Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Posts

INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#1

INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Galen Vetterick

Mark at Incra did offer to send me a new miter bar or plastic discs on a second email, but I was able to finally make what I had work.

The bar has a small taper above the screw threads. I increased the depth, as I could see a polish line where the screw lower taper was hitting. This gave more screw engagement. I then polished the milled steel surface and the mating bottom of the plastic ring so they could slide, over just bitting in under clamping pressure. I then put a light oil on the mating bar and disc surfaces, plastic ring taper and screw threads. Located the slot in the disc where it just kissed the side opening (about 2 o'clock).

This combination along with some moderate applied torque to the screw I got the gauge to fit my miter track!

A new bar and or disc might have been nice but it is also nice when you can adapt and make things work. Still like the idea of the two sets of disc on opposite sides like the addendum Mark sent, that must be for the standard long miter bars.

Thanks Mark Mueller.

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#2

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Glad things worked out!

I'd hate to see the gold anodizing get tarnished! The I-BOX got another accolade- In addition to the Wood Magazine Innov-8 award for 2012 and #2 on the NewWoodworker dot net list of Top 10 Tools list for 2012, Woodcraft also selected it as one of their Top Tools for 2012!

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#3

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Dick Coers

Those tool review guys must have narrower miter gage slots than some folks that are actually using them have. With two people on WC having to reach out to find out how to make it work, I'm not too impressed.

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#4

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

It is the nature of the beast when you try to design a tool to fit "all." Just ask someone who has an old Sears or Shopsmith what kinds of trouble they have buying accessories that will fit their miter slot. The slot on the old Sears like Galen has is close, but the old (and current?) Shopsmith miter slot width is totally different and requires a special bar.

The manufacturer has to decide if the numbers make it worthwhile to manufacture two size bars, provide special milling services, or come up with another solution. The costs to make limited runs of special parts is high.

As an example of other things that can happen. We made a spreadsheet of blade-to-miter-slot spacing. We thought we had them all, except for one or two small benchtop saws like the little Skil, that didn't even have standard width miter slots, so were intentionally avoided. It was only after the I-BOX had been on the market for a number of months that we learned there was an old Jet with wider spacing. As a result, the factory immediately changed the milling code to make the mounting slot longer to accommodate that one model of saw. That was an easy fix, others are not so.

I don't know what would impress you, but there may be as many as 5000 I-BOXes in the hands of woodworkers now (I don't have the numbers), and if there have only been a few problems, I'd say that is pretty darn good!

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Alan,

I have a Shop Fox cabinet saw, and the slot is dead-on 0.750". My (early production) iBox's bar dropped right in, and was perfectly adjusted in about thirty seconds. Sometimes, thing really do work "as planned."

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#6

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Dick Coers

What really doesn't impress me is when we get what are basically commercials for products without disclaimers or permission from Ellis. A guy comes on and asks about making a jig, and gets swamped with folks telling him that he should buy the latest wiz bang jig. He gets the jig, and basically can't use it. Then we get a nice promotional response that tells us about all the awards the jig is getting. The promotional awards response has nothing to do with helping him use the jig, or him cutting finger joints. Just my grouchy opinion of course. I come on here for discussions, not sales pitches.

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#7

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Based on the OP's original box joint post and from my extensive research, few if any DIY box joint jigs would meet his criteria. I suggested the I-BOX and a number of folks agreed with me and they stated why.

I monitor a number of forums, and find that the power of the INTERNET is both good and bad. One unhappy customer who posts can easily outweigh hundreds of happy customers who don't. I try to help whenever I can, and you will see in this case the manufacturer was very responsive and accommodating- the president of the company and his technical assistance person both contacted the OP. How many WW companies do that?. The issue and the company's response are two data points that might be of interest to potential customers.

In many of my earlier posts I have stated that I came up with the design and licensed it to INCRA. I don't hide that, and am proud of it. I don't know how you can state the facts about something without sounding like a sales pitch when they are positive and true. I don't see that it is much different than many of the posts by the legions Festool or Sawstop owners. As to the awards, that is just fact.

Finally, the I-BOX is sold by at least four or more of Wood Central's paid advertisers, but it's Ellis' railroad so he can delete my posts if chooses.

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

#8

Re: INCRA I-Box Jig resolution

Henry Higginbotham

Dick, I was one of those who recommended Galen have a look at the I-Box. I don't see that as a "commercial." He asked for advice, and I told him about my experience. I've built and used a jig of the sort he inquired about, and I've since bought and used the I-Box and found it to work as claimed. I offered him photos of my jig, along with the opinion that no shop-built jig would match the accuracy or convenience of the store-bought model. Buyer's choice.

Many tools don't work perfectly right out of the box (or crate), but not always by fault of the tool. Miter slots, particularly Craftsman, are well known for variability. It took a bit of backing off and looking at the situation on Galen's part, but he got it to work correctly and I'd bet that he'll be happy with the results.