Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Posts

Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#1

Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Derek Arita

Finishes are very expensive these days and wasting it is something I can't afford to do. That's one of the things that keeps me from spraying my finishes. When I buy a quart of waterbourne poly, I know I'll use about 1/2 of it to finish a cabinet. I'm afraid if I use my HVLP, I'll use far more and lose lots of it in overspray. Am I wrong to think this?

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#2

JL

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

JL

Finishes are very expensive these days and wasting it is something I can't afford to do. That's one of the things that keeps me from spraying my finishes. When I buy a quart of waterbourne poly, I know I'll use about 1/2 of it to finish a cabinet. I'm afraid if I use my HVLP, I'll use far more and lose lots of it in overspray. Am I wrong to think this?

My personal experience (and I'm no expert on spraying) - it's all in the technique and the project. I can use my HVLP spray system and spray flat work (i.e. a bar) and use less finish than brushing the finish on. However if I'm doing a chair with lots of spindles and turnings, I use more finish.

YMMV

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#3

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

del schisler

i spray lacquer all the time, i don't have hardly and over spray, i set the gun air to 30 lbs of air and use a 2 mm nozzel, of course when you spray you start from the closes and move out away , that way no over spray on the nice finish , whan you start the spray from away and move in closer than that is whatn you get over spray on the finish, i don't belive the HVLP gun will use more finish and the amount of over spray will be high if the air is up on the high side, i guess you could test it your self say take a couple oz of lacquer or poly and spray a pattern and see how far you get and than use a brush and brush on the finish and see how far that went ?? , i belive the finish you get with the spray out weigh's the loss of material?

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#4

Bob

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Bob

Here is my take on one vs. the other: How much do you loose when cleaning the brush or tossing the rag? Some finishes have almost doubled in cost over the past few years. You may just have to pass the cost along, it only amounts to a few dollars and what I mean by a few is less then $5.00.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#5

Too Many Variables

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Transfer Efficiency (can-to-surface) is near 100% in hand applications whereas it will reach only 70-80% with a quality spray outfit that is correctly set for the particular coating being applied. As mentioned, the shape of the workpiece has an effect as well.

All that said, however, has to be modified by a bottom line analysis of how much finish is left in the can when the job is done. That will vary widely depending on the entire finish routine and the materials. For examples: 1-Closed pore or open pore wood? 2- Filled-pore (piano) finish or open grain? 3- Reactive (oil) or solvent (shellac/lacquer) or waterborne finish? 4- Pre-sealed or pre-filled surface (shellac or sanding sealer) or raw wood? An open pore wood like walnut or oak will take a lot more finish to achieve a smooth, filled-pore surface than say cherry or maple.

If you have to "level" and rub out a hand-applied coating to get an acceptable surface, you will actually be removing a fair percentage of the finish you applied with the brush, whereas a properly set up HVLP application will often produce a finish surface "off-the-gun" that needs no further work making the HVLP option the more efficient from the net-net view at the end of the job.

Then there's the coating itself and how that is prepared (thinned, diluted, etm.) which will effect how well it applies, flows out, and self levels.

All this and I haven't answered your question, but hopefully I've given you some questions to address. Bottom line, do a test if you wish:

Measure out a specific amount of a finish and then apply it by both methods to a pair of pieces of wood that are prepared in the same way. You'll need to carefully adjust the size of your spray fan to minimize over-spray. Do the same number of coats being careful to use as little as possible. Compare how much you have left of each or note which you ran out of first.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#6

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Derek Arita

Thanks for the replies. I just remember back to my days of air brushing R/C car bodies...after completing a painting session, I always found lots of paint dust all over the place. I used to think I got more paint on the floor than I did the piece I was painting.

If you add the $ I spend on the gas for the 1 1/2 hour, round trip to the WW store...I'm having to cut back on finishes and wood. It's amazing what a difference 10 years can make.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#7

Bob

Re: Too Many Variables

Bob

Good answer.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Mostly.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The only point with which I would disagree is doing the brush v. spray test using the same number of coats. I don't think that's a fair comparison.

I'm not happy with the direction the cost of finishes have gone (I'm a painting contractor--in 10 years, our prices have pretty much doubled), but in the overall scope of the vast majority of projects, be it painting a room or finishing an end table, finish is such a small aspect of the overall cost. I'd much rather spray a piece, wasting $5-10 worth of finish than have to deal with brush marks throughout the finishing process or look at them every time I saw the piece when it's done.

And, some of the others are correct--technique has a LOT to do with transfer efficiency. What I see automotive painters doing with their spray guns would never fly on one of my job sites--they put way too much material in the air, relying on their spray booth to keep things clean, something not possible on most job sites.

Jason

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#9

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Dick Coers

You have it backwards. HVLP guns have a transfer efficiency that is double traditional siphon feed guns. Around 50% for HVLP, 20-25% for traditional siphon feeds. The high volume low pressure guns had to be redesigned so that it would atomize the materials at pressures around 30 psi, versus 45-50% for the old traditional guns.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#10

HVLP  PSI?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not sure what HLVP gun(s) you're referring to Dick, but my CAT Tech Jr. (shellacs, toning, and glazing) uses 10psi and the "big" Walcom/pressure pot rig I use for top coats runs very nicely at 15-20psi with waterborne finishes. Both guns are controlled by on-board 2nd stage regulators for very precise pressures. My T/E on both guns is way over the 50% you mention.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#11

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

james jacomb

Today was the first time I used my HVLP. I shot an oil modified water based poly, what a learning cure this is going to be. I noticed how fast it sets, and builds on the nozzle. It even appears to leave little "poly threads" on the surface, might be the product is not suited to spraying. But when you figure costs I also have to take into account the labor savings if it took less time and the labor rate involved. Doesn't take much labor cost to buy material!

Think I need to check out water based lacquer vs poly.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#12

Re: HVLP  PSI?

Dick Coers

I just did a quick Google to try and get some numbers for the OP. I have an older Binks, Mach 1. I forgot that the line pressure is around 30psi, but it is regulated at the gun to 10psi. Sorry for the bad numbers.

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

#13

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Does HVLP Use More Finish?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I've not found WB poly to spray very well. Also, it doesn't meld in to earlier coats like lacquer does.

My preference is WB lacquers. Two of the best I've found are General Finishes "Enduro" and Targer E6000. Both spray beautifully, and bot 'burn in' well.

If you need a Pre-catalyzed WB lacquer, M.L. Campbell "Agualente" is a good one.