Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Might be the wrong forum for this...

Posts

Might be the wrong forum for this...

#1

Might be the wrong forum for this...

doug f, san clemente, ca

A friend of mine has a beautiful walnut burl she would like carved into a bowl. I've been told by a professional turner that because of shape of the piece, turning a bowl would not be possible, so this needs to be done by hand.

I have no desire to take on the task myself, I neither have the tools, the experience nor the time to tackle it.

Does anyone know someone who does this type of work and also, any idea what it might cost.

Thanks for any and all suggestions. I'm working on pictures of the burl. I post those as soon as I can.

Doug

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#2

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this... *LINK*

Larry Barrett

Drew Langsner, at Country Workshops, teaches bowl carving and does it. He might be able to help, or point you in a useful direction.


http://countryworkshops.org/Carving%20Large%20Bowls.html

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#3

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

Don Orr

I did a small yellow birch burl this summer with an Arbortech mini grinder with a Kutzall wheel and then used my angle drill/power sanding setup that I use for turning. It came out great and the customer was very pleased. It's not difficult, just time consuming and dusty. If I was closer I'd probably be willing to take a crack at it. Not a cheap job though. Several hours at an hourly rate plus materials like sanding discs and finishes.

I'm sure there is someone in your area that can easily do this. Contact a local woodturning or woodworking club.

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#4

Not me but curious...

Gary Smyth

can you post a picture of the burl? I'd like to see the size and try to figure why it could not be turned. Not saying it could be turned, but I'm curious.

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#5

Re: Not me but curious...

doug f, san clemente, ca

Picture's in the works.

Doug

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#6

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

doug f, san clemente, ca

I'm definitely going to get in touch with him. Thanks.

Doug

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#7

Re: Not me but curious... *LINK*

John Lucas

Yea I"m with Gary on this. Would love to see a photo. I haven't seen much that can't be turned in some fashion.

Back to the original fashion. You can carve a bowl using lots of tools. 24 grit sandpaper on a disc using an angle grinder will do bowls pretty darn fast and reasonably safe.

The Arbotec mini grinder is excellent and will reach into tighter places than the 24 grit paper.

I use the Lancelot chainsaw grinder because it was about 1/4 the price of the larger arbortec. It is a lot larger than the mini grinder so won't reach into tighter places.

My friend Brad Sells could easily do the work but I don't think he takes on any small commission jobs. See the link below for his work. I'm not interested in doing that work either since I am too busy doing my own work.


http://www.bradsells.com

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#8

Computer problem

doug f, san clemente, ca

I've got some nice pictures, but I'm having trouble making them small enough to post.

Working...

Doug

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#9

Finally, some pictures

doug f, san clemente, ca


Any reason this could not be turned?

Doug

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#10

Re: Finally, some pictures

Don Orr

It could probably be turned but you might not end up with much. This does not look like a true burl but instead it looks to be a healed over branch scar. There appears to be a fair amount of rot as well. The oblong shape could be a limiting factor also. I doubt I would turn it myself. Hard to tell if there is much sound, solid wood. Carving out with grinders and sanders as I mentioned previously might give you the results you are after though. Interesting piece of wood!

Re: Might be the wrong forum for this...

#11

Re: Finally, some pictures

Keith Newton

Doug, I don't much think that is a burl either. If not a limb scar, it may be a canker, neither of which is worth putting any effort into.

I can turn 7' diameter on my lathe, so that wouldn't be much of a challenge for it, but I suspect if you knock the bark off, you will find a small opening under that dark streak, which connects to the defects on the cut side. That of course would mean a bowl with a hole in the bottom, and uninteresting sapwood on the outside.