Otterbox.
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
There is no other. I've been using the Otterbox Defender (the priciest) with my iPhone 4 for 2.5 years. I've swapped out the belt clip once (used my wife's old one, as she now has an iPhone 5).
I'm a painting contractor, but do a few other things as well, so I'm hard on my phones and their cases.
I'm right-handed, and I wear the phone on my left hip.
For Barry: I wear it with the phone upside-down (so that the loudspeaker/ringer is pointing up so I can more easily hear it in loud environments), screen towards my body, and the release clip towards the front. I can easily unclip it with my left hand (thumb on clip, forefinger around and below the clip, palm against the back of the phone), and as long as the case is in place on the phone and my shirt is out of the way, it will go back in the case with one hand also.
Jason