Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

Posts

Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#1

Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

Doug Ridley

Gonna have to buy a new drill or new batteries one. I would like to know what is the diff. btw Lithium and Ni-cad as far as the user is concerned. I can actually buy a new Lithium powered drill w/ 2 batteries cheaper than I can get the old Ni-cad batteries rebuilt. (I will also get another flashlight to throw away).

I don't care about the tech. diff., just as far as using. And before you answer, no I don't want to rebuild the old Ni-cads myself.

Doug

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#2

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

Bill Tindall

Suggestion: what ever batteries you buy they will die. If you buy "Rigid" at Home Depot the batteries are guaranteed for life. When, not if, they die you return them to Home Depot and they are rebuilt or replaced, free. Son-in law just picked up an 18V drill and impact driver for $178.

One problem in comparing is that there is a large range in quality in either battery chemistry depending on the manufacturer. But there are some generic comparisons that are valid regardless of who and how the battery was made.

When people afforded the sophisticated charger essential to preserve the life of a NiCad battery this was an excellent battery chemistry. Pace makers powered by this battery type lasted for decades. Environmental fanatics didn't like them because they contained cadmium, a compound "know the state of CA" to do/cause something or another.

The lithium ion battery has a higher energy density than NiCad. Li ion batteries come with charging and discharging management electronics as part of the package. They shut down before fully discharging or charging which promotes longer life. NiCad battery life depends strongly on the details of how they are charged which depends on the sophistication of the charger and the patience of the owner for slow charging has a strong affect on promoting battery life. There are numerous other differences that could be relevant- self discharge rate, performance at high or low temperatures, recharge cycles to failure, etc. Overall the li-ion battery is preferred for tool application. But it is unlikely that you can buy a NiCad powered tool now days so these factors may be irrelevant.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#3

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

R Payne

Having used both - if you don't want to talk technical - the biggest, most noticeable difference is weight. Li-ion is lighter. The other differences can vary depending on the particular battery cells in the battery, some are better than others.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#4

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lithium-ion batteries can sit on the shelf for weeks and still be ready to go. A Ni-Cad battery, sitting on the shelf, will slowly lose its charge. If you cycle through battery charge frequently, this is not a big deal, but for an occasionally-used tool, the Lithium-Ion battery's a lot nicer.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#5

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

BilWil

If you work outside in the cold the LIthium will loose power in the cold. Have to keep them warm. If it is windy they can loose power very quickly on a roof.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#6

delf discharge

Bill Tindall

all batteries self discharge. The best in this regard are the silver oxide button batteries. As you report in general a lithium ion battery holds its charge better than NiCd.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#7

batteries and temperature

Bill Tindall

All batteries suffer a drop in voltage as the temperature is lower. This is why you car doesn't start as robustly in MN in the winter. Your 12 V battery may only be 10V on a cold day plus its internal resistance increases. Li-ion and NiCd are about the same when it comes to the lessening of voltage as the temperature drops. More important, batter life is greatly shortened when they are either charged or discharged at either hot or cold temperatures. However, storing cold prolongs battery life and charge retention.

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#8

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

NickinMass

Go with the new drill and batteries. You didn't say what your level of use will be, but if you're anything like me, my cordless drill can sit for weeks/months (depending on kids/work) between uses. Li-ion has lower self-discharge and there isn't a memory problem (so you can top up a partially discharged battery). I've had the same Panasonic drill (with the original batteries) for at least 10 yrs now and they still work (don't have the run time they used to, but then neither do I).

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

#9

Re: Lithium vs Ni-cad difference

Doug Ridley

I am going with the Lithium. Thanks for all the replies.

Doug