OT: Ear Buds or Headset
Stuart Johnson
I would like to find a ear bud or comfortable head set with a standard 3.5mm plug that is good at blocking out loud noise. Any suggestions that won't break the bank?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT: Ear Buds or Headset
Stuart Johnson
I would like to find a ear bud or comfortable head set with a standard 3.5mm plug that is good at blocking out loud noise. Any suggestions that won't break the bank?
Well not Ear Buds
Dustmaker Mike
I have worn them a few times while flying around the world and I hate them they hurt my ears. As for a head set I now use a set of Bose noise blocking and love them but they will break the bank. I also have a set of Philips brand that I used to use and they worked OK. I went to Best Buy and tried a few sets on before I got the Philips set. If you have a Best Buy around I would try them on for fit before I bought a set.
Buds
John in NM
I have a couple sets of Jbuds, and like them a lot. I believe most modern buds are made in the same Chinese factory, just like a lot of tools are.
The thing to look for is those little silicone cups instead of foam covers, a lot of brands have them. They really make a good seal with your ear (though not on a par with ear plugs or noise canceling units) and keep the buds from irritating when worn for hours.
The JLab brand comes with three sizes of those cups, probably most other brands to as well. I always buy the cheap ones myself, never over $20 or so. I can't hear any difference in quality and comfort in use is the priority for me. I've worn the set I have for 8 hours before it really got to where I wanted to take them out - wasn't the usual irritation like with the foam buds, it was more like just fatigue from noise.
I have been considering
Merle
the Klipsch S4 earbuds. They got a great review on CNET. My reluctance has been the amount of noise isolation (-16) they provide. I don't know if that would be adequate hearing protection in the shop.
http://www.amazon.com/Klipsch-IMAGE-S4-Noise-Isolating-Headphones/dp/B001V9LPT4/ref=pd_cp_e_0
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset
JasoninOC
These ear plugs are good for both audio quality and sound isolation, at a variety of price points.
For long durations, ear muffs get sweaty and uncomfortable on me. Etymotics has a variety of ear plug sizes to help with the "sore ear canal" issue.
http://www.etymotic.com/
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset
Dave Bair
Peltor "worktunes" have a jack for external sources like an ipod but also receive AMFM signals. They also work well as hearing protectors.
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset
John McGaw (Bodger)
Not buds (I figure that the uncomfortable unwearable things that come with an iPad are buds) but in-ear units are the way to go. Even relatively inexpensive ones come with multiple silicone rubber flangy fittings that make them suitable for most any ear configuration. The best ones provide very reasonable isolation from external sounds along with superior sound quality. I'm wearing Koss units now when I exercise and for a couple of hours a day they are quite comfortable but I really bought them because they were on sale and I occasionally break units since I use then so often and sometimes roughly. As someone else noted, Etymotic Research is super and they have custom units that are fitted by an audiologist in the same way as a hearing aid but they are way beyond my budget. Here is a link to a recent review of various brands that might be of help:
http://reviews.cnet.com/best-earbuds/
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset
vamatt
This is actually my first time being able to help someone else out on the forum. So here it goes, I owned the Klipsh S4 and they had amazing sound but minimal noise reduction. They also fell out if you got sweaty. They broke after a year of use/abuse. I'm going to buy another pair for traveling, b/c i've never heard better headphones. BUT I would not recommend these for a "shop set" due to durability and mediocre noise cancellation. by brother is in a band and he turned me on to noise reducing headphones that drummers use for recording. so i bought the vic firth set for $50 on amazon. they have held up for the few months i have had them. the sound is not as good as klipsch, but is quite adequate. the noise reduction is MUCH better (as good as my ear muff style hearing protectors). I'd defintely recommend, although I haven't owned them for too long so I don't know about durability yet.
matt
Klipsch S4
Merle
Matt, thanks for the info. I have Peltor headphones, but I wear glasses and after a while, the headphones and glasses together get uncomfortable. Also, the glasses prevent a good seal around my ears letting unwanted decibels in. Guess I need to keep looking for a reasonably priced noise cancelling bud.
Re: Klipsch S4
vamatt
Unless the buds have active (white noise) noise canceling, then i think they're all about the same in noise canceling properties. not sure of the durability of buds, so good luck.
cheers,
matt
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset -thanks
Stuart Johnson
Thanks for all the answers. I looks like the price can range from around $10 for some Panasonic buds to hundreds for Bose. In looking at the different suggestions I came across Ryobi Tek4 for around $50. I'm going to give them a try and can at least return them to HD if they don't work.
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset -thanks
Yonak
Stuart, I don't think I would care to return something that was in my ears to the store. At least, I wouldn't want to be the next person to buy them.
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset -thanks
Stuart Johnson
These aren't bud, they fit over the ear. I do understand what you mean.
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset
NickinMass
I haven't used them myself, but my wife just got a set of Panasonic Marshmallow ear buds and tells me that they work great at blocking external noise (I think they were less than $20 at a local electronics place). Myself, I use Sony ear buds (MDR-ED12 - just had to buy a new pair b/c I lost my MP3 player) that are comfortable but don't really block out noise (when I'm wearing them in the shop - mostly for power sanding - I just put a pair of muffs over). I have custom molded earplugs for really blocking out noise (they do a great job blocking noise and you can wear them all day).
Re: OT: The answer
Rick L
http://www.howardleight.com/ear-protection/earmuffs Noise comtrol and stereo ear phones
Re: OT: Ear Buds or Headset -thanks
Leo Cuellar
I've had a set of these for over a year now. They are very tough and have put up with getting knocked about & rained on in an industrial setting. I don't have an ipod or similar (not allowed at work any way) so can't say anything for sound quality through the jack. They are non-discriminatory, so you won't be able to hear voices well over loud machinery, however the microphone does pick up sound well though, if ambient noise levels are low, you can hear people talking at distances you wouldn't be able to un-aided
It is also pretty directional, if you put them on backwards you will hear sound from behind you better than from the front. Bad thing is the pads don't last long before going hard, and you can only order them directly from Ryobi on a very hard to find corner of their website.
I think I have a pair of every type discussed
Chad Pearson
I have a pair of the Bose over-ear noise canceling headphones, a couple of different versions of the over the ear Sony noise canceling headphones, a pair of the Klipsch S4 buds, a few different pair of the Shure buds, including their top of the line models and innumerable pairs of the 20-30 dollar pairs of noise canceling buds. To be absolutely honest the only pair of any of them I regret buying is the very low end Sony noise canceling headphones. All of the others offer relatively good value for the money.
Bits of wisdom:
I travel a fair amount and find that ear buds start to hurt on a 10 hour flight. For long flights and if you are not price sensitive I would recommend the Bose over ear headphones. Very comfortable and good at eliminating droning noises like airplane engines.
For listening to music in a very noisy environment I would buy one of the Shures with the expanding foam plugs. They work the best at canceling ALL noise. Price points for the Shure brand mostly relate to how good the speaker quality is within the earbud. The very high end ones (retail around $500) have remarkable sound. I would not however appreciate them if I was mowing the lawn or running the jointer. The value simply isn't there because no matter how well they block noise you aren't going to appreciate the sound quality with whatever residual sound is left.
If I wanted to block a little noise and have decent sound then the 20 dollar price point buds work well enough. Kids love them on the airplane and the wife uses them for mowing.
Have you found any earbuds
Merle
that would do a good job of cancelling noise, think dust collector and TS? My current earphones claim to have a NRR of 26. I am not an audiophile so don't need top of the line Shure quality. TIA
Re: Have you found any earbuds
Chad Pearson
I think the only ones that are truly very good at canceling noise are the Shure brand. This is because they are essentially just a set of foam plugs with a speaker tube poking through. If you are looking for just blocking out noise, (as opposed to blocking out nose and playing music) then I don't think anything beats a simple pair of foam earplugs. The over the ear noise canceling headphones certainly won't be as good for eliminating jointer noise. They are however great for comfort and for making a long airplane ride a little less stressful.
BTW - I forgot to mention in my thread above that with all the different types of headphones I have the pair that get the most use is the Klipsch model that sells for about$200. They are not the best at blocking noise and they do not have the best sound but they really have a nice balance of being good enough at most things that they tend to get used more than any other pair I have. Their small profile makes wearing them for extended periods pleasant compared to the heavier Shure brand. The sound doesn't seem as good, and they don't block sound like the Shure but I find them more comfortable to wear and less of a hassle to put in my ear. If I am going on a long flight I pack the Bose over the ear headphones because they are more comfortable to me than any earbud.
Thank you!
Re: Ryobi TEC4
Stuart Johnson
I've gone with the Ryobi TEC4. They aren't 100 percent of what I want but they work well for both my wife and myself. When using our elliptical machine we watch Netflix stuff, unfortunately the TV we use doesn't have an output jack so the headset has to be plugged into the Roku with a set sound level. Turning the sound up on the tv allows the earphone mic to work well. Think they would work better when plugged into something with volume control.