Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT Steel Tank Cutting

Posts

OT Steel Tank Cutting

#1

OT Steel Tank Cutting

Gary Smyth

After six months of waiting I finally got a call to pick up a 80# non-flammable gas steel tank. All its pressurized life it contained 90% helium, 7.5% argon, and 2.5% carbon dioxide. Never contained a flammable mix. I want to cut the bottom off to make a garden bell. I have here and will be willing to use anything from a hacksaw to a reciprocating saw to a plasma cutter. No portable band saw however. The valve has been removed with a hole in the top exposed to air. Eventually a eye bolt will be welded there as a place to hang the bell by a chain once the bottom is gone. I thought that I saw a bell here of a similar type.

I want to be safe which is why I waited for a non flammable gas shell. I'm looking for opinions in an effort to avoid/before I do something stupid. For example should I fill the bottle with crushed dry ice or water as I cut? Just checking for opinions, or a source to check with to be sure.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#2

Cut away...

John in NM

No more dangerous than cutting any other steel object.

Lacking a bandsaw or power hacksaw, I would probably start with an angle grinder and see how that goes.

Can't remember who had made one of those now, Jack Guzman maybe?

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#3

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

Thomas S Stockton

Gary

I've made a couple and used a jigsaw with a bimetal blade, drilled a hole first to fit the blade through. Worked great but it was noisy. I think using a plasma cutter would work great. I found that to mark the line wrapping a piece of heavy paper or card stock around the piece and marking it with a sharpie worked great. I used teeth from a mechanical tree harvester for the clanger. Here are pictures of some of mine. Two are old scuba tanks, the yellow one was emergency oxygen for a pilot and the one in back was a fire extinguisher which I think has the best sound.

Tom

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#4

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

Yonak

Gary, where did you go about obtaining one of those heavy bottles ? I've been asking around my town to get one but have been told they are not allowed, by law, to sell them to me. (It could be they are just saying that because they don't want any possible liability.) I have been able to get some old fire extinguisher bottles, but they don't produce the kind of "gong" I want.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#5

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Yonak, I'm not sure where you live, but here in Indiana, I can buy any tank I want from Thoroughbred gas company at Tractor Supply, Rural King etc. However these are "new or refurbished" tanks and are pretty expensive. I have 2 acetylene, 1 oxygen and one Argon/Co2. If I were you I would look at Craigslist, possibly any Welding supply houses, Scuba equipment suppliers - possibly talk to your local fire department to see if they have any old Air tanks. Another possibility is one of the old Freon tanks although they are pretty thin - I don't believe they are considered refillable so Air conditioning repair places (Automotive and or home) may have them. Other options may be old water pump tanks, Water heaters, air compressor tanks ---

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#6

Re: Steel Tank

Gary Smyth

Mine came from a welding supply house -- it is classified as scrap and not refillable. I must tell you I had a bunch of questions to answer as to why I wanted it, how was it to be used, he wanted to see my drivers license before he was ready to walk me out to the yard. He also told me that if it was a tank that formerly contained flammable gas he wouldn't let me have it. If you go searching be careful, apparently some gasses get absorbed into the metal and could be a problem with sparks even if empty. Oh. It is the policy of that yard for them not to load the tank in an enclosed car or van. Even empty and without a valve I had to lift it in on my own.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#7

Re: Steel Tank

Keith Newton

I have used an abrasive wheel on a circular saw for this, and it did a fine job, leaving a nice clean end. I've also used a low hook, triple-chip carbide on the aluminum extinguisher tanks on the circular saw as well.

Like someone else stated, rolling a poster-board around it, is the best way to mark the cut.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#8

OT - Steel Bottle Resonance

Yonak

I was able to procure a heavy tank which I will fashion as a garden bell, like Gary did. I have cut off the bottom. It has sort of a "clanky" sound, however it may be that once it's suspended and the sound is not deadened by setting it on a surface it may sound better.

..But my friend said he thinks these things have a natural vibration frequency achieved by matching the length of the bell by its wall thickness and by cutting it shorter I may get better resonance. My opinion is that resonance is achieved by matching the vibrations of two things, not one, and cutting it shorter will only raise the tone, not improve the tone quality. Does anyone have an opinion on this ?

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#9

Re: OT - Steel Bottle Resonance

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I made a copper pipe wind chime some years back, and found that the pipe resonated at all lengths but that the pitch changed as the length did.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#10

Re: OT - Steel Bottle Resonance *LINK*

Gary Smyth

The Acoustics of Bells

From the link. Worth a look even if you don't want to get through the whole thing (you most likely won't). To me it seems counterintuitive but according to the work "In all bells, enlarging the diameter lowers pitch, while a corresponding increase in thickness (and consequent rigidity) raises it." If you choose to go back to Chapter One it talks about "Bells of the Orient" which may help with a garden "bell".


http://www.msu.edu/~carillon/batmbook/chapter5.htm

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#11

Re: OT - Steel Bottle Resonance

Keith Newton

You have to suspend it, for it to vibrate freely. Sitting on a surface will deaden the vibration.

Re: OT Steel Tank Cutting

#12

Will the steel alloy make a difference?

Dick Coers

Harden steel plate will "ring" a lot different than mild steel. Don't know what those pressure tanks are made of, but assume it's better stuff than something to hold water. Just guessing here.