Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Gel Stain Help, Please...

Posts

Gel Stain Help, Please...

#1

Gel Stain Help, Please...

Derek Arita

I've been doing some tests looking for the right finish procedure for some red oak, to match typical yellowed oak kitchen cabinets. I got some GF Golden Pine Gel Stain to test. What I found is that using the stain straight from the can to the wood, the finish is too dark and too brown, however if I take the cloth with residual stain and rub that on, then it looks pretty good. Trying to duplicate that is really tough, as what works well, is when there's just a little left over stain on the cloth. Question is, can I thin the gel or lighten it in some way? By the way, I'm using GF Arm R Seal, oil and urethane top coat. I was originally thinking about spraying waterborne on this, but now I'm thinking wipe on might be simpler and more direct. First I have to learn how to use the sprayer, then I can think about using it on a project.

Here's what I'm trying to match...

[URL=http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/18/img0605ji.jpg/][/URL]

Re: Gel Stain Help, Please...

#2

Here is your problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For the next year or two the wood is going to darken and the finish is likely to yellow. The finish will most assuredly yellow if it is urethane based. Hence, if you match now, you won't later.

You can lessen the take of the stain by pretreating the wood with the General Finishes conditioner which, according to the General formulations person, is the stain less the pigment. Another approach is to dilute the stain with this conditioner or linseed oil. And, apply the stain with a "rubber" like shellac is applied to control the take- see picture.


Re: Gel Stain Help, Please...

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When it comes to using an untried finish schedule practice is essential. Never practice on the final product.

Re: Gel Stain Help, Please...

#4

Re: Here is your problem

Derek Arita

So, if I apply the GF Arm R Seal directly, in a year or two it will yellow like the rest of the cabinets?

Re: Gel Stain Help, Please...

#5

Where life gets complicate

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are dozens of materials used to make the film forming component of finishes, depending on the product to be made. Some yellow more and some yellow less. Even if we just consider "urethanes" there are numerous urethane formulations that yellow more (aromatic) or less (aliphatic). Acrylics yellow much less, to not at all, but the wood beneath will still darken. So, unless you repeat what was done before there is no telling whether a new finish will wind up more or less dark or yellow.

If the finish is yellow in the can it is a good bet that it will be yellow on the wood and likely get more so with time.

I would be inclined to target some fresh look that was a bit lighter than the aged oak and hope for the best. A close match after 2 years will be a crap shoot.

As an example, I did a small filled patch on some ash which was white when I did it. It was finished with a "nonyellowing" "water white" aliphatic conversion varnish. Over time the finish still darkened some as did the wood. The light patch stands out in stark contrast to the aged wood.

Re: Gel Stain Help, Please...

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Here is your problem

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

The finish may yellow, too, but the real color change is within the wood itself.

Nearly any wood will experience some color change over time and UV exposure. Cherry is the most dramatic of changes, but pine, oak, maple, etc. will also show some degree of color change. Most will darken, but walnut (and some others, too) will actually lighten a bit over time.