Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Posts

Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#1

Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Mark

I need to drive hex bolts, and occasionally nuts and bolts at the cottage for the three pipe docks we have.

I have been looking at the Dewalt 18v impact drivers and the Dewalt 18v impact wrenches.

Keep in kind this is for maybe 10 set bolts that secure the pipes on the docks...not a tire changing shop

Seems the impact wrenches are not sold as kits that easily that I can find , meaning you have to buy the wrench AND the charger + battery as extras.

My question is does it matter?

If I can get a 1/4 onch to 3/8 inch socket adapter for the impact driver ( which is more available as full kits ) that will allow me to use all the sockets I need ......or should I be getting the wrench because the driver is not really the right tool for nut and bolt driving

Any experience or comments out there on this

Also as a driver for screws etc , seems more useful and multipurpose..then the wrench which only drives nuts and bolts .....

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#2

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Barry

If you are looking for the cheapest alternative, what's wrong with a ratchet and socket? I would think this would be quite acceptable unless you have an awful lot of bolts and nuts.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#3

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Mark

Thanks but it is a little bit of having to hold it up ( 12 foot long dock ) and get it tightened at the same time..I don't have three guys doing this so I need to be able to get the dock in position, pole in position and tighten it fast and tight.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#4

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Barry

I was in my neighborhood Lowe's during Christmas and noticed that DeWalt now has 20-volt cordless drills and imapct drivers. Some of the motors are brushless, which is new technology that delivers more power with fewer parts and no brushes to replace. I bought a DeWalt 12-volt impact driver/drill combo last year and have been very pleased with it. The lithium batteries are great. The 18-volt batteries can be a bit heavy and cumbersome. If I were you I'd try to spring for the 20-volt version unless it is just cost-prohibitive. I'd be very surprised if the 18 or 20-volt didn't meet your needs. Lowe's was offering some very good deals on the 18-volt models just before Christmas.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#5

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Mark

Thanks Barry I was concerned the driver wouldn't deliver the tongue for bolts etc ( versus the wrench) but sounds like you see the power in the driver.

Also i would think the driver is more versatile.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#6

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Dustmaker Mike

Howdy I am in the process of replacing a few battery operated tools, and have done a little research to figure out what is what. I went with LiOn batterry technology because it seems to hold up a lot longer under usage. I was helping a friend redo his deck and I had the 18V DeWalt kit and I. Would have to recharge twice as much and it wouldn't drive the screws as deep or fast as his 20V max impact driver his was lighter as well.

The 20V max impact driver spins fast even under load. I was just at a Blue Borg and they had a few on clearance. Also DeWalt has a set of impact sockets that fit into te chucks with no adapters required.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#7

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Barry

Lowe's was selling the 18-volt Drill with charger and one nickle-cadmium battery for $99.00 (about 1/2 price) before Christmas. When something is offered for a price that good, it usually means one thing.........there's something better coming. Well, "it" is already here! "It" is the 20-volt lithium-ion line-up. I have the 12-volt driver/drill combo with two batteries and a charger. The batteries are half the size of nickel-cadmium and have a run time that is much longer. My 12-volt driver and drill have an amazing amount of torque. Either will drive a 3" deck screw edge-wise in a 2X4 without breaking a sweat. If the 20-volt had been out when I bought mine, I would have probably sprung for the 20-volt, but I have been quite satisfied with my 12-volt combo. Now, they have the 20-volt with "brushless" motors, which allows for a more compact and more efficient tool.

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

#8

Re: Impact Driver versus Impact Wrench

Barry

If my 12-volt combo is any indicator, what you intend to do with 18-volts ought to be a piece of cake.