Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

Posts

OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#1

JL

OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

JL

We've got a 40 gallon electric. We do have propane supplied to the house for our furnace and our gas logs. The hot water heater might be original - which means it's probably 17 years old.

Anyway - I'm seeing a little corrosion around the relief valve. I'd rather replace it earlier than later - as I don't want my tools in the shop getting wet!

We have Lowes, Home Depot and City Plumbing and Electric - which means Whirlpool, GE + Marathon and Bradford White.

We've 2.5 bathrooms - but only two people. I've looked at the plate - it says 4500 W. The breaker panel has a twin 30 amp breaker. So - we could possibly put in a 2.2 GPM Rheem Tankless - but we'd have to seriously upgrade the electrical to put in anything larger. I don't think a tankless would work with our cold water in the winter.

I'm leaning towards a 40-50 gallon tank. Probably a 12 year. GE or Whirlpool. Opinions?

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#2

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

Barry Irby

Investigate the GE Heat Pump water heater. Uses 545 watts of power unless there is a heavy demand and then the 4500 watt elements kick in. Saw one demonstrated at one of my Home Inspector meetings and was impressed. About

$1200 but very efficient and it comes with a 10 Year warranty.

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#3

JL

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

JL

I am ashamed to say - this space also contains the litter boxes. It is also next to my shop. Maybe a bit too dust for that.

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#4

Space use

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I am ashamed to say - this space also contains the litter boxes."

Hey: they have to go somewhere. Ours are in the laundry room, right off the kitchen, which sometimes means a rather aromatic kitchen (one of our cats, particularly, could serve very effectively as an airborne chemical weapon).

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#5

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

Pete in Holland, MI

Why would you want to heat hot water?

They are not "hot water heaters". They are either "water heaters" or more specifically, "cold water heaters".

Falls in the same category as PIN number, VIN number, unthaw,.......

: )

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#6

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

Ken Garlock North Texas

Good Morning JL. When we built back in 2002, I researched hot water tanks along with everyting else in the house. I found that the Reem Marathon is the best, for two reasons. One, it has a fiberglass thank that is guaranteed for as long as you have it. Second it has R19 insulation. I am happy with it and would buy it again without hesitating. Yes, they are expensive, but it is the last water heater you will need to buy.

Happy saw dust,

Ken

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#7

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

bud

Just my 2 cents. Since you have propane on site I'd propane tankless supposed to be a lot cheaper.

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#8

I like Marathon's too...

John in NM

Amazingly well insulated units. Element wattage is almost irrelevant with these because they hold heat so well.

Just make sure you get one 20% over your expected volume demand though, I had 3 units fail where the plastic tank is glued to the side ports. All I can figure is that the cause was frequent temp cycling of a just big enough unit. So if you figure you need a 40 gallon, get a 50 instead. They were very good about waranty though, I only paid for one :D

Re: OT - Hot water heater - possibly going

#9

JL

Thanks for the responses

JL

Got an estimate from a plumber for a tankless install. Let it suffice to say that I'd rather not spend that. It also turns out that the yearly energy cost between a propane tankless and an ordinary water heater isn't that different. The cost of propane and the delivery charges in our area don't make it that cost competitive in terms of heating water.

The Whirlpool 50 gallon energy save water heater looks to have the best reviews, the best warranty (except for the Marathon) and a reasonable energy cost. I can put in a Whirlpool for under $600. It would cost me over $1000 for the Marathon. The LOML and I will talk further on getting the Marathon as opposed to the Whirlpool. GE is pretty much out of the picture. The reviews are not positive. Bradford White is builder grade - inexpensive and low in longevity.

So - I'm leaning strongly towards a 50 gallon Whirlpool (followed by a 50 gallon Marathon).