Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Deer rubbed tree

Posts

Deer rubbed tree

#1

Deer rubbed tree

Merle

Our local buck has rubbed this antlers on one of our aspen tree and rubbed the bark off one side. I saw a number of products that might save the tree. Does anyone have experience with any of these to recommend or pan any of them? Here is a link to one product and others are mentioned down the page. Thanks for any guidance you might provide.

http://www.amazon.com/Tree-Repair-Deer-Damage-Repellent/dp/B007R5P45C

Merle

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#2

Ellis Walentine

My 2¢ -- Bogus

Ellis Walentine

If the deer has rubbed the cambium off, no amount of cellophane tape is going to make this critical layer of tissue reappear. From what I've seen here in deer country, that area of the tree will cease to transmit sap and it will scab over. If it girdles the trunk, the tree's a goner.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#3

Re: Deer rubbed tree *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

The rubbed-off cambium will never be replaced. Trees seal the wound..animals heal...a very important distinction. No new tissue forms once the damage is done.

Next growing season the cambium that is on the edge of the wound will grow a layer and start to close the wound.

There has been scientific research done that shows merit for wrapping fresh wounds in some sort of water proof material...Saran wrap, tape, etc. Keeping insects, micro-organisms out and moisture in helps the tree's internal defenses. The catch...it has to be wrapped quickly, within 2-3 hours of wounding to have any good affect. After that the tree's CODIT responses have started.

The best cure for buck damage is lead poisoning...meted out in 30 caliber doses!

Tom...an arborist ;)


A New Tree Biology~~~ Dr. Alex Shigo

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Deer rubbed tree

Dale Lenz

Seriously, get you a friendly junk yard dog that loves to chase deer. Worked for me and a thousand + pine trees. When the dog died, started getting a few rubs.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#5

Question

John in NM

Keeping in mind that Merle and I live in NM, and we are in the midst of a severe drought, would some kind of sealer help at all? I've noticed the pinon trees have so little sap running that last summer I killed a couple just by pruning them - sap usually scabs over the cut limb.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#6

Wish I could,

Merle

but gun fire is illegal in my county. I am trying to find a bow hunter. However, even that has limitations. :(

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#7

Yup, that's the problem

Merle

Our dog died and we didn't want to get a replacement due to travel. We may need to rethink that. :)

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#8

Really?

John in NM

I would expect restrictions due to the residential area, but not county wide, that's almost un-heard of... are you in Bernalillo county or Torance?

I realize the discussion is less than serious of course, but I don't think deer qualify for nuisance management :D :D :D I could find a lot of nuisance around my place if they did!

One thing you could try is planting a section of telephone pole somewhere near by. Give them something else to rub antlers on.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#9

I could be wrong

Merle

since I am not a native New Mexican, but that is what I was told or read. I just checked the Bernalillo county website, but couldn't find anything related to firearms. I will have to try a little harder. Maybe it was just during the summer when there was a fire warning in effect.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#10

Ahhhh.... fire danger, that was it...

John in NM

I remember that last summer, Forest Service closed most of the National Forests in AZ and NM to any kinds of activities that could cause fires. Could be Bernalillo and other counties followed suit.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#11

won't work.....

Bill Tindall

....at least for eastern deer. They are very picky about what they rub on. I have never seen one rub on anything dead. Cedar and smooth barked trees are preferred here, as well as anything planted in a yard.

There are two times they rub- to remove velvet and when they have does on the brain.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#12

Not surprising...

John in NM

That would be just too convenient :D

Our goat would butt his horns on cactus before we had him neutered. Of course for him it was the second reason, not the first :D He doesn't do it any more, or any of those other annoying goaty habits.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#13

Re: Question---answer

Tom Dunlap

Trees have evolved over the past millenium to take pretty good care of themselves. Since they can't get up and move away from pests and damage they are self-sufficient when it comes to isolating damage.

Think of how a tree grows. Every year it replicates itself from bud tip to trunk. We all know about growth rings...better called increments. That's the new tree every year. If damage occurs today the damage is there forever. Next spring the tree's cambium will grow another layer to replicate itself. At the edges of the wound a bit more tissue will generate to create a wall. After X seasons the tree will grow over the wound and start to create single, continuous layers of clear tissues.

Within minutes of wounding the tree's systems react and start to generate chemicals to isolate the wound. In time the tree will generate tissues..b ut that takes a while.

Dr. Alex Shigo who is the Father of Modern Arborculture started his research with the USFS trying to find the best wound dressing. What he found years later was taht the trees take care of themselves. The tree paints and glop that we put on them either don't do any good or actually cause more damage. Some of the decay microorganisms thrive on the stuff that we think/thought worked.

Obviously, I could blather on and on...but, by now I'm sure that it's 'glassy-eyed' time.

If you're interested in tree decay...search on "Dr. Alex Shigo" or "CODIT"

Tom

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#14

Interesting, thanks!

John in NM

I think rather than attempting to seal cut limbs on pinons, I'll just refrain from pruning them up when its been really dry.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#15

Re: Interesting, thanks!

Tom Dunlap

If they're dead cut them anytime.

Just be careful to cut at the edge of the branch collar/live wood. If you nick the live wood you will have made a new wound that the tree has to isolate which leads to more decay.

Tom

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#16

Not glassy eyed here!

Don Orr

I always find your post interesting and informative. Keep 'em coming! I enjoyed the link to the article very much. I probably should have been an arborist. I didn't even know what it was when I was in college. My degree is in general biology so all kinds of things interest me. I have a nephew who is a certified arborist down in NC.

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#17

Re: Not glassy eyed here!

Tom Dunlap

Hi Don,

Thanks :) If you want to learn more about how trees become 'lumber' let me know.

In August I moved to Asheville to take a job as the foreman of the arborist crew at Biltmore Estate. This is as close to a perfect job as I could ever ask. I get to work in a tree museum everyday. This is similar to doing commercial treework but we only have two clients. One is the Biltmore Estate and the other are the Guests.

Many of the trees we work on were originally planted under Olmestead or his Head Gardner, Chauncey Beadle just over a hundred years ago. There are some trees growing here that are rare or on endangered species list.

I'm a Certified Arborist too. There's a good chance that your nephew and I might know each other. For sure, we'll have friends in common!

Tom

Re: Deer rubbed tree

#18

Re: Not glassy eyed here!

Don Orr

Awesome news on the new job! You must be like a kid in a candy store with all those cool trees.

Thanks for posting your links and sharing your knowledge.

My nephew is in Wake Forest area and works for Bartlett. He's from up here in NY and worked for a few years at a very large private estate that is building a huge native plant "garden" to the tune of several hundred acres. He has some great stories from there.

I'm a bit of a tree-hugger but from more of a conservation aspect.