of the way through and make an oak plug to match. Then drill 3/4" holes in the center of these. Well actually I would drill the 3/4" holes first and then turn the plug.

Anyone have a better idea.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#2

Build a new work bench. 


Re: repairing bench dog holes

#3

Re: repairing bench dog holes

Stephen Kirk

Drilling and plugging sounds about the easiest. I'm not sure if epoxy could fill a hole that large, but something like that might also work.

My first bench was a solid core door. Worked well for many years. I even retrofit a wagon vise onto it.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#5

Re: 3/4" id mild steel pipe

John Lucas

Dick would that damage my Hold Fasts. I doubt they are hardened steel since they need to have some spring.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#6

Re: 3/4" id mild steel pipe

R Payne

Hardening steel does not change the amount of spring, just the failure mode. The amount of spring is dependent on the modulus of elasticity (Young's if I remember correctly) and cross section. If I was to make hold fasts I'd heat treat them like a spring.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#7

You always have a good reason.

Galen Vetterick

John

From someone that never used bench dogs I was wondering.

Why drill a more complicated stepped hole if the plugs are glued in well? Wood movement over time or what?

Turning a plug I know is easier end grain but would cross grain give you a stronger wall plug at least in the direction of force on the piece? If the plug is supported by the existing wood how much plug wall would be needed?

Just wanting to learn. Who knows. I may need to plug something.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#8

Re: 3/4" id mild steel pipe

Keith Newton

John, I like the idea of using 3/4" pipe as well, and I don't think you have to worry about damage, especially if you bevel the top edges.

Not knowing how much oversize the holes are, I was thinking of getting your plumbing supplier to cut some extra long threads on some bushings for this. Then get yourself a NPT tap, which you can thread the newly enlarged holes, then epoxy the inserts in. the threads would really lock well into the top.

I often use standard thread taps into wood for jigs and or mounting special hardware.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#9

Bob

Re: repairing bench dog holes

Bob

John I like your idea of a plug but I would try to match the direction of the grain as mentioned below in another comment. And yes I to would use epoxy, something like west systems thay have one for wood.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: repairing bench dog holes

Jesper, Denmark

Hi John,

My preference would be the wood plug with the 3/4" hole drilled through. The metal pipe would invite nicks i any cutting tools used on the surface of the bench and if set below the bench surface, collect dust.

You should note thet the ID dimension of standard schedule 40 pipe is 0.82 inches. The link provided is for steel TUBING, which has the right ID, but may be a little difficult to source.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#11

Re: repairing bench dog holes

Jason Waters

Good idea here.

If you are going to use metal, order from online metals or somewhere as suggested to get tubing easier to work with due to ID/OD issues. However, I would use something like brass tubing, softer and easier. A lot more expensive though. Aluminum could be used too, it's cheaper than brass and available in more sizes. And I'd still set it a little below the bench top, maybe a 1/4, and then put a 1/4 plug over the top, and redrill a new hole from the bottom through the brass or aluminum tubing (with a backer on top to prevent tearout). Make sure if you use tubing to sand and rough up the outside well so it will bond well.

As for matching the grain, I don't see how it matters except aesthetically. I'm betting the door is particle board core and not laminated strips? If so, that's why the holes elongated probably.

My bench is built from a standard solid core door (luan sides, particle core) that I edge banded with brazilian cherry and put a piece of laminate on the top. It has help up really well, and is hard to beat for the money (particulary since the cherry was bought cheap and the laminate was a piece the corner was broke off I got it real cheap). My next one will probably be a maple top. I've been thinking of buying the laminated kitchen countertop, it's gotten fairly inexpensive from several places.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#12

JL

Re: repairing bench dog holes

JL

Brass or copper sleeves?

Actually, I'd just turn some 2" plugs out of maple or birch (or white oak) and drill the center out when it's in the bench. I have a nice attachment for a drill that lets you drill vertical holes (or any other set angle).

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#13

Re: repairing bench dog holes

John Lucas

Jason this door is solid oak strips with a maple veneer to hide the strips. It's really heavy. I'm not worried about appearance. I thought If I turn the plugs from end grain then all the forces of the Hold Fast will be pushing against the end grain and they may last longer. I built this bench about 15 years ago so it's done pretty well so far.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#14

Re: repairing bench dog holes

John Lucas

JL I have a radial drill press so I think I can set near the work bench and swing the arm around and extend it enough to drill the holes. Failing that I'll just make a jig and use the router.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#15

Re: 3/4" id mild steel pipe

John Lucas

I'm still a little leary of the steel. I know I can leave it dead soft and it probably won't hurt the Hold fasts which have been hardened and then tempered back to be spring steel. I'm just worried that it will leave marks in the hold fasts and they will either slip or be hard to insert. Also not sure I want metal near my edge tools.

It would be simple enough to turn it down or weld on a collar to make it sit flush so I might still consider that. I can buy all sorts of steel locally and have a metal lathe and welder.

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#16

Re: repairing bench dog holes

Jason Waters

I'm sure a wood plug repair should last as long as the original in that case. 15 years is pretty good. I doubt a newer door would be solid core like you have. Haven't seen one in a long time. Not a flat slab sided one anyway.

Jason

Re: repairing bench dog holes

#17

Re: repairing bench dog holes, how about..

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi John,

How about drilling them out to 1-1/2", add a 3/4" backer to the bottom of the bench top, then plug the drilled out holes, and re-drill new dog holes. The thicker area around the dog holes should help them last longer and also keep the plugs from dropping out the bottom etc.

They also might last 20-25 years so you won't have to do this again in 15 years:)

Bob in NJ.