Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Finishing problem

Posts

Finishing problem

#1

Finishing problem

Warren White

My friend (a real craftsman) has built a couple of new cabinets for his front room. He made the cabinets out of material he salvaged from cabinets he made before and from new materials.

We sprayed the cabinets with flat black as a primer and then with semi gloss black as the finish coat. So far the parts (door fronts and trim) made from MDF look good; the parts he salvaged from pre-finished plywood also look like glass. The problem is the parts made from new wood (most evident on the sides which are made from unfinished plywood) look awful. The grain of the plywood is showing through. All parts were thoroughly sanded.

In hind sight, I think we should have used shellac as a sealer for the wood and then sprayed it.

The questions are: 1) Will additional coats of the semi gloss finally cover the grain? 2) If not, what do we do?

Thank you so much. The folks on this forum are great!

Warren

Re: Finishing problem

#2

Re: Finishing problem

William Duffield

You didn't tell us what type of paint you used. If it was water based, it would have raised the grain on the plywood. You also didn't tell us what your sanding schedule was on the new ply, and you didn't tell us what kind of plywood you used. I assume is was something better than CDX rotary cut pine :) Your best bet is MDO, a paint grade, pre-primed waterproof ply used by sign painters, but that is hard to find and expensive, and anyway it's too late for that now.

Re: Finishing problem

#3

Re: Finishing problem

Howard Acheson

>>>> The questions are: 1) Will additional coats of the semi gloss finally cover the grain? 2) If not, what do we do?

What is the species of the veneer on the plywood? If it's a prominent grained wood like oak, you will have a tough job smoothing it to the point that the grain is perfectly flat and not noticeable. The only way to do it is to use a grain filler and that can be problematic if you are not familiar with the process.

If you wanted a smooth surface where the grain did not show, a maple or birch faced plywood should have been used.

Re: Finishing problem

#4

Re: Finishing problem

Warren White

William and Howard,

Thank you for being so quick to reply.

The paint is waterbased, purchased at a local big box. Expensive stuff, which in order to spray with my HVLP, was thinned with water. I do it all the time on pre-primed moldings with great results. (But it is pre-primed ;-( )

The ply is maple, also bought at a big box. My friend has used this before with great results, but he usually paints it himself by hand. He was under a time crunch and asked for my help.

Will additional coats help? Or are we doomed?

Warren

Re: Finishing problem

#5

Re: Finishing problem

John Veerkamp

Not an expert, but I think that if you lightly sand the offending pieces with a rigid sanding block, a few additional coats will really help. Be sure to sand between coats. May not be quite as perfect as your other sides, but will definitely improve it.

My 5 cents(think Lucy)

Re: Finishing problem

#6

Seems to me that if it's now painted

Gary Smyth

you have sealed it. Without a picture it's hard to provide opinions. That said, can it be sanded again? With the piece now sealed (AND DRY) and if it can be resanded (320) and the HVLP providing properly mixed top coats, I don't see why in this case more might not be better. Is the piece supposed to be glossy/reflective? What is the intended final color?

Re: Finishing problem

#7

Re: Finishing problem

Jim Hoeller

I made a small base for a statue that was to be semi-gloss black. I used hard maple and discovered that no matter how well I thought I had sanded, small defects showed. I talked to another wood worker who had repaired finishes on black grand pianos and he urged me to quit thinking wood and think automotive. He recommended an automotive primer that fills minor imperfections and a semi-gloss laquer both in a spray can. The primer filled all of the defects and sanded smooth enough that two coats of the black laquer looked great.

Re: Finishing problem

#8

Re: Finishing problem

Dick Coers

Since it is maple, "covering the grain" shouldn't be that big of an issue. A picture would be a big help. Are you seeing a different look from one piece of veneer to the next on the sheet? When they bookmatch veneer, you get one side of the veneer that was away from the knife, the next piece you get the side that was against the knife. They will show differently because of minor checking in the veneer from the slicing process. I suggest you sand it hard with 180 or 220 to level everything out. Then fill with a filler of choice, even drywall compound could be used. Then sand the filler, use a compatible primer, sand, primer, sand, final coat or two. As mentioned, for a quality paint job, it's not the paint that does the job. It's the prep and base coats that sets the quality.

Re: Finishing problem

#9

failed to fill

Bill Tindall

The first coat should have been something like Kilz which builds a heavy coat of material which can then be sanded glass smooth before applying top coats.

Re: Finishing problem

#10

To all who have responded....

Warren White

....our thanks for your suggestions.

There is a real time crunch here, so although we would love to, we can't essentially start over again. We are also up against some temperature and rain considerations that limit what we can do.

We have has fairly good success with the suggested light sanding, painting, light sanding and painting. Most of the issues are resolved. This has been a valuable lesson in surface preparation for both of us that will improve our success next time. As implied (and stated), there is no substitute for surface preparation. Sometimes I forget that in my haste to get something done.

Again, your help and observations have been most helpful. It kept me, at least, from pulling what little hair that I have left out.

Thanks again!

Warren